https://www.facebook.com/1417860988500706/

Koinonia News, 216 South 124th Avenue, Avondale, AZ (2025)

10/13/2025

Successful Peace Negotiations in the Middle East: A Time for Thanksgiving and Reflection

By + Bishop Michael-Zachaeous

Koinonia News – October 13, 2025

⸻

A Moment Worthy of Thanksgiving

In an age too often marked by division and strife, moments of reconciliation deserve to be celebrated. The recent and historic peace negotiations in the Middle East, culminating in the release of hostages and a cessation of hostilities, have brought renewed hope to millions.

As Orthodox Christians, we pause to give thanks to Almighty God for this fragile but profound step toward peace — and to acknowledge the diligent leadership of President Donald Trump, whose tireless diplomatic efforts helped make these negotiations a reality.

Whether one agrees or disagrees with his politics, it is right and proper to recognize any leader who works toward the preservation of life and the pursuit of peace. For the Lord Himself taught:

“Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God.” — Matthew 5:9

⸻

1. Peace Through the Eyes of Faith

The Orthodox Church has always prayed “for the peace of the whole world, the good estate of the holy Churches of God, and the union of all.” True peace, however, can never rest solely upon treaties or political accords; it must begin in the heart.

Yet we must not discount the temporal good that such agreements bring. Every ceasefire spares families from grief; every release of captives mirrors, however faintly, the divine mercy that frees humanity from bo***ge to sin. When nations lay down their weapons, even for a season, the hand of God is at work.

⸻

2. The Church’s Understanding of Israel and God’s Covenant

Within Orthodox theology, the name Israel bears a deeper significance than national identity. From the Apostolic age, the Church has understood herself to be the “Israel of God” (Galatians 6:16) — the people formed by faith, not by bloodline, and grafted into the living covenant through baptism and the Holy Spirit.

“There is no longer Jew or Greek… for you are all one in Christ Jesus.” — Galatians 3:28

This is not a rejection of the Jewish people, but the continuation and fulfillment of God’s ancient promise. The Fathers — St. Justin Martyr, St. Irenaeus, and St. John Chrysostom among them — taught that the Old Covenant was a foreshadowing of Christ’s redeeming work. The Church, then, is not a “replacement” for Israel but its divine fulfillment — the flowering of the same root in the light of Christ.

⸻

3. A Contrast with Modern Interpretations

Many modern denominational Christians, particularly those shaped by Evangelical and Dispensational thought, see the modern State of Israel as a prophetic key to end-time events. They anticipate the rebuilding of the Temple and view political developments as signs of the Messiah’s imminent return.

Orthodoxy does not share this view. The Church has never divided God’s redemptive plan into separate covenants for Israel and the Gentiles. There is one Lord, one faith, one baptism — one Body of Christ. Our eschatology is not centered on geopolitics but on the universal restoration of all creation when Christ returns in glory.

“For all the promises of God find their Yes in Him.” — 2 Corinthians 1:20

⸻

4. The True Temple and the True Peace

The Orthodox Church teaches that Christ Himself is the Temple, and that His Body, the Church, is the dwelling place of God among men. Thus, the rebuilding that matters most is not of stone and mortar but of hearts reconciled to God. Every Eucharist renews that peace; every act of forgiveness lays another cornerstone of His Kingdom.

Peace in the Middle East, therefore, is not merely a political milestone — it is an opportunity for spiritual reflection. It invites all peoples to contemplate the Prince of Peace, who alone can reconcile heaven and earth.

⸻

5. Gratitude and Caution

We give heartfelt thanks for this diplomatic success and pray that it endures. Yet we remain vigilant: earthly peace is fragile. History reminds us that treaties may falter and human ambition may undo goodwill. The Church’s role is not to anoint political systems but to call all leaders to righteousness and to pray that their decisions be guided by divine wisdom.

Our gratitude for President Trump’s efforts — and for all who labored toward reconciliation — does not rest on partisanship but on the conviction that peacemaking is holy work. May this spirit of reconciliation ripple across borders, bringing healing to a wounded region.

⸻

6. The Orthodox Response

The Orthodox Christian response is threefold:
1. Prayer — for the peace of Jerusalem and for all who dwell in the Holy Land.
2. Thanksgiving — that hostilities have ceased and captives have been freed.
3. Witness — to remind the world that all peace, to be lasting, must be rooted in the Cross.

As St. Isaac the Syrian taught:

“Make peace with yourself, and heaven and earth will make peace with you.”

