11/24/2025
Analysis of Papua New Guinea's National Debt
The video displays a screen recording from an application that tracks the National Debt of Papua New Guinea (PNG), expressed in Papua New Guinean Kina (PGK).
The key features and trends highlighted are:
1. Debt Magnitude and Real-Time Increase
Current Debt Figure: The video opens with the national debt at approximately 67.938 billion PGK and shows it rapidly increasing in real-time. This dynamic display emphasizes the continuous accrual of debt.
Currency: The debt is measured in Billions of Papua New Guinean Kina (PGK).
2. Debt Trend Over Time (1980 - 2027)
The line graph shows a clear and dramatic trend of increasing national debt since 1980.
Pre-2000s: The debt was relatively stable and low, hovering around 3 to 8 billion PGK through the 1980s, 1990s, and early 2000s.
Example data points: 1995: 3.3 PGK, 2000: 5.4 PGK.
Post-2010 Acceleration: The debt begins to accelerate around 2010 and then shows a very steep, almost exponential, increase starting around 2014-2016.
Example data points: 2014: 11.9 PGK, 2016: 18 PGK.
Recent and Projected Sharp Rise (2020s): The most significant surge is shown from 2020 onwards, with the debt rapidly approaching the 80 Billion PGK mark. The application notes that "Values after 2024 are estimated."
Key data points shown on the graph:
2021: 40.2 PGK (Billion)
2023: 53.7 PGK (Billion)
2024: 59.6 PGK (Billion) (Estimated)
2025: 63.3 PGK (Billion) (Estimated)
2027: 72.1 PGK (Billion) (Estimated)
3. Conclusion of the Visual Data
The video's primary message, based on the visual data, is that the national debt of Papua New Guinea has been growing rapidly in recent years and is projected to continue this sharp upward trajectory through at least 2027. The most notable feature is the acceleration of the debt-to-GDP ratio (or total debt) since the mid-2010s.
💰 Economic Context & Currency Conversion
The video shows the debt at approximately PGK 67.938 Billion.
To provide a snapshot of this figure in US Dollars (USD), we'll use a widely referenced forecast for the Papua New Guinean Kina (PGK) exchange rate.
Current Debt (from Video): $\text{PGK } 67,938,000,000$ (approx.)
Approximate Exchange Rate: $\text{1 PGK } \approx \text{ 0.26 USD}$ (This is an approximation based on recent market rates as of late 2024/early 2025.)
Converted Debt in USD: $\text{PGK } 67.938 \text{ Billion} \times 0.26 \approx \text{USD } 17.66 \text{ Billion}$
Conclusion on Magnitude:
The national debt of Papua New Guinea stands at approximately $68 \text{ billion Kina}$ or around $17.7 \text{ billion US Dollars}$.
📉 Drivers of the Sharp Debt Increase (Post-2014)
The steep, upward curve in the video's graph, which begins around 2014-2016, is largely attributed to a combination of external shocks, economic vulnerabilities, and persistent fiscal deficits:
1. Global Commodity Price Decline (Post-2014)
The Shock: PNG's economy is heavily dependent on resource exports (oil, gas, minerals). The global commodity price slump that followed the initial boom years (like the one after the PNG LNG project completion in 2014) led to a sustained drop in government revenue between 2012 and 2019.
The Result: The government ran large fiscal deficits (spending more than it earned), which were financed by borrowing, causing the public debt to double in that period.
2. External Shocks and Natural Disasters
Compounding Factors: PNG faced several major shocks that required government spending and lowered revenue:
A severe drought in 2015-2016.
A major earthquake in 2018 (requiring reconstruction costs).
The COVID-19 pandemic in 2020-2021, leading to a massive, pandemic-induced deficit.
3. Financing and Structural Issues
FX Shortages: Ongoing foreign exchange (FX) shortages have hampered private sector development and worsened economic conditions.
Weak Expenditure Control: Government expenditure, particularly the salary bill (wages for public servants), has been historically difficult to control, often exceeding appropriations and contributing to deficits.
Costly Domestic Borrowing: Historically, PNG has relied on domestic borrowing, which often carries higher interest costs than external, concessional loans (though this composition has been shifting recently).
🎯 PNG's Medium-Term Fiscal Plan (2025 - 2027)
While the video's graph shows a continued increase in the nominal Kina value of the debt through 2027, external reports (such as the 2025 Budget documents) suggest a change in the debt-to-GDP ratio is the key focus:
Debt-to-GDP Goal: The government has an ambitious 13-year Fiscal Repair Plan aiming to reduce the debt-to-GDP ratio from its recent peak of over 50%. The plan aims to bring the ratio back down towards the legal limit of 40% and below 60%.
Budget Surplus Target: The government aims to achieve a budget surplus by 2027, which would be the first since 2010.
Financing Shift: PNG is increasingly prioritizing concessional external financing (cheaper loans from institutions like the World Bank, ADB, and IMF) over costly domestic borrowing to help manage interest payments and reduce debt distress risk.
In summary, the video accurately reflects the high nominal value of PNG's debt and its dramatic recent increase, which is a result of structural fiscal deficits and commodity price shocks. Current government forecasts, however, suggest that if their fiscal consolidation plan is successful, the debt relative to the size of the economy (GDP) should begin to stabilize or decline after 2025.
⛏️ Status of Key Resource Projects in PNG
1. Porgera Gold Mine (Reopened)
Status: Officially Reopened and undergoing recommissioning.
Timeline:
The mine closed in April 2020 following a lease dispute.
The new project commencement agreement was finalized in December 2023.
Recommissioning began immediately, with the goal for mining and processing to fully restart operations in the first quarter of 2024.
Economic Impact: The mine is projected to become a Tier One gold asset, with PNG stakeholders receiving 53% of the overall economic benefits (estimated to exceed $7 billion USD over the mine's life). Its return to production is essential for boosting gold output and government tax revenue, which is a major factor in the debt-to-GDP outlook.
2. Papua LNG Project
Status: Awaiting Final Investment Decision (FID), but moving forward.
Timeline: This is the second major LNG development after PNG LNG. While regulatory processes have caused delays, analysts anticipate the FID to be reached around 2026.
