The Sirens Podcast

The Sirens Podcast Sirens | Southern True Crime with Raven Rollins
Support the Show: https://bit.ly/SupportShows

This is a true crime podcast from creator Raven Rollins where she hosts and talks to friends and experts about cases all around the Southern States, including her former home town of Ada, Oklahoma.

08/16/2026

I want to explain something about the way I approach true crime journalism, because it comes up from time to time: why I rarely seek out interviews with perpetrators.

I am not saying perpetrators should never speak. I am not saying everything they say is automatically false. I am saying that their retrospective account is not the center of the work I produce.

My work is victim-centered.

I research the facts as rigorously as I can through court records, police reports, autopsy reports, transcripts, investigative files, forensic evidence, contemporaneous reporting, and whatever other primary documentation is available. Then, when I conduct personal interviews, their purpose is usually different. They help us understand who the victim was, what their loss did to a family, what grief looked like afterward, and how a violent crime affected an entire community.

Personal interviews can add humanity. They can add perspective and context. They can sometimes reveal leads that can later be investigated and verified.

But I do not believe personal recollection should set the facts.

Someone's memory, opinion, or preferred version of a crime years later does not become forensic evidence simply because they feel strongly about it.

That is also why I generally do not solicit interviews with convicted perpetrators. It is not because I believe they are incapable of telling the truth. It is an editorial boundary against allowing the person who committed the crime to become the protagonist of the story.

Because that can happen very quickly.

Suddenly the focus becomes: Why did you do it? What happened to you? What were you thinking? Do you regret it? Were you misunderstood? What is your version of what happened?

And before long, the person who was killed becomes little more than something that happened in the perpetrator's story.

I refuse to do that.

The fact that someone committed an extraordinary crime does not entitle them to extraordinary attention.

That does not mean I would never interview a perpetrator. If someone convicted reaches out to me directly, I may listen. There can be legitimate investigative value in doing so. They might reveal a previously unknown detail, identify another crime, raise a question that can actually be tested, or provide information that leads to something verifiable.

But even then, an interview is not an automatic platform.

Access does not equal publication.
A statement does not equal evidence.
An interview does not equal a platform.

Anything worth pursuing still has to be investigated and corroborated.

There are many different ways to tell true crime stories, and other journalists may make different choices. This is simply mine.

My work exists to document what happened as accurately as possible, to show the human consequences of violent crime, and above all, to keep the victim from disappearing behind the person who took their life.

Because in my work, the victim remains the center of the story.

🎡 Oklahoma’s State Fair season is right around the corner, and I want to bring an older Sirens episode back into the spo...
08/14/2026

🎡 Oklahoma’s State Fair season is right around the corner, and I want to bring an older Sirens episode back into the spotlight—especially in light of an important step forward for Oklahoma’s cold-case families.

Earlier this week, Governor Kevin Stitt held a ceremonial signing for Senate Bill 1636, legislation inspired in part by the unsolved murders of sisters Cheryl Genzer and Lisa Pennington.

Cheryl, 25, and Lisa, 16, disappeared after attending the Oklahoma State Fair on September 23, 1987. Their bodies were discovered approximately one month later in a shallow grave. Nearly 39 years have passed, and no one has ever been brought to justice for their murders.

Longtime family friend and advocate Dorian Quillen helped spearhead the effort behind SB 1636. When the law takes effect on November 1, certain family members of cold-case victims will finally have a formal way to request a fresh review of an eligible case. That review must be conducted by investigators who were not involved in the original investigation and must consider updated forensic testing, new investigative methods, and the possibility of re-interviewing witnesses.

This is the kind of accountability and forward movement families have needed for far too long.

In September 2023, I released an episode of Sirens examining the murders of Cheryl and Lisa, along with the September 26, 1981 disappearance of 13-year-olds Cinda Pallett and Charlotte Kinsey from the Oklahoma State Fair.

I also explored several other cases that may have connections to the same traveling carnival circuit, including Carlene Brown, Christi Gross, Deborah Meyer, Jayleen Banker, Carolyn Eaton—known for decades as “Valentine Sally”—and Oklahoma sisters Rozlin and Fawn Abell.

Because advocacy also means prevention, the episode includes practical safety information for attending fairs, festivals, concerts, and other crowded public events. That part of the conversation remains just as important today—especially for parents preparing to take their children to the Oklahoma State Fair or Tulsa State Fair this year.

With fair season approaching and renewed hope surrounding Cheryl and Lisa’s case, now is the perfect time to revisit:

🎧 The Oklahoma State Fair Murders
Sirens: Southern True Crime
Listen anywhere you get your podcasts.

Please share this episode—not only to help others prepare for fair season, but to keep these victims’ names and stories in the public eye.

Justice delayed should never mean justice abandoned.

