06/08/2026
Do you ever allow players to make a check WITHOUT rolling their dice?
I've definitely done this before:
- When the player is making a charisma check (typically persuasion) and does some excellent RP
- When the player is making a sleight of hand check to build a cool trap or gizmo and has a creative and clever plan
Some risks I have found with this approach is that by removing the mechanics of dice, you could be uneven in rewarding your players. For example, maybe your sense of humor or play style is more similar to one person, so you consistently hand wave their checks, but make others roll.
When I do this at the therapy table, it is ALWAYS done in a skill-challenge format where every player gets the opportunity to do something clever without dice, and then again to do something clever with dice. In the therapeutic play setting, clear balance should be felt by all of the players with no chance to perceive preferential treatment or favoritism.
What do you think? How have you tried this?
Dice isn't always right