Economic Impact: The project, led by TotalEnergies, has an estimated capital expenditure of around $12 billion USD. Once FID is achieved and construction begins, it will trigger a massive wave of foreign direct investment, employment, and service sector growth, which is central to the country's long-term economic expansion and capacity to manage its debt.
3. Wafi-Golpu Copper-Gold Project
Status: Awaiting key regulatory approvals (the Special Mining Lease).
Timeline: The project is a joint venture between Newcrest (now Newmont) and Harmony Gold. It is anticipated to commence construction in the same timeframe as Papua LNG, potentially around 2026, once the necessary agreements are finalized.
Economic Impact: This is a world-class copper and gold deposit. Its commencement would further diversify PNG's resource exports, providing a long-term stream of high-value revenue that directly supports the government's fiscal repair plans.
Summary of Impact on Debt
The increasing debt shown in your video through 2027 reflects the current borrowing required to sustain government operations while waiting for these multi-billion-dollar resource projects to come online. The government's confidence in achieving a budget surplus by 2027 (as mentioned in the previous analysis) is explicitly hinged upon the tax and revenue flows from the Porgera mine's restart and the start of the massive construction phase for the Papua LNG project.
🎯 PNG's Medium-Term Fiscal Targets (2025-2027)
The government's strategy is based on an ambitious 13-year Budget Repair and Reconstruction Plan (introduced in the 2022 Budget) with clear, quantifiable goals:
1. Deficit Reduction Goal
This is the most critical metric for debt control, measuring the difference between government spending and revenue.
2020 (Peak Deficit): $8.9\%$ of GDP (due to COVID-19 and structural issues).
2025 (Target Deficit): Projected to fall to $2.2\%$ of GDP (a significant, sustained reduction).
2027 (Ultimate Goal): Achieve a Budget Surplus (spending less than revenue), which would be the first since 2010.
2. Debt-to-GDP Ratio Targets
While the nominal Kina debt (shown in the video) continues to increase to fund the deficits, the plan aims to control the debt relative to the size of the economy.
2025 (Projected Peak): Debt is projected to be around PGK 64.9 Billion, which is about $47.4\%$ of GDP.
Medium-Term Target (2028): Reduce the ratio to below $40\%$ of GDP.
Long-Term Goal (2034): The plan includes an aspirational target of repaying all government debt by 2034.
⚖️ Debt Financing Strategy (2025)
The government is actively managing how it finances its deficit to minimize risk and cost, adhering to a Medium-Term Debt Strategy (MTDS 2024-2028):
Financing Source
2025 Financing Mix
Strategy Goal
External Concessional
Prioritized (K2.1 Billion projected)
Prioritize low-cost, long-term loans from multilateral institutions (ADB, World Bank, IMF) to lower overall interest payments.
Domestic Borrowing
Reduced (K0.86 Billion projected)
Lessen reliance on short-term instruments (Treasury Bills) to mitigate rollover risk and develop a deeper, more liquid domestic debt market.
Debt Composition
FX debt $< 50\%$ of total debt
Maintain a balanced mix of domestic and foreign currency debt to manage exchange rate risk.
The Role of the Non-Resource Sector
While the resource projects (Porgera, Papua LNG) are vital for the major revenue boost, the government's fiscal plan is also counting on a robust non-resource sector.
Projected Non-Resource Growth (2025): $5.2\%$
Driving Factor: The agriculture, forestry, and fishery (AFF) sector is expected to grow by about $3.0\%$, fueled by increased production of crops like cocoa and palm oil, and is recognized as the key to creating jobs, reducing poverty, and diversifying the economy away from its heavy dependence on the volatile resource sector.
In summary, the steep debt increase seen in the video has been recognized, and the government's strategy is a determined, multi-year effort to use future resource revenues and growth in the non-resource sector to significantly reduce the deficit and stabilize the debt-to-GDP ratio.
🌿 Potential of the Agricultural Sector
Agriculture, forestry, and fisheries are the lifeline for over 85% of Papua New Guinea's population, who primarily live in rural areas. The potential for growth is significant and focuses on high-value cash crops and domestic food security.
1. Major Export Crops
PNG produces world-renowned crops that can fetch premium prices on the international market:
Palm Oil: PNG's largest agricultural export by value, often produced on plantations.
Coffee: Mainly Arabica coffee from the Highlands, often fetching premium prices for its quality. Nearly 70% of production comes from over 250,000 village households, making it a crucial source of cash income.
Cocoa: Highly regarded for its flavor profile, with production increasing, largely driven by smallholders. Cocoa is often intercropped with coconuts to share costs and reduce disease risk.
Other High-Value Exports: Vanilla and Coconut products also offer significant potential for expanded production and value-added processing.
2. Role in National Development
The sector is not just about exports; it is foundational to domestic stability:
Food Security: It supplies the majority of food for the population, though malnutrition remains a serious issue (around 50% of children under five are stunted).
Economic Diversification: It is the government's best chance to create sustainable, non-resource-based GDP growth to smooth out the cyclical ups and downs of the minerals sector.
Livelihoods: It provides a direct livelihood for the vast majority of the population, reducing poverty and improving community stability.
🚧 Key Challenges Hindering Growth
The biggest hurdles in scaling up the agricultural sector are structural and infrastructural, directly affecting farmers' ability to get products to market:
Challenge
Impact on Farmers & Economy
Inadequate Infrastructure
Poor road networks (often unusable in rainy seasons) make transporting perishable goods extremely difficult and costly, leading to significant post-harvest losses and lower prices for farmers.
Land Tenure Issues
The customary land tenure system makes it challenging for investors to secure the large, long-term leases required for major commercial farming operations, limiting foreign investment.
Limited Access to Finance
Farmers and small businesses (SMEs) struggle to access credit and financing to invest in improved seeds, processing equipment, and better farming techniques.
Lack of Extension Services
There is a general absence of effective government extension services to provide farmers with advice, research, and high-yielding, disease-resistant planting materials.
Value-Addition Gap
Most high-value crops (cocoa, coffee) are exported as raw beans or copra. A lack of modern in-country processing facilities means PNG misses out on the significant profit margins from turning them into chocolate, roasted coffee, or refined oils.
The World Bank emphasizes that unlocking this potential requires boosting smallholder productivity, prioritizing investments in agro-logistics and infrastructure (like the government's Connect PNG road plan), and creating a more favorable environment for private investment.
