30/04/2024
Two books, written 150 years apart – and both touch on how a woman’s voice is viewed. One, a classic novel, the other a contemporary thriller, unveils a persistent theme: the struggle women face to be heard.
"Women were expected to have weak opinions; but the great safeguard of society and of domestic life was, that opinions were not acted on." (George Eliot, Middlemarch, 1872)
This seemingly innocuous statement by George Eliot has a layer of scathing sarcasm. Women were expected to have meek opinions, but even those were deemed a threat to the "safeguard" of society.
Fast forward 150 years and look at it again from a male gaze (and of course, this is male chauvinism, coming from a character who is clearly going to end badly in the book).
"The trouble with women... is that they lack the courage of their convictions." (Sarah Vaughan, Anatomy of a Scandal, 2018)
It stings and stinks, but you have to wonder if a character can think this in 2018, so must people in real life.
Women's voices haven't always been valued (and perhaps, are still not). When George Eliot said this, she was of course critiquing the power structures that silenced women. It reflects a 19th-century view when women had fewer rights and limited agency.
But look at it today, and you have to ask, has social conditioning really changed in all this time? We still hold women back with outdated gender norms and expectations. Not every voice gets heard. When it does, it gets downplayed.
Even across a gulf of 150 years, we are fighting the same battle.