⸻

7. The Work of True Reconciliation

We stand today at a threshold — a moment when diplomacy has triumphed and war-weary peoples glimpse the light of a new dawn. Let us give thanks for this merciful pause in violence and pray that it becomes a lasting peace.

May this moment remind the world that only in Christ Jesus, our Peace, can humanity be fully reconciled to God and to one another.

“Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace, goodwill among men.” — Luke 2:14

⸻

A Prayer for Peace in the Middle East

O Lord Jesus Christ, Prince of Peace and Savior of the world,
who didst stretch out Thine arms upon the Cross to reconcile all things in heaven and on earth,
look now with mercy upon the peoples of the Middle East — the lands where Thou didst walk, teach, and redeem mankind.

Still the voice of anger, silence the instruments of war, and soften the hearts of those hardened by hatred or fear.
Bless all leaders and peacemakers, especially those who have labored diligently to end bloodshed and restore hope.
Grant them wisdom to preserve what has been achieved, courage to stand for truth, and humility to serve the cause of justice.

Remember, O Lord, the captives and refugees, the widowed and the orphaned,
and all who suffer through the folly of man.
Bring healing to every wounded soul, and renew the hearts of all peoples with the fire of Thy divine love.

Strengthen Thy Holy Church throughout the world to be a beacon of reconciliation,
that in every nation Thy children may learn to love one another as Thou hast loved us.
For Thou alone art the true Peace of the world, O Christ our God,
and to Thee we ascribe all glory, together with Thine eternal Father and Thine all-holy, good, and life-creating Spirit,
now and ever, and unto the ages of ages. Amen.

⸻

+ Bishop Michael-Zachaeous
Holy Orthodox Catholic and Apostolic Church of America
Diocese of Phoenix
Donald J. Trump JD Vance Bishop Michael Callahan Authentic Faith Series.

09/13/2025

🕊️ Violence, Vigil, and the Voice of the Church: An Orthodox Reflection on Public Safety and Christian Witness

“We must not become easily triggered. We must remain a prayerful people, offering a contra-voice when needed—never repaying rage with rage.”
— Bishop Michael

⸻

In our present cultural moment, public safety has become a battleground—not just of streets and statistics, but of narratives, accusations, and deeply divided ideologies. The recent wave of gang violence, civil unrest, and the tragic murder of Charlie Kirk has again forced us to reckon with not only the fragility of peace but the tone of our collective response.

In a previous reflection, I pointed out the stark contrast between how many on the political Left have responded to perceived injustices—with looting, rioting, and arson—and how many on the Right responded to Charlie Kirk’s murder—a shocking assassination of a high-profile Christian public intellectual—with prayer vigils, peaceful gatherings, and public mourning.

This is not a partisan point. It is a moral one.

⸻

🛑 Safety Is Not a Partisan Issue

The protection of innocent life is not the property of the Right or the Left. It is a sacred obligation of government and a shared concern for all people of good will. When cities become war zones, when young people die in crossfire, when local officials seem more committed to political positioning than public protection—someone must act.

If the President, acting within the constitutional authority granted to him, moves to safeguard vulnerable communities, the Church must not respond with suspicion simply because such action defies local political preferences.

⸻

✝️ The Orthodox Response: Peace, Not Passivity

It is tempting, in a climate of escalating rhetoric and ideological fearmongering, to fall into the same reactive traps as the rest of society. But as Orthodox Christians, we are called to something higher.

We are not to become easily triggered.
We are not to repay outrage with outrage.
We are not to allow our witness to Christ to be co-opted by media cycles or political factions.

When Charlie Kirk was murdered, the faithful responded with candles, hymns, and prayers. No fires were lit. No windows were broken. No police precincts were torched.

This is the spirit of Orthodox witness: firm, peaceful, rooted in truth, and unshakable in charity.

⸻

🧭 Discernment in the Age of Confusion

It is troubling, though sadly not surprising, that some have drawn outrageous comparisons between current law enforcement efforts or National Guard deployments and the tactics of N**i Germany. These kinds of accusations are not only historically absurd, but they are spiritually harmful. They stir up fear, obscure the truth, and dishonor the real victims of tyranny.

We are not witnessing the rise of fascism. We are witnessing an attempt—flawed perhaps, but earnest—to restore order in cities where lawlessness is destroying lives.

Orthodox Christians must discern carefully and resist the cultural pressure to catastrophize everything. We must watch and pray—not panic and post.

⸻

🙏 What Then Must We Do?

1. We must pray.

Prayer is not passivity. It is our greatest act of trust in a sovereign God. We pray for victims of violence, for our leaders, and for our own hearts to remain soft and watchful.