🛣️ The Connect PNG Program (2020-2040)
The Connect PNG program is Papua New Guinea's most ambitious and transformative infrastructure initiative, envisioned as a 20-year commitment to transform the country's transport landscape.
Key Goals and Scope
Duration: 20 years (2020–2040).
Total Network Target: Develop and maintain over 16,000 km of roads, including national highways and new "Missing Link" roads.
Ultimate Vision: Achieve 100% road connectivity across all provinces and districts by 2040.
Funding Commitment: The program is underpinned by the Connect PNG (Implementation and Funding Arrangements) Act 2021, which commits a minimum of 5.6% of the annual national budget to the program, aiming for a total investment of K20 billion over its lifetime.
Impact on the Agricultural Sector
Connect PNG directly tackles the two biggest challenges facing rural farmers: access to markets and high transport costs.
Connecting Farms to Markets:
The program prioritizes "Economic Corridors" and "Missing Links" to connect previously isolated agricultural areas (like the Highlands and Sepik regions) to major ports (Lae and Port Moresby).
Reduced Post-Harvest Losses: Improved roads drastically cut down the time required to transport perishable goods (like fresh produce and vegetables), reducing spoilage and ensuring higher quality reaches the consumer.
Lowering the Cost of Business:
By reducing travel time and vehicle wear-and-tear (which is currently among the highest in the world), Connect PNG aims to deliver significant savings in vehicle operating costs. This makes agricultural products more globally competitive.
Facilitating Service Delivery:
Better roads enable easier access for agricultural extension officers (to provide training and resources) and allow the transport of essential inputs like fertilizers and equipment back to the farms. The program is specifically designed to integrate and support other sectors like rural electrification and health services.
Flagship Projects (Phase 1: 2020–2027)
The first phase is focusing on high-impact projects that directly link major economic hubs:
Trans-Island Highway: The highly anticipated project to create an all-weather road connection between the industrial hub of Lae and the capital, Port Moresby, which is expected to be completed around the country's 50th Independence Anniversary.
Missing Links: The construction of new roads that close critical geographical gaps, such as linking Gulf Province and the Highlands, allowing inland provinces access to the sea.
In essence, Connect PNG is the long-term investment that converts PNG's natural agricultural and mineral wealth into tangible economic activity by making internal logistics viable, thereby supporting the government's ambitious goal to reduce the national debt-to-GDP ratio through expanded revenue.
Connect PNG Program's 20-year National Road Network Development Plan.
Opens in a new window www.pngbusinessnews.com
The map illustrates the ambitious plan to connect all four regions of Papua New Guinea (Momase, Highlands, Southern, and New Guinea Islands) by linking key strategic corridors and completing the critical "Missing Link" roads.
🇵🇬 Analysis of Papua New Guinea's Demographic Development Challenges
Papua New Guinea (PNG) faces profound development challenges driven by its unique and rapidly evolving demography. The core issues stem from a high population growth rate, a pronounced youth bulge, rapid but unmanaged urbanization, and persistent rural-urban disparities.
1. Rapid Population Growth and Youth Bulge
PNG's population structure is characterized by an expansive pyramid, signifying a young and rapidly growing population, which acts as a major brake on development progress.
High Growth Rate: The national annual population growth rate is high, estimated at around 2.5% to 2.7%. At this rate, the population, currently around 11 million, is projected to double by 2050.
Youth Bulge: Over one-third (33% to 40%) of the population is under the age of 15. The median age is extremely low (around 22.8 to 23.8 years). This "youth bulge" creates massive pressures:
Education Demand: There is an overwhelming demand for new schools and teachers. High dropout rates and insufficient classroom capacity mean many children are excluded from basic education.
Employment Crisis: The number of young people entering the workforce far outstrips the formal sector's capacity to create jobs, resulting in high rates of youth unemployment and limited opportunities for skill development.
High Dependency Ratio: The large proportion of non-working-age dependents (children) puts a significant financial and resource strain on the working-age population and the government's budget for social services.
2. Strain on Services and Human Capital
The rapid population growth, combined with limited government capacity and rugged geography, has led to a decline in per capita service delivery across the country.
Health and Sanitation: PNG has one of the highest maternal mortality rates in the region. Health clinics are often under-resourced, lack electricity or refrigeration, and are insufficient in number to meet demand. Widespread issues with unsafe water and sanitation contribute to high rates of communicable diseases (like malaria and diarrhea).
Infrastructure Deficit: Infrastructure (roads, electricity, water, sewerage) has deteriorated due to poor maintenance and the increased demand from a rising population. This lack of infrastructure severely hinders economic activity and access to essential services, particularly in rural areas.
Gender-Based Violence (GBV): PNG remains a place where over 1.5 million people experience GBV annually, a crisis often compounded by weak law enforcement and a lack of support services. 15 High rates of child marriage further restrict girls' rights and educational attainment.
3. Unmanaged Urbanization and Informal Settlements
Despite over 85% of the population living in rural areas, the rate of migration from rural to urban centers is high, often exceeding the national growth rate. This rapid urban influx creates distinct challenges:
Informal Settlements (Squatter Settlements): The failure of the government to provide affordable, formal housing and service infrastructure has led to the proliferation of large informal settlements. These areas are characterized by:
Lack of basic services (water, sanitation, electricity).
Overcrowded living conditions.
Increased security and crime issues.
Urban Poverty and Unemployment: Many migrants arrive with limited formal skills, leading to intense competition for few formal jobs and exacerbating urban poverty. The social problems in cities are directly related to the disparity between population growth and job creation.
Governance and Planning: Urban growth is often uncontrolled due to dysfunctional governance structures, corruption, a lack of clear land-use planning, and the complicated nature of land ownership (customary vs. state land).
4. Cultural and Governance Complexities
PNG's extreme cultural and linguistic diversity (over 800 languages) and its fragmented, decentralized governance system further complicate development efforts.
Sub-National Allegiance: Most citizens retain a stronger allegiance and trust in their sub-national groups (clans, wantoks) than in the national government, which can lead to friction and instability.
Decentralized Confusion: The complex system of multiple tiers and levels of government (National, Provincial, District, LLG) often results in overlapping responsibilities and confusion over who is accountable for service delivery, making effective policy implementation difficult.
