12/09/2025
Apple iPhone 17 vs. Samsung Galaxy S25: Two Flagship Lines, One Tough Choice
Both Samsung and Apple are making strong plays for your pocket. We pit the new iPhone 17 against the tested Galaxy S25 to see which one comes out on top.
Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.
Eight phones are available between the Apple iPhone 17 and Samsung Galaxy S25 lineups, with the iPhone ranging from $799 to $1,999 and the Galaxy S25 line from $799.99 to $1,659.99 for the top S25 Ultra.
Here are the starting prices for this octet:
Apple iPhone 17, $799; iPhone Air, $999; iPhone 17 Pro, $1,099; iPhone 17 Pro Max, $1,199
Samsung Galaxy S25, $799.99; S25+, $999.99; S25 Edge, $1,099.99; Galaxy S25 Ultra, $1,299.99
Adding storage increases the price of each phone. The two lineups are priced similarly at most tiers, but the Apple iPhone Pro Max with 2TB of storage is the most expensive model at nearly $2,000. Also, the base iPhone 17 ships with 256GB of storage, whereas the base S25 has half of that.
If dollars and cents are the only important things to you, the Apple iPhone 17 is the lowest-cost phone (even if only by 99 cents). But it's potentially a better value than the Galaxy S25 because it has twice the storage.
Winner: iPhone 17
Design: Styles and Colors Galore
Generally, smartphone design has settled on the rounded rectangle with a screen dominating the front and a front-facing camera interrupting it. A power button, volume rocker, USB-C port, and a camera bump are also typical. All of this is true of every iPhone 17 and Galaxy S25.The iPhone 17 relies on the Dynamic Island to contain its selfie camera and Face ID for biometrics. The Galaxy S25 phones have a punch hole front-facing camera and use an under-display fingerprint sensor for security, positioned near the bottom of the screen.
The rear panels stand out the most. The iPhone 17 looks like a modern iPhone with two rear cameras, while the Air features a Google Pixel-like horizontal bar with just one camera. The iPhone 17 Pro has a large rectangular plateau to contain its three main cameras.
Meanwhile, the Samsung S25, S25+, and Ultra feature a flat back with circular camera rings lined up vertically in the top left corner. The S25 Edge's two rear cameras are stacked atop a vertical pill-shaped island.
The Galaxy S25 is the smallest and lightest phone of the group at 5.78 by 2.78 by 0.28 inches (HWD) and 5.71 ounces. The iPhone 17 Pro Max is the heaviest at 8.22 ounces, while the Air is the thinnest at 0.22 inches thick, just beating the 0.23-inch thickness of the S25 Edge.
All iPhone 17s and Galaxy S25s have an IP68 rating to protect them from dust and water. Apple uses aluminum for the iPhone 17's frame and the 17 Pro's unibody chassis, and titanium for the Air. The iPhones' screens are all protected by Apple's anti-reflective Ceramic Shield 2, which the company says is three times more scratch-resistant than the previous version. Every phone's back, except the iPhone 17, is protected with the first-generation Ceramic Shield.
Samsung builds the S25 and S25+ with aluminum frames and Corning Gorilla Glass Victus 2 glass on the front and back. The S25 Ultra has a titanium frame, Gorilla Glass Victus 2 on the back, and the anti-reflective Corning Gorilla Armor 2 on the front. Colors? Too many to list.
With so many sizes, shapes, materials, and colors, surely one will speak to you. Design is subjective, so it's your call.
Winner: Tie