25/06/2025
I (27F) have a long-term boyfriend, who I’m very happy with. A few weeks ago at the gym, a guy (32M) approached me and struck up a conversation. The first thing I said when he approached was that I had a boyfriend. He immediately said it wasn't like that and he wanted more gym friends. We spoke casually for a while and he asked to add me on instagram so he could add me to this group chat with all these gym people, which I said yes to and he did add me to this group chat. Before judging me - ladies, (and men in many cases), you know how hard it can be to say no when someone is being nice to you.
Since then, he’s DMed me a few times. Nothing overtly flirty, but it’s starting to feel like he wants a closer emotional connection than just gym buddies. For example, at the gym he asked about my band T-shirt, and I told him it's my favorite band. He listened to literally an entire album of theirs and followed up on Instagram which felt unusually personal. He also has been sharing music, band videos, etc. It's feeling a bit more personal and intentional than I'm comfortable with.
I don’t think he’s a bad guy but I wonder if he's trying to cross a line. I just get the sense that it’s veering into emotional intimacy, and I want to shut it down respectfully without being rude. I don't want any weirdness at the gym, but I also don’t want to lead him on or feed a vibe that isn’t platonic. I need help for this reason - how do I shut this down without being cold/rude/making it awkward to be at the gym? I also don't want to straight up accuse him of being into me.