These demographic pressures—driven by high fertility and a young age structure—are outpacing the country's development progress, creating a constant struggle to provide basic services and opportunities for its rapidly expanding population.
💔 The Vicious Cycle: GBV and Poverty in PNG
PNG has one of the highest rates of gender-based violence in the world, with over two-thirds of women estimated to experience physical or sexual violence in their lifetime. This violence is not merely a social issue; it has profound, measurable economic costs that trap women, families, and the nation in poverty.
1. How GBV Drives Poverty
Lost Productivity and Earnings: Violence leads to physical injury, chronic pain, and mental health issues (like PTSD), causing women to miss work, lose their jobs, or reduce their productivity in the informal sector (agriculture, markets). This results in lost household income.
Health Costs: Victims require medical treatment, counseling, and legal support. These direct costs drain the already limited resources of poor households, potentially pushing them further into debt.
Intergenerational Impact: Children living in violent households often experience poor nutritional status, are forced to drop out of school, or face abuse themselves. This restricts the next generation's human capital, preventing them from escaping poverty.
Restricted Economic Participation: The pervasive threat of violence, including on the way to or from markets, limits a woman's mobility and participation in the economy, especially in rural areas.
2. How Poverty Aggravates GBV
Resource Competition: Economic downturns, high unemployment, and poverty can create stress and tension within households. The scarcity of resources is often cited as a trigger for violence, as men may feel a loss of control or be unable to fulfill traditional provider roles.
Extractives and Cash Influx: Ironically, sudden resource wealth from mining or gas projects can also increase tensions and violence if the benefits (jobs, money) flow predominantly to men. This shift in power can lead to men spending cash on vices or taking second wives, causing conflict in the home.
Lack of Recourse: Poor women in remote areas have limited access to formal justice, police, or health services. This means perpetrators are rarely held accountable, reinforcing a culture of impunity and perpetuating the cycle of violence.
📊 Government Policy on Demographic Management
The PNG government recognizes that the high growth rate (around 2.6% annually) and the resulting youth bulge will continue to outpace economic growth and undermine development efforts unless actively managed.
1. The National Population Policy (NPP) 2015-2024
The current policy framework aims to accelerate the Demographic Transition—the shift from high birth/death rates to low birth/death rates—to allow PNG to reap a "Demographic Dividend."
Focus Shift: The policy shifted its focus from merely setting birth targets to a reproductive health and empowerment approach (influenced by the 1994 International Conference on Population and Development).
Key Goals:
Improve Reproductive Health Status: Lowering maternal and child mortality rates.
Advance Gender Equality and Empowerment: Seen as crucial to reducing fertility rates.
Increase Contraceptive Use: Improve access to information and modern contraceptive methods.
2. The Role of Family Planning
Family planning is considered the single most effective tool for managing the rapid population growth and improving maternal/child health.
Unmet Need: Only about one in three married women use modern contraceptives, leaving a high unmet need for family planning services.
Impact of Success: Projections show that if modern contraceptive use increased to around 47% by 2030, the country could:
Reduce the Total Fertility Rate (children per woman) from about 4.2 to $2.7$.
Significantly reduce maternal and child deaths.
Allow PNG to fully benefit from the Demographic Dividend, leading to higher GDP per capita.
3. Recent Government Stance (2024 Census)
Following the release of the 2024 census figures, Prime Minister James Marape has made the issue of population control a national priority.
Call for Responsibility: The PM urged young couples to practice responsible family planning and consider limiting families to two or three children, warning that the cost of raising a child in modern PNG (estimated at up to K5 million to adulthood) is too high for the average family.
Proposed Policy Link: The Prime Minister suggested initiating a national discussion to link free education support to family size (e.g., funding only the first two or three children), marking a significant policy step toward managing demand for public services.
The government's success in managing the national debt and sustaining the Connect PNG program will heavily rely on its ability to effectively implement these population policies and unlock the economic potential of women, which requires a direct confrontation with the endemic issue of GBV.
📈 Papua New Guinea's Demographic Dividend Opportunity
That
That is a critical area for PNG's long-term prosperity.
The concept of a Demographic Dividend (DD) is key to escaping the cycle of debt and poverty, as it promises accelerated economic growth simply from a favorable shift in the population's age structure.
Here is an analysis of PNG's status regarding the Demographic Dividend and the conditions required to seize this opportunity:
🇵🇬 Harnessing the Demographic Dividend (DD)
The Demographic Dividend is a window of opportunity for accelerated economic growth that occurs when the proportion of the working-age population (typically 15–64) is significantly larger than the non-working-age population (children under 15 and elderly over 65). This lowers the dependency ratio.
1. PNG's Current Status: The Window Has Not Opened Yet
According to PNG's National Statistical Office (NSO) and UNFPA, the country has not yet entered the main DD window, but it is approaching the optimal moment for intervention.
High Fertility Barrier: The Total Fertility Rate (TFR) is still high at approximately 4.2 children per woman. This means the proportion of children (non-working dependents) remains large, keeping the overall dependency ratio high and straining government resources.
The Pre-Dividend Phase: PNG is currently in the pre-dividend phase, characterized by a large and growing youth population (youth bulge). The working-age population (15-64) is currently about 63% of the total population, which is a stable foundation, but the true dividend boost requires a sharp drop in the child dependency ratio.
2. The Window of Opportunity: When and How?
The window for the DD is not automatic; it must be earned through strategic policy and investment. For PNG, the opportunity is projected to open within the next 10 to 30 years, provided two major shifts occur:
Condition
Action Required
Fertility Decline
Scale up Family Planning: This is the trigger. Policy must increase the Contraceptive Prevalence Rate (CPR) and address the high unmet need for family planning services to accelerate the decline in the TFR from 4.2 toward the replacement level (around 2.1).
Human Capital Investment
Employ, Educate, Empower: This is the mechanism. The government must make massive, sustained investments in four areas to ensure the growing working-age population is productive:
The Four Pillars for Seizing the Dividend (The "4 Es"):
Educate: Ensure high-quality, relevant education and skills training for all young people. The next generation must be equipped to compete in a modernized economy.
Employ: Create formal and informal employment opportunities at a pace sufficient to absorb the approximately 143,000 young people entering the workforce annually. This is where major resource projects and the Connect PNG plan are crucial.
