24/10/2025
Review by Julia Pattison: Murder at Midnight at York Theatre Royal
(Age guidance 14+) Running until Until Saturday, October 25
I’d heard praise for writer Torben Betts’ previous thriller, Murder In the Dark, and having been promised in the publicity that “Murder at Midnight blends razor-sharp wit with chilling suspense and will keep you guessing until the final stroke of midnight” I was anticipating a sitting on the edge of my seat Press Night. I was to be disappointed… this was more farce/sitcom territory, with flashes of suspense and violent cartoon comic capers - entertaining at times certainly, but definitely not a taut thriller as the publicity had led us to believe.
The overall star of this production was Colin Falconer’s triple-tier set featuring a full cutaway of a modern house, including a living room, kitchenette, patio area, and bedrooms, one of which was a “man cave” full of Robbie Williams memorabilia – a nod to Jonny’s “The Cyclops” devotion to his pop hero.
The first half of the play was very full and frantic; a bit too frantic really with lots of overlapping dialogue being said across the various levels of the house.
Lots of exposition, yet lots of repetition too, and I began to switch off, not really engaging with any of the characters apart from Jonny “The Cyclops” ( played with wonderful swagger by Jason Durr ) and his mother, Shirley (portrayed with great mischief by Susie Blake, who also seemed to have the best one liners in the play).
The second half was a considerable improvement; exposition ended, as did the chasing from room to room thankfully, and there was more of a storyline. Jason Durr showed his versatility as an actor going from mirthful to mean and moody in a heartbeat. We got to warm more to Trainwreck’s character (played with pathos by Peter Moreton), with Max Bowden (Paul), and Katie McGlynn (Lisa) coming into their own with their banter together as things got more and more bizarre and bloody.
If you’re looking for light-hearted night’s entertainment then you’ll enjoy this. But be warned – it’s not a Thriller!
Photos courtesy of Pamela Raith