07/28/2026

Karl Allen Fontenot wants federal judge to permanently stop prosecutors from retrying him in infamous 1984 murder case. See link below ⬇️

📸 THE OKLAHOMAN FILE

07/25/2026

This one is especially heartbreaking because it happened in Owasso, Oklahoma - just north of me in the Tulsa area.

Late Thursday night, Owasso police responded to a domestic disturbance after a child inside the home called 911. When officers arrived, they found 38-year-old Sara Duff deceased. Her husband, Sean Duffey—known to many on TikTok as DuffDaddy1—was found with a self-inflicted injury and later died at a local hospital.

June 10, 2026: Sara filed for an emergency protective order against Shawn Duffey, alleging he had a gun, threatened su***de, and fled. The order was later extended through August.

July 11, 2026: Sara posted the now-viral TikTok using the Netflix documentary trend, writing that she had just discovered her soon-to-be ex-husband was a pe*****le.

According to the protective order filed on behalf of a 15-year-old girl, the girl's mother alleged that Shawn Duffey, who coached her basketball team:

He kissed the girl.
He touched her inappropriately.
He sent her private messages.
He invited her to his hotel room during a basketball tournament.
He allegedly offered her money to keep quiet.
Another coach reportedly witnessed him kissing or engaging in inappropriate contact with the girl.

July 23, 2026 (around 11:15 p.m.): Owasso police responded to a 911 call from a child in the home. Investigators say Shawn Duffey fatally shot Sara before taking his own life.

Sara was a hairstylist, a mother of two children from a previous marriage, and someone whose life should not be reduced to headlines. My heart is with her children, loved ones, and everyone in the Owasso community now trying to make sense of this tragedy.

I'm sharing one of Sara's own videos below because her voice deserves to be heard. She was killed 12 days after posting it.

💜 If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic violence, please know that help is available. You are not alone.

The anniversary is upon us and I would love it if you all would check out and share my center column in The Ada News tod...
07/08/2026

The anniversary is upon us and I would love it if you all would check out and share my center column in The Ada News today about Justice for Daniel Furr. With the family’s permission, we've released the latest information in the case.

July marks the anniversary of one of Oklahoma's most heartbreaking unsolved murders.On July 7, 1995, 15-year-old Daniel ...
07/01/2026

July marks the anniversary of one of Oklahoma's most heartbreaking unsolved murders.

On July 7, 1995, 15-year-old Daniel Lee Furr disappeared from Ada, Oklahoma. Four days later, on July 11, his body was allegedly discovered at an abandoned quarry near the old Ada Brick Plant. The death was ruled a homicide, but more than three decades later, no one has been held accountable for Daniel's murder, and the family still questions whether they actually laid Daniel to rest.

Daniel was a son, a brother, a friend, and a teenager whose future was stolen far too soon. His family has spent years fighting to keep his name in the public eye and searching for the answers they still deserve.

If you'd like to learn more about Daniel's case, you can:

📚 Read the full investigation in Sins of the South: Three Oklahoma Cold Cases, which has just been enrolled in Amazon's Kindle Unlimited program, so subscribers can read for free.

📖 Read the highlights in Allegedly: True Crime From Pontotoc County, Oklahoma, which will be 50% off on Smashwords during July.

🎙️Listen to the free episode on my podcast Sirens: Southern True Crime. Find it anywhere you stream your podcasts.

All options feature interviews with Daniel's mother, Gale, and sister, Chelsea, and every page read, every listen, and every share helps ensure that Daniel's story is not forgotten.

A $10,000 reward remains available for information leading to an arrest. Anyone with information is encouraged to contact the OSBI at (800) 522-8017 or [email protected].

Question... what are y'all doing out there? Please don't do this...mmkkkaayy...STATEMENT BY HOSPITAL:While the events po...
06/19/2026

Question... what are y'all doing out there? Please don't do this...mmkkkaayy...

STATEMENT BY HOSPITAL:

While the events portrayed were real and remain a matter of public record, they also represent one of the most painful chapters in the lives of the victim’s family, the New Boston community, and the healthcare professionals who responded that day. For many, the emotional impact of this tragedy has never fully faded.
This is not a story of entertainment or a destination for tourism. It is a story of devastating loss. Out of respect for those affected, including the family, our staff, and the community, McCurtain Memorial Hospital will not participate in interviews, photo opportunities, tours, or discussions related to these events.

Today, we remember the mother and child whose lives were taken, and we continue to hold their loved ones in our thoughts. We also acknowledge the lasting impact this tragedy had on the first responders, nurses, physicians, and hospital staff who worked tirelessly in its aftermath.

The New Boston community will forever carry the scars of this loss, and many members of our team continue to carry those memories as well.
There will be no further public comment beyond this statement.

Address

Ada, OK

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Sirens Podcast posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Sirens Podcast:

Shortcuts

Share

Category