01/09/2020
An Ambassador Comes to Dinner
On a rainy night in March 2018 a dinner was hosted in Café Milano in Georgetown, Washington by Yousef Al Otaiba, the then and current United Arab Emirates Ambassador to the United States of America. Café Milano has a well-established reputation as a meeting place for the power-brokers of Washington. Its clientele includes administration officials, diplomats, lobbyists, journalists amongst many others. It’s the place to meet. Among the UAE Ambassador’s guest list on the night was a senior Trump administration official who oversaw the administration’s policy on Iran.
Coincidently (or not), on the night in another room, Prime Minister of Israel Benjamin Netanyahu was dining with his wife Sara. Prime Minister Netanyahu was in Washington that week for a meeting of the powerful pro-Israeli lobbying group AIPAC, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee. According to Mark Lander then While House correspondent of the New York Times who was a guest of Ambassador Yousef Al Otaiba, on the basis that all conversations at the table were off-the-record, one of the dinner-party guests (he does not say who) thought it interesting/fun to invite Mr. Netanyahu to meet with Ambassador Al Otaiba.
At the time this ostensibly impromptu meeting was taking place between the Ambassador and the Prime Minister, the United Arab League, of which the United Arab Emirates is a member, did not recognise the state of Israel, had spent years championing the Palestinian cause while denouncing the Israeli occupation of Palestine. From a journalistic/by-standard perspective the fun/interesting prospect of these two adversaries sharing dessert (they didn’t apparently) undoubtedly added an unexpected frisson to the evening’s entertainment.
Two years and five months later the United Arab Emirates and Israel announce their intention to establish full diplomatic ties, the UAE only the third Arab country to do so. All against the seething anger the Palestinian leadership.
On an August night in Clifden in 2020, in a week that Met Éireann issued an orange weather warning threatening dangerous, stormy conditions which could pose a risk to life and property, a now much discussed dinner was held in the Kylemore Suite of the Station House Hotel in Clifden. Unlike the Milano restaurant in Georgetown, Clifden House does not have a reputation for hosting dinners where the country’s power brokers break bread together. Among the guests, as is now well established, were prominent current and retired politicians, a now retired EU Commissioner, a Supreme Court Judge, a banking representative and a prominent retired broadcaster.
Less commented upon was the presence of Mr. Lahcen Mahraoui, Morocco’s ambassador to Ireland. Both Israel and Morocco claim sovereignty over disputed lands. Israel, Palestine. Morocco, Western Sahara. According to Samantha Power, the former US Ambassador to the UN, 18 resolutions were adopted by the UN General Assembly and others in the Human Rights Council in 2016, all condemning Israeli occupation of Palestine. Morocco’s sovereignty claim over Western Sahara is not recognised by The African Union. Instead, the African Union recognizes the self-declared Sahrawi Arab Republic.
In the above context, the presence of Ambassador Lahcen Mahraoui at the Oireachtas Golf dinner is no small matter.
In 2019, then Tánaiste and still Foreign Affairs Minister, Simon Coveney announced the government’s intention to open an embassy in Morocco this year, delayed due to the Covid 19 pandemic. Ireland will become a member of the United Nations Security Council on January 1st, 2021. As The Economist recently pointed out “Ireland is now an unlikely diplomatic superpower”.
All of which makes the Moroccan Ambassador’s presence at the Clifden event more curious. The question is: who invited the Ambassador? And why the Moroccan Ambassador? And was there an understanding, as in the Georgetown dinner in the United States, that all conversations at that dinner were off-the-record. Even for retired broadcasters?
What conversations, if any, ensued between the Ambassador and the EU Commissioner? The Ambassador and the Minister? The Ambassador and the Leas-Chathaoirleach of the Seanad? The Ambassador and the former minister, MEP and the current head of the head of the Banking and Payments Federation of Ireland?
And how likely is it that we will see those conversations make their way into major policy decisions in the future? Decisions that may very well affect the estimated 173,600 Sahrawi refugees (according to figures from the United Nations) stranded for over forty years in what is known as ‘the desert within the desert’ in Algeria?
Conversations over dinner matter. That the Moroccan Ambassador had access to critical policy makers and policy influencers is no small matter. And what impact will that dinner have on the future prospects of the Sahrawi people? Just look at what started in the Milano restaurant in Georgetown, Washington on a rainy night in March 2018.