2. We must discern.

Not all causes are righteous. Not all outrage is holy. We must look past headlines and algorithms and seek what is true, what is just, and what is of God.

3. We must speak carefully.

Speak when needed. But let every word be seasoned with grace. We must be a contra-voice, yes—but never a clanging cymbal of wrath or reactivity.

4. We must never return violence for violence.

Christ went to the Cross without retaliation. The martyrs bled without striking back. We are not called to defeat the world’s violence by matching its fury—we are called to overcome evil with good.

⸻

🕯️ In Memory of Charlie Kirk

Let the response to Charlie Kirk’s death stand as a witness to the world. His supporters mourned him not with destruction, but with dignity.

With candles instead of cocktails.
With prayer instead of provocation.
With broken hearts, not broken windows.

And that, brothers and sisters, is a more powerful revolution than any angry mob could ever stage.

⸻

✝️ A Final Word

This is not about Left versus Right. This is not about politics at all.

This is about how the Church of Christ will respond when the world burns, when the truth is twisted, and when our neighbors live in fear.

We must not be easily triggered.
We must not fear standing for what is right.
We must never lose our peace, or our prayer, or our love for those made in the image of God.

“The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.”
— John 1:5

⸻

📿 A Prayer for Public Peace

O Lord, source of all peace and justice,
Look upon our land with mercy.
Bring rest to the weary, protection to the vulnerable, and wisdom to those in authority.
Give Your Church courage to speak and grace to love, that we may reflect Your kingdom even in a fallen world.
Let us be light-bearers in this dark hour.
In the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Amen.
𝑭𝒐𝒍𝒍𝒐𝒘𝒆𝒓𝒔.

Charlie Kirk Matt Walsh Turning Point USA Donald J. Trump JD Vance Ben Shapiro Bishop Michael Callahan

09/12/2025

When Debate Yields to Violence: Reflections on the Killing of Charlie Kirk

By +Bishop Michael (IBK) for Koinonia News

A Time of Turmoil and Reflection

The last few days have been filled with turmoil for many of us. We are holding together two somber realities: the annual memorial of 9/11, when our nation remembers thousands of innocent lives lost to terrorism, and now the shocking murder of Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University. In the aftermath of these events, I invite you to pause. Take a moment to reflect on the good and righteousness in your own life. Say a prayer. Spend time with your loved ones. Do not allow the constant news cycle to rob you of your humanity or your hope.

My Own Connection to Charlie Kirk

I have been following Charlie Kirk’s work for several years. In my view, he was one of the sharpest minds of our age — able to be challenged on nearly any contemporary topic and respond in a calm, reasoned, and factual manner. While not Orthodox, he consistently used his public platform to advocate for principles he believed to be moral and culturally renewing. He was articulate and bold in presenting his convictions, and for that he was sometimes applauded, sometimes vilified, and now, tragically, killed.

A Call to Prayer

As a pastor and bishop, I am asking you to join me in prayer for the repose of Charlie’s soul. Pray that our merciful Lord will forgive his sins and receive him into eternal life. Pray also for his grieving family and friends, and even for the soul of the shooter, that God might grant him repentance and transformation.

In my own prayerful hope, I ask that God, in His mercy, will view Charlie’s witness and his death as that of a martyr — one who stood for moral truth in the face of hatred. We cannot declare this ourselves; that belongs to God alone. But we can commend him to the Lord with hope, asking that his witness and his death may not be in vain.

Lamenting the Spirit of Evil

This tragedy is not just about one man. It reveals the deeper spiritual battle in our culture. Saint Paul reminds us, “we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, powers, the rulers of the darkness of this world” (Eph. 6:12). The gleeful celebrations of his death by some on social media and in public posts are a chilling sign of that darkness. A city council member in Oregon posted that Kirk’s death “brightened up my day.” Florida teachers are under investigation for making light of the tragedy online. Viral posts — some authentic, some false — circulated with mocking phrases.

As Christians, we must also acknowledge that whenever hatred or mockery greets the death of any person, no matter his or her politics, it grieves the heart of God. This spirit of evil does not belong to one party or ideology; it slithers wherever human hearts give in to rage and contempt. It whispers that opponents are not our neighbors but our enemies, not image-bearers of God but targets. We must name this spirit for what it is and resist it with prayer, fasting, and steadfast love.

