07/23/2025
Koinonia News
Open Borders, COVID Lockdowns, and Riots in the Streets:
A Christian Call for Truth, Compassion, and National Integrity
By Bishop Michael Callahan
St. Nicholas Holy Orthodox Catholic and Apostolic Church of America
An Authentic Faith Commentary
When COVID-19 turned the world upside down, American citizens were told that the most loving, responsible thing they could do was to stay home, shut down, and remain silent. Churches closed their doors. Businesses collapsed. Weddings and funerals were canceled. Children were locked out of schools, and families were forbidden from comforting their dying loved ones in hospitals.
We were told this was for the common good. That compassion demanded isolation. That sacrifice would save lives.
And yet, as this was happening, our southern border remained open.
Illegal immigration continued unabated. And while law-abiding Americans mourned alone and suffered in silence, undocumented migrants were bused and flown into sanctuary cities, often untested and unvetted, under the cover of night.
Even then, many of us sensed that something deeper—more orchestrated—was taking place.
Today, that suspicion is no longer theoretical. It’s being confirmed in real time, as violent protests have erupted once again, this time in reaction to President Trump’s renewed effort to deport criminal illegal immigrants.
🔥 Just This Year: The Riots Return
Just this year, Los Angeles, Chicago, and New York have once again erupted into mob violence, this time with protestors and agitators marching in defense of criminal illegal immigrants—many of whom are facing deportation for serious offenses including gang affiliation, drug trafficking, violent assault, and even sexual crimes.
Rather than acknowledge the legitimate authority of the state to remove dangerous individuals from our communities, liberal activists and politicians have framed these deportations as acts of cruelty, equating the removal of violent criminals with general hostility toward all immigrants.
This is a false narrative.
It is propaganda.
And it is deeply unjust.
🧨 A Compassion Without Truth
Yes, many protestors claim to be motivated by compassion. But this is a selective and misplaced compassion, grounded in a liberal mythology that refuses to distinguish between lawful immigration and criminality.
It is one thing to show mercy to the stranger. It is another thing entirely to shield those who r**e, assault, steal, or murder, simply because their deportation might challenge political sensibilities.
Where is the compassion for the families torn apart by gang violence?
Where is the compassion for the victims of sanctuary city policies that released repeat offenders back into vulnerable neighborhoods?
Where is the compassion for citizens whose votes are diluted, whose voices are ignored, and whose communities are collapsing under the weight of manipulated representation?
It seems there is no compassion for them.
🧮 How Sanctuary States Are Gaming the System
The United States Constitution requires that congressional seats and Electoral College votes be apportioned according to population. But it makes no distinction between citizens and non-citizens.
This means:
States like California, New York, and Illinois—home to the most aggressive sanctuary policies—receive additional political power because they house large undocumented populations, even if many are here illegally.
Those states gain seats in Congress and more votes in presidential elections, while law-abiding states with smaller undocumented populations lose representation and funding.
The refusal to secure the border—even during the COVID lockdowns—was not an oversight. It was part of a long-term strategy to swell the numbers of sanctuary jurisdictions, ensuring they would benefit politically, financially, and electorally.
That’s why the border never closed.
That’s why protests rage over deportations.
And that’s why criminal illegal immigrants are being rebranded as "victims."
🛑 What COVID Revealed
Perhaps the most revealing aspect of the entire crisis was this:
We were told it was too dangerous to gather for Easter—but not too dangerous to allow tens of thousands of unvetted individuals to cross the border.
Americans were prohibited from:
Attending church
Visiting their dying parents
Hosting weddings or funerals
Sending their children to school
But border crossings?
Still open.
Still protected.
Still feeding the Census count in sanctuary cities.
This wasn't compassion. It was manipulation—an abuse of mercy for the sake of political gain.
🕊️ A Christian Response: Compassion with Justice
As a bishop in the Orthodox Christian tradition, I say this with humility and conviction:
We must love the immigrant, including the undocumented. But we must not become blind to truth in the name of sentimental compassion.
The Scriptures command us to care for the stranger, the widow, and the orphan. But they also call us to uphold justice, to protect the innocent, and to restrain evil.
Christians must not fall prey to reactionary nationalism, nor to false mercy that excuses violence and undermines law.
We are not called to hate.
We are not called to fear.
We are called to truthful love—a love that protects, that discerns, and that upholds both grace and order.
🗳️ A Path Forward: Reforms That Reflect Justice
The time has come to act—not out of rage, but out of righteous clarity:
✅ 1. Enact Voter ID Laws Nationwide
To protect the voice of every legal citizen, we must require voter identification. This is not oppression—it is justice. Every vote must count equally.
🛑 2. Reform the Census
Illegal immigrants should not be counted for political apportionment. Public services may still require inclusive data, but representation in Congress and the Electoral College must reflect citizenship, not sanctuary manipulation.
🔒 3. Secure the Border with Law and Love
We must welcome the stranger through lawful means. A secure border is not a wall of hate—it is a gateway of justice, ensuring that those who come here do so with respect for our laws and our people.
📣 A Final Plea to the Church and the Nation
We are witnessing a nation that:
Tolerates violent mobs but punishes prayerful citizens.
Defends criminality while ignoring its victims.
Rewards defiance of the law while shaming those who seek justice.
This is not sustainable.
It is not moral.
And it is not Christian.
Let us grieve, yes. But let us not grow weary. Let us rise—with grace, with truth, and with holy courage—to be a voice for those who are forgotten:
The victims.
The law-abiding citizens.
The children of broken neighborhoods.
The quiet faithful who long for order and peace.
✝️ In Closing
We must remember:
Justice without mercy is cruelty.
Mercy without truth is deception.
But truth and love together—these are the marks of God’s people.
Let us seek a nation that reflects that holy balance.
Let us pray for leaders with courage.
Let us speak with compassion, but never compromise.
And let us never forget the words of our Lord:
“You will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.” (John 8:32)
+Bishop Michael Callahan
Diocese of Phoenix, Arizona
St. Nicholas Holy Orthodox Catholic and Apostolic Church of America
𝑭𝒐𝒍𝒍𝒐𝒘𝒆𝒓𝒔.