Empower (Health): Invest in health and reproductive services (family planning) to create a healthier, more productive workforce and allow women to participate fully in the economy. This also means tackling GBV.
Enact (Governance): Implement sound macroeconomic policy, encourage savings and investment, and maintain good governance to ensure financial markets are stable and the private sector can create jobs.
3. Projected Economic Benefits
If PNG successfully navigates the transition and capitalizes on the DD, the economic benefits could be substantial, mirroring the growth experienced by the East Asian "Tiger" economies (like South Korea and Singapore).
Boost to GDP per Capita: Studies suggest that for countries that successfully capture the DD, the structural age change can add an average of 0.3 to 0.5 percentage points per year to their GDP per capita growth rate over the dividend period (which can last 30–50 years).
Increased Savings and Investment: With fewer children to support, households can increase savings. These collective savings can then be channeled into national investment (banks, infrastructure, and business expansion), fueling a virtuous cycle of growth.
Higher Female Labor Participation: Reduced fertility frees women from constant childcare, allowing them to enter the formal workforce, which has proven to be one of the most effective tools for socioeconomic development.
The challenge for PNG is immense: the debt shown in your video is a sign that the country is currently consuming resources to support a dependent population faster than it is investing in the human capital and infrastructure required to make that future working population productive. The window of opportunity is approaching, but decisive action on fertility and education is needed now to realize the benefit.
11. 📚 Education: The Key to PNG's Demographic Dividend
The working-age population (63.3% of the total) can only drive economic growth if it possesses the skills demanded by the market (the "E" for Employment). PNG faces immense challenges in meeting this requirement due to persistent issues in access, quality, and relevance.
1. The Challenge of Access and Retention
While progress has been made, huge disparities persist, particularly between rural and urban areas, and genders.
Out-of-School Children: A significant percentage of children are still out of school, especially at the primary and secondary levels. For children of primary school age, an estimated 13% are out of school, with the rate higher for girls (17%) than boys (10%).
Low Attainment Levels: Data from the 2011 Census indicated low educational attainment among the population aged 5 years and over:
Only 22.1% completed Grade 10.
Only 6.6% completed Grade 12.
This highlights a major leaky pipeline issue, where many students drop out before obtaining the basic certification needed for further training or formal employment.
2. The Tertiary Education Bottleneck
The gap between the number of high school graduates and the number of university/college spaces is a critical failure point for human capital development.
Extremely Low Enrollment: PNG's Gross Tertiary Enrollment Ratio (GTER)—the percentage of the age-eligible population enrolled in higher education—is startlingly low, estimated at approximately 1.8% to 2.3%.
Context: This compares unfavorably to regional neighbors like Fiji (46%), Indonesia (32%), and Australia (near 100%).
The Grade 12 Crunch: Each year, over 30,000 Grade 12 students graduate, but only around 11,500 secure a place in any tertiary institution. The majority are left without a clear pathway to formal skill acquisition.
Skills Mismatch: Many tertiary graduates still face unemployment or underemployment, indicating a severe mismatch between the skills taught in academic programs and the technical or professional skills demanded by the formal job market (e.g., in construction, engineering, and resource management).
3. The Quality Crisis (The "Education Dividend" Factor)
The sheer number of people with a basic education is insufficient; the quality of that education determines the productivity of the workforce.
Teacher Training and Resources: Schools often lack basic infrastructure, teaching materials, and properly trained teachers, particularly in remote areas. The implementation of curriculum reforms has struggled, leading to poor mastery of fundamental skills like literacy and numeracy.
The "Education Dividend": The experience of other developing countries suggests that the demographic benefit (more workers) is only realized when combined with an Education Dividend (smarter, more skilled workers). Without quality education beyond primary school, a large working-age population can become a drag on the economy, leading to increased social instability and unemployment.
Policy Imperative
To successfully capture the Demographic Dividend, the government must prioritize:
Retention: Investing in programs to keep girls and boys in school through Grade 12.
Quality: Shifting focus from just access to ensuring students master core skills and competencies.
Relevance: Aligning Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) with the specific demands of the resource sector projects (like Papua LNG) and the Connect PNG infrastructure boom to ensure graduates are immediately employable.
Successfully addressing these educational metrics is the only way to convert PNG's youth bulge from a fiscal liability into the productive workforce needed to pay down the national debt and drive sustained economic growth.
12. 🧑🌾 PNG Labour Market: Informal vs. Formal Employment
The PNG labour market is characterized by a stark imbalance, where the formal sector is small and struggling to grow fast enough to absorb the new entrants into the workforce.
1. The Dominance of the Informal Economy
The Informal Economy—composed mainly of subsistence agriculture, small-scale trade (selling betelnut, fresh produce), and micro-enterprises—is the true employer of Papua New Guinea.
Employment Share: Approximately 84% of the employed workforce is engaged in the informal economy, including subsistence work. This figure has remained largely unchanged since 2014.
The Livelihood Base: Subsistence and informal activities support the livelihoods of over 80% of the entire population. This is particularly vital in rural areas where the majority of the population lives.
Income Potential: Paradoxically, recent studies have shown that high-performing individuals in the informal sector (e.g., successful betelnut vendors) can earn more than twice the minimum wage of the formal sector, often around PGK 300–500 per week. This potential for higher, daily cash earnings is actually a "pull" factor drawing people, even some former formal workers, into the informal economy.
2. The Small Formal Sector
The Formal Sector encompasses jobs with legal contracts, fixed salaries, and social welfare benefits (like public service, mining, banking, retail). It represents a small, often inaccessible segment of the workforce.
Employment Share: Only about 16% of the employed labour force is in formal wage employment.
Absorption Crisis: The annual number of young people entering the working age population (over 140,000) far outstrips the rate of new formal job creation, which has been in decline across most non-resource sectors since the completion of the PNG LNG construction boom around 2013.
Key Sectors: The majority of formal jobs are concentrated in the services sector (53.7%), followed by agriculture (38.6%) and industry (7.6%).
Gender Gap: Twice as many men as women are employed in the formal sector, perpetuating the gender inequality linked to poverty and GBV.
3. The Unemployment Paradox
PNG’s unemployment rate is statistically low, typically reported at around 3% to 4%. However, this low figure is highly misleading and is a result of the dominant informal sector.
