18/12/2025
In 2014, when CBC's The Fifth Estate covered Emma Fillipoff's disappearance, they invited University of Victoria criminologist Garry Gray (Associate Professor, Department of Sociology) and nine of his Sociology students to take part in a day of fieldwork.
The goal was to help retrace Emma's steps on the night she went missing and gather observations that could inform the documentary - and, importantly, encourage public participation through crowdsourcing on social media after the episode aired. Due to time constraints, only about a minute of the episode focused on Garry Gray and his students. A lot of the deeper message behind the fieldwork didn't really make it on screen, and instead it was folded into the broader narrative the show was telling about Emma
Years later, Bayberry Films had the opportunity to interview Garry about that fieldwork for our upcoming six-part docuseries, Barefoot in the Night: The Search for Emma Fillipoff. Garry's subsequent academic research examines how criminology is changing in this age of social media - where ordinary citizens, not just police, increasingly play a role in investigations. His work explores crowdsourcing criminology and how it intersects with newsmaking, public criminology, and the very rapidly growing tension between serious investigative reporting and basic true-crime infotainment.
This distinction matters. Documentary work around crime can either deepen understanding, responsibility, and care - or flatten complex human stories into content designed primarily for consumption. Steering narratives rather than truth because they make for a better or more interesting story that will keep people entertained. Garry's research speaks directly to that crossroads: how stories about real people, real harm, and unresolved cases are shaped, shared, and sometimes distorted in a media landscape that is driven by attention.
✨CROWDWITS ✨
In November, Garry launched a new website and newsletter called Crowdwits, which brings his academic research into a more accessible, public-facing space. His very first newsletter focuses on Emma's case and a question many people quietly struggle with:
What are you supposed to do when you think you might have seen someone who's been missing for years?
✨Read the article:
https://www.crowdwits.com/p/the-stranger-who-looked-back-at-me-why-we-stay-silent-when-we-think-we-ve-seen-a-missing-person
Crowdwits is Garry's way of translating his core research areas - crowdsourcing criminology and institutional trust - into thoughtful, real-world discussions, without easy answers or sensationalism.
✨Introducing Crowdwits: When Can You Trust the Crowd vs. Experts?
“The old rules about who to believe are breaking down. A criminologist who studies both crowdsourcing and institutional corruption explores what comes next.”
✨Subscribe:
https://subscribe-forms.beehiiv.com/f1a5db06-cb87-49fa-8107-0a94b94e266b
✨Website:
https://www.crowdwits.com/
Lessons from Emma Fillipoff's case