28/09/2026
ARE YOU A GOOD SHEPHERD?
A good shepherd does not only teach obedience to God and the Church; he also teaches his clergy to respect legitimate civil authority.
The question therefore deserves to be asked:
Are you a good shepherd if you encourage or permit your priest to disregard a legitimate invitation from the civil authorities?
A good shepherd should not shield his cleric from a lawful civil investigation. Rather, he should encourage the priest to appear, cooperate with the investigation, answer questions truthfully, and allow due process to take its course.
If a priest disobeys his bishop, disciplinary consequences may follow because ecclesiastical authority requires obedience. The same principle of lawful authority applies in civil society. A priest remains a citizen and is subject to the laws of the country.
This does not mean that every action of a police officer is automatically lawful. Where an invitation is improper, abusive, or contrary to the law, the appropriate response is to challenge it through lawful procedures, preferably with legal counsel—not simply to ignore the authorities or obstruct an investigation.
Authority must be respected, and accountability must be mutual.
St. Paul teaches:
“Let every person be subject to the governing authorities.”
— Romans 13:1
The Christian understanding of civil authority does not place any individual above the law—not a priest, bishop, archbishop, governor, former president, Inspector-General of Police, or any other public figure.
Likewise, ecclesiastical office does not confer immunity from legitimate civil investigation.
A bishop expects his priests to obey him because ecclesiastical order depends upon discipline. A responsible bishop should therefore also teach his clergy how to respond properly to legitimate civil authority: with respect, transparency and lawful cooperation.
If there is an allegation of defamation, misconduct, or any other civil matter, the proper approach is not to hide behind ecclesiastical