Definition: The low rate exists because most people, unable to find formal jobs, immediately engage in subsistence farming or informal trade, meaning they are technically "employed" and therefore not counted as unemployed.
Youth Not in Education, Employment, or
Training (NEET): A more accurate measure of the opportunity crisis is the high rate of youth who are NEET, which is around 27.7% for the youth population. This represents a significant pool of idle, potentially frustrated, but educated labour.
🛑 Policy Challenge: Formalization and Productivity
The primary development challenge is not necessarily reducing the informal sector, but increasing its productivity while simultaneously expanding the formal sector's capacity to absorb the growing, educated youth population.
Revenue Impact: The vast size of the informal economy means that a huge portion of economic activity (estimated to be worth around 20% of GDP) remains largely untaxed, starving the government of the revenue needed to service the national debt and invest in infrastructure like the Connect PNG program.
Policy Focus: The National Employment Policy (2023–2032) and the Medium-Term Development Plan aim to address this by:
Investing in SMEs: Supporting the creation of more formal Small-Medium Enterprises (SMEs).
Labour Mobility: Leveraging schemes like the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) scheme to send skilled workers abroad, which reduces domestic pressure and generates remittances.
In short, PNG's economic structure is currently unable to provide formal, high-productivity jobs for its rapidly growing and increasingly educated youth, which threatens to undermine all efforts to reduce poverty and seize the demographic dividend.
13. 🇵🇬 Analysis of the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) Scheme
That is a crucial area to explore. The Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) scheme is increasingly important for Papua New Guinea as a direct, short-term measure to address the crisis of youth unemployment and generate foreign income.
The scheme is framed as a "triple win"—benefiting Australia (filling labour shortages), the workers (higher earnings), and PNG (remittances and skills).
Here is a detailed analysis of the opportunities and challenges the PALM scheme presents for PNG's development goals:
🇦🇺🇵🇬 The Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) Scheme
The PALM scheme allows eligible Australian employers to hire workers from the Pacific (including PNG) for seasonal work (up to 9 months) or longer-term roles (1 to 4 years) in sectors like agriculture, aged care, meat processing, and hospitality.
1. 💰 Economic Opportunities for PNG
The core benefits for PNG are immediate and directly address the issues of high youth unemployment and revenue generation:
Remittances: This is the most significant benefit. PALM workers earn significantly more than they would in PNG—often three to ten times their pre-departure earnings. These funds are sent back to families (remittances), which are immediately injected into the local economy, increasing household income, financing education, improving housing, and reducing immediate poverty.
Skills and Experience Transfer: Workers gain formal experience, technical skills, and a professional work ethic in a foreign environment. The scheme is designed to facilitate a skills dividend, where workers return home to apply these skills in domestic sectors or start their own businesses (SMEs), addressing the skills mismatch in the formal sector.
Poverty and Unemployment Reduction: The scheme acts as an economic release valve by providing productive, formal employment for thousands of young people who would otherwise be either unemployed or limited to low-productivity informal work.
2. 🚧 Challenges for PNG's Participation
Despite the potential, PNG has struggled to maximize its participation compared to smaller Pacific Island nations (like Vanuatu, Samoa, and Tonga).
Challenge
Impact on PNG
Low Participation Rate
PNG supplies only about 3% of the total PALM workers, despite having the largest population base in the Pacific. The government's goal to deploy 8,000 workers by 2025 is ambitious and difficult to meet at the current pace.
Bureaucracy and Costs
The process of getting workers ready (passports, police clearances, medicals, pre-departure training) is often slow and expensive. PNG's model of using District or Provincial Service Improvement Program (DSIP/PSIP) funds to cover these costs is not yet sustainable or scalable.
Recruitment and Mobilization
PNG's decentralized regional recruitment model, involving numerous Recruitment Hubs, has been slow to deploy workers efficiently. Many hubs have registered but few have successfully sent people overseas.
“Brain Drain" Risk
While the scheme is mostly for low-to-semi-skilled work, there is a risk that the most entrepreneurial and skilled members of rural communities are removed for long periods, potentially hindering development efforts at home.
3. Worker Welfare Challenges
There are ongoing, systemic issues within the scheme that pose risks to PNG workers:
Exploitation: Workers remain vulnerable to exploitation due to the employer-tied visa, which limits their ability to change jobs or report abuse for fear of deportation.
Upfront Costs: While employers may pay initial travel costs, workers are often required to repay these through wage deductions, sometimes placing a heavy financial burden on them during their initial weeks of employment.
In conclusion, the PALM scheme is a valuable tool that offers a concrete, high-return path for thousands of PNG youth to secure formal employment and inject foreign currency (remittances) into the debt-stressed economy. However, PNG must urgently streamline its selection and mobilization processes to dramatically increase participation and ensure worker welfare is protected to make the scheme a truly effective tool for national development.
14. 💸 Remittances: Impact on PNG Households
Remittances—money sent home by workers abroad, especially through schemes like PALM—are a key source of national income and act as a social safety net, providing funds for food, education, and health.
1. Remittance Value and Worker Savings
The PALM scheme offers significant earnings potential for individual PNG workers:
Short-Term Workers (Seasonal): Remit an average of A$1,061 per month.
Long-Term Workers (1-4 years): Save and remit an average of A$1,310 per month, equating to nearly 40% of their monthly Australian income.
Household Impact: This substantial, reliable cash flow is vital for poverty reduction, allowing beneficiary households to spend about 10% more of their total expenditure on education (Source 2.1). This directly addresses the human capital investment needed for the Demographic Dividend.
2. PNG's Low Macroeconomic Reliance
While the income is huge for individual households, PNG's reliance on remittances at the national level is extremely low, contrasting sharply with its Pacific neighbors.
Country
Remittances as % of GDP (2023 Approx.)
Source of Income
Tonga
$\approx 41\%$ - $50\%$
Highest in the world; foundational to the economy.
Samoa
$\approx 28\%$ - $34\%$
A major component of national income.
Vanuatu
$\approx 12\%$
Significant, driven largely by PALM participation.
Papua New Guinea
$\approx 0.01\%$ - $0.02\%$
Negligible at the macro-level; primarily via informal/unrecorded channels.
