
07/29/2025
In February 1896, prominent New Mexico lawyer and politician Albert Jennings Fountain and his young son Henry disappeared while traveling from a court appearance.
Their disappearance sparked a major investigation, with initial suspicions pointing to rivals involved in a land dispute. Despite extensive searches and investigations, including efforts by Pat Garrett, their bodies were never found, and the case remains unsolved.
The Disappearance:
Albert Jennings Fountain was a well-known figure in New Mexico Territory, involved in legal and political affairs, and was known for prosecuting cattle rustlers.
On February 1, 1896, he and his eight-year-old son, Henry, were returning from Mesilla, New Mexico, to Lincoln, New Mexico, after a court case.
They were traveling by buggy and were last seen near the White Sands.
When they failed to arrive, a search was launched, and their buggy was found abandoned with some personal items still inside.
Investigations and Suspects:
The disappearance quickly became a major public concern, and the governor called in both the Pinkerton Detective Agency and Pat Garrett, the famous killer of Billy the Kid, to investigate.
Suspicion initially fell on Oliver Lee, James Gililland, and William McNew, who were former deputies and were allegedly aligned with powerful politician Albert B. Fall.
The men were tried for the murders, but due to a lack of bodies and other evidence, they were acquitted.
The prosecution was hampered by missing witnesses and a courtroom atmosphere that was intimidating due to the presence of armed supporters of the defendants.
Fall, a rival of Fountain's, even acted as the defense attorney for Lee, Gililland, and McNew.
Unresolved Mystery:
The lack of bodies and the complex political climate of the time made the case very difficult to solve.
The disappearance of Albert and Henry Fountain remains one of the most enduring mysteries of the Old West.
Many theories exist, but the true fate of Albert and Henry Fountain remains unknown.
New Mexico History/Albuquerque Reminiscing