Key Takeaway: For Tonga and Samoa, remittances are the single most prominent component of the national economy, often outpacing Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and Official Development Aid (ODA). In PNG, remittances are statistically insignificant as a percentage of GDP (Source 3.2), which reflects the country's low overall participation in the PALM scheme and historical reliance on massive resource projects and ODA (which accounts for $\approx 4\%$ of GDP, Source 3.3).
3. Policy Implications: Remittances vs. Debt
The remittance data presents a clear challenge:
Household Resilience: The funds that do enter PNG households provide a strong social safety net, helping families sustain living standards and invest in education, even when the broader economy struggles.
Revenue Gap: Because these are private flows and the total volume is small, remittances currently do almost nothing to help the government service the $\approx \text{PGK } 68 \text{ billion}$ national debt shown in the video.
Need for Scale: If PNG were to successfully meet its ambitious goal of deploying 8,000 workers (or more), the flow of remittances would increase substantially. This would not only reduce unemployment but also provide a more stable, non-debt foreign currency income stream, diversifying the foreign exchange market which is otherwise dominated by resource revenues.
To fully benefit from the "triple win" of the PALM scheme, PNG needs to streamline its mobilization process and facilitate cheaper and easier ways to remit money, as high transaction costs in the Pacific still unnecessarily drain household income.
🇵🇬 Current Status of the PNG FX Market (2025)
The most significant recent development is the substantial easing of the foreign exchange backlog that had constrained businesses since 2014:
Backlog Reduction: The backlog of outstanding foreign exchange orders has been significantly cleared, with banks reporting order books approaching zero. Clearing times for essential import orders have fallen from months to weeks, or even days, in early 2025.
Central Bank Intervention: The Bank of Papua New Guinea (BPNG) has been able to purchase surplus foreign currency from commercial banks for the first time in nearly a decade, signaling a significant turnaround in liquidity. The BPNG has been providing regular, predictable intervention ($125 million per month as of late 2024) to support the market.
Exchange Rate Policy: The central bank, with support from the IMF, is implementing a gradual transition to greater exchange rate flexibility (a crawling depreciation mechanism). The Kina has been allowed to depreciate slowly, which has helped to correct the overvaluation and encourage faster repatriation of foreign earnings.
💰 Key Impact Drivers
1. Resource Revenue (Mining and Petroleum)
This remains the primary driver of foreign currency inflows.
Surging Commodity Prices: High global prices for key PNG exports, particularly gold, have significantly boosted foreign currency earnings in 2025.
Increased Production: The restart and ramping up of major projects, such as the Porgera gold mine, are injecting substantial new foreign currency into the economy.
Long-Term Dependency: While vital, the market remains highly exposed to global commodity price volatility, emphasizing the need for diversification.
2. Aid and International Support
Aid and support flows are crucial for both macroeconomic stability and FX market confidence.
IMF-Supported Reform Program: The current stability is largely underpinned by a comprehensive economic reform program backed by the International Monetary Fund (IMF). This program is focused on fiscal repair, addressing FX shortages, and reforming BPNG operations.
Increased Confidence: The commitment to reform has boosted international investor confidence, which could lead to increased foreign direct investment (FDI) and lower government borrowing costs in the future.
3. Remittances
While remittances (funds sent home by PNG citizens working abroad) are a more stable source of foreign currency for many developing nations, their impact in PNG is often less prominent than the resource sector.
Sustainable Flow: Remittances generally offer a more resilient and sustainable source of foreign currency compared to volatile resource revenue.
Policy Focus: The BPNG and government continue to focus on strengthening financial systems and making it easier and cheaper for money to be sent through formal channels, which helps maximize the flow of this foreign currency into the official market.
The overall outlook for the PNG economy and the FX market in 2025 is one of cautious optimism, with economic growth projected to accelerate, driven by both resource and non-resource sectors, provided the policy reforms and increased commodity prices are sustained.
1. 📋 BPNG's Foreign Exchange Prioritization Policy (Rationing)
Despite the recent improvement in foreign exchange (FX) availability, the BPNG maintains a set of guidelines for Authorized Foreign Exchange Dealers (AFEDs, i.e., commercial banks) to prioritize orders. This is the mechanism used to manage the long-standing imbalance between demand and supply, often referred to as FX rationing.
The Priority System
The BPNG generally requires commercial banks to clear orders for "essential" goods and services before executing orders for "non-essential" purposes.
Category
Description
Examples of Orders to be Prioritized
✅ Essential Orders
Transactions critical for the immediate operation of the economy, public health, and safety.
* Food and Medicine: Imports of basic foodstuffs, essential medications, and medical supplies.
* Critical Raw Materials: Imports necessary for the functioning of domestic industries (e.g., fuel, vital manufacturing inputs).
* Public Services: Payments for contracts related to public health, infrastructure development, and utilities (e.g., power).
❌ Non-Essential Orders
Transactions that are not considered critical for the immediate operation of the economy.
* Capital Transactions: Repatriation of profits and dividends by foreign-owned companies (this is the largest category of non-essential demand).
* Offshore Investments and capital remittances.
* Some trade and service orders that are not deemed critical.
Key takeaway: The priority system is a temporary measure designed to protect the flow of critical imports. The policy goal, supported by the IMF program, is a gradual transition to greater exchange rate flexibility and the ultimate removal of FX restrictions and rationing once the Kina reaches a market-clearing rate and the backlog is fully eliminated.
2. 📈 PNG Economic Growth Projections for 2025
The consensus among major international financial institutions is that PNG's economic growth is set to accelerate significantly in 2025, driven by both the resource sector and a recovery in the non-resource economy.
Institution
2025 Real GDP Growth Forecast
Key Drivers
World Bank
4.7%
Strong resource growth (Porgera, Ok Tedi), improved agricultural output, and government spending (Connect PNG infrastructure).
IMF
4.7%
Driven by the resource sector and resilient non-resource growth, partly due to improved access to foreign exchange.
Asian Development Bank (ADB)
4.2%
Led by the resource sector (Porgera ramp-up, stable LNG) and an upward trend in non-resource sectors like agriculture and retail.
BPNG
~4.3%
Increased capacity and full-year production from the Porgera gold mine and other resource project construction.
Summary of Drivers for the Strong 2025 Outlook:
Resource Sector Boost: The full-scale reopening and ramp-up of the Porgera gold mine is the single largest factor injecting new foreign currency and driving resource sector GDP.
FX Improvement: The easing of the foreign exchange backlog is crucial for the non-resource sector (e.g., manufacturing, retail, and agriculture) as it allows businesses to secure essential imported inputs and raw materials more quickly, removing a major constraint on production.
Fiscal Measures: Government policies, such as the GST exemption on essential household goods and the removal of income tax for lower earners, are expected to provide household relief and boost consumer demand.
17. 🛑 Key Structural Challenges
1. Security and Law & Order
Security challenges are the most immediate and visible constraint on business activity and investment.
High Crime Rates and Civil Unrest: PNG experiences persistently high rates of violent crime and civil unrest. Events like the January 2024 riots in Port Moresby and Lae demonstrated how quickly unrest can escalate, leading to massive financial losses for businesses.
Impact on Resource Projects: Major resource projects, like the Porgera gold mine, have had their operations and ramp-up slowed by landowner disputes, illegal mining, and general law and order issues around the mine site. Security costs for these operations are substantial.
Business Operations: Companies often face high costs for private security, insurance, and supply chain logistics, which deter foreign direct investment (FDI) outside of the high-margin extractive sector.
Tribal and Community Violence: Inter-group fighting and tribal conflicts often disrupt road networks and general business activity in provincial areas, particularly affecting the agriculture and forestry sectors.
2. Power and Infrastructure
The lack of reliable and widespread infrastructure, particularly electricity, remains a severe bottleneck for all non-resource economic activity.
Chronic Power Outages: PNG Power Limited (PNGL), the state utility, struggles with frequent and prolonged power outages (load shedding) and system failures across major grids, including Port Moresby and Lae.
Impact on Business: Businesses are forced to rely heavily on expensive diesel generators, significantly raising operating costs and reducing competitiveness. This lack of reliable power severely limits the growth of small-to-medium enterprises (SMEs) and manufacturing.
Widespread Access Gap: Only a small percentage of the population (estimated around 15% to 20%) has access to the electricity grid, constraining human capital development and excluding large segments of the population from socio-economic progress.
Debt and Maintenance: PNGL is burdened by significant legacy debt and inadequate funding for maintenance and necessary upgrades to the aging power generation and transmission network.
3. Governance and Corruption
Weak governance undermines the government's capacity to effectively address structural issues and manage the economy for inclusive growth.
Corruption Perception: Corruption is widely perceived as a major obstacle to business and development. The weak enforcement of anti-corruption laws and lack of transparency deter investment and lead to misallocation of public funds.
Regulatory Uncertainty: Although the government is working to streamline regulations, the process for obtaining licenses and permits can be opaque and lengthy, creating regulatory burdens for the private sector.
Financial Market Risk: PNG has faced warnings about deficiencies in its anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing regime. If not fully addressed, this could lead to a potential "grey listing", which would significantly increase the cost of international financial transactions and deter foreign investment.
Political Instability Risk: The political environment remains volatile, with a history of no-confidence votes and cabinet reshuffles. This instability can distract from the necessary long-term economic reforms.
In summary, while the foreign exchange market is experiencing short-term relief, the ambitious growth figures for 2025 are still heavily reliant on resource extraction. Sustained, inclusive growth for the entire nation requires tackling these structural impediments to unlock the full potential of the non-resource economy.
🏗️ 1. Infrastructure Strategy: The Connect PNG Program
The government's primary strategy for infrastructure is the Connect PNG Economic Road Transport Development Program (2020-2040), which aims to provide 100% road connectivity across the country by 2040.
Key Features and Progress (2025)
Long-Term Funding Commitment: The program is legislated under the Connect PNG (Implementation and Funding Arrangements) Act 2021. This Act commits a minimum of 5.6% of the annual national budget to the program, aiming for a total investment of K20 billion over 20 years. This dedicated funding mechanism is a significant change designed to ensure work continuity.
Focus on 'Missing Links': The core goal is to construct new roads, known as "missing links," to connect all provinces and major economic corridors. A key goal for Phase 1 (2020–2027) is to complete the Trans-Island Highway, linking Port Moresby to Lae (the industrial hub), with progress reported on key sections like the Gulf-Southern Highlands and Central-Milne Bay links.
Maintenance First Policy: The Department of Works and Highways is implementing a "Maintenance First Policy" under the National Road Network Strategy. This prioritizes maintaining existing infrastructure to prevent costly deterioration, which is a major shift from past practices.
Multi-Sectoral Approach: The program extends beyond roads to include digital infrastructure (ICT) and supporting national electrification and water transport projects, recognizing that connectivity is a multi-dimensional challenge.
Challenge: Despite the legal funding commitment, the actual budget allocated in recent years has often been less than the legislated 5.6% minimum. The program remains highly reliant on loans and grants from development partners (like the ADB and World Bank) to cover the funding shortfall.
⚖️ 2. Anti-Corruption Strategy: The ICAC
The government's main reform addressing governance and corruption is the establishment of the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC), an agency designed to investigate and prosecute corrupt conduct.
Key Reforms and Status (2025)
Legislation and Establishment: The ICAC was legislated in 2020 (Organic Law on the ICAC) and became operational in 2023, fulfilling a long-standing national aspiration. It is empowered to investigate and prosecute corruption by public officials, systemic corruption, and corruption by private individuals who misuse government funds.
Supporting Legislation: This reform is supported by the Whistleblower Protection Act (2020) and policy work towards a Freedom of Information Law, which are crucial for creating a culture of transparency.
International Framework: The reforms align with PNG's commitments under the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC) and are critical to addressing recommendations from the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) to prevent PNG from being "grey-listed" for deficiencies in its anti-money laundering framework.
Challenge: The effectiveness of the ICAC has been immediately challenged. In 2025, there was internal turmoil involving the suspension of the inaugural commissioners, which exposed deep institutional rivalries and political interference risks. While the government reaffirmed its commitment, the incident underscored that political will is fragile and that anti-corruption efforts struggle to move beyond symbolic gestures to sustained, impactful prosecution of high-profile cases.
The success of Connect PNG and the ICAC will determine whether the current positive FX market momentum translates into long-term, equitable prosperity for all Papua New Guineans.
00111012511240522