Longing for a Turning Point in the American Dialectic

My heartfelt longing is that Charlie’s death might itself become a “Turning Point” in the American dialectic. By “dialectic” I mean the shared process of seeking truth through reasoned discussion — a back-and-forth exchange of ideas, arguments, and counter-arguments that refines understanding rather than destroys it. This is the lifeblood of a healthy republic and a healthy Church: the ability to disagree without hatred, to debate without dehumanizing, to honor each other’s dignity even in conflict.

If this tragedy drives us only deeper into our trenches, then darkness has won another battle. But if it drives us to examine our own hearts and speech — to rediscover our common humanity — then perhaps this sorrow can become the seed of renewal.

A Christian Response

Orthodox Christianity calls us to something radically different. We are commanded to “love your enemies” (Matt. 5:44) and to grieve even for the death of the wicked (Ezek. 33:11). We are to pray for those who persecute us. Our Lord Himself prayed for His executioners.

This does not mean abandoning truth or ceasing to speak plainly. Charlie Kirk did not. But it means rejecting the spirit of revenge and mockery that now stalks our civic life. It means naming violence for what it is, while also refusing to dehumanize those who oppose us.

A Call to Reflection

Charlie Kirk’s death is a tragedy. The celebrations that followed in some quarters are a scandal. Yet the real question for us, as believers, is whether we will allow this event to harden our hearts or deepen our commitment to Christ’s way.

I urge you to step back from the brink: to pray for Charlie Kirk’s soul, for his family, and for the conversion of those who would rejoice at his death. To pray also for the shooter, that God might bring him to repentance. And to recommit ourselves to the first principles of the Faith — loving God above all, and our neighbors (even ideological foes) as ourselves.

This is the narrow path Christ described. It is harder than outrage, harder than mockery, harder even than vengeance. But it is the only path that leads to life.

⸻

A Prayer for Charlie Kirk and for Our Nation

O Lord Jesus Christ, Son of the Living God,
We commend to You the soul of Your servant Charlie, who bore witness to many truths in a hostile world.

Forgive his sins, receive him into the place of light and peace, and, if it be Your will, crown him among Your martyrs who held fast to moral truth.

Comfort his family and all who mourn him.
Have mercy also upon the soul of the one who killed him; grant repentance, forgiveness, and conversion.

Dispel the spirit of hatred and evil from our land; heal our divisions and turn our hearts back to You.

Let this tragedy become a true turning point for our country — a moment when hearts are softened, discourse restored, and neighbor-love renewed.

Strengthen us to love our enemies, to speak truth with courage, and to walk the narrow way that leads to life everlasting.

For You are the Resurrection and the Life, and to You we give glory, together with Your Father who is without beginning and Your All-Holy, Good and Life-Creating Spirit, now and ever and unto the ages of ages. Amen.

+Bishop Michael (IBK)
Charlie Kirk Matt Walsh Ben Shapiro Turning Point USA JD Vance Donald J. Trump 𝑭𝒐𝒍𝒍𝒐𝒘𝒆𝒓𝒔.

09/11/2025

THEY NEVER LET A CRISIS GO TO WASTE

The Left’s Predictable Gun Control Demands After the Murder of Charlie Kirk

The nation is grieving after the tragic murder of conservative leader Charlie Kirk — a man known not only for his firm convictions, but also for his calm, reasoned defense of liberty in a time of chaos. He was taken from us by a rooftop sniper using a bolt-action long rifle, not a so-called “assault weapon.”

But as always, before the facts were fully known, leftist politicians — led by figures like Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez — leapt to the microphone to push for more gun control. Never mind that the weapon used didn’t fall under the categories they love to vilify. Never mind that the shooter clearly ignored the multitude of laws already in place. This was a political opportunity — and they seized it.

It is, as Rahm Emanuel once said, “a terrible thing to waste a good crisis.” And waste it they did not.

⸻

🔄 Charlie Kirk Faced These Arguments Often — And Exposed Their Flaws Calmly

Charlie Kirk was no stranger to the emotionally charged, logically hollow arguments that dominate the gun control debate.

Time and again, he stood face-to-face with anti–Second Amendment activists on college campuses and in media interviews. He never raised his voice. He never shouted them down. But he always exposed the internal contradictions in their reasoning.

When confronted with the usual talking points — “weapons of war,” “no one needs an AR-15,” “more laws equal less crime” — Charlie would respond with calm clarity:

“If gun laws worked, Chicago would be the safest city in America.”
“Criminals don’t follow laws. That’s what makes them criminals.”
“If your goal is to reduce gun deaths, why are you focused on banning weapons used in a tiny fraction of them?”

Perhaps most notably, Charlie often asked:

“There are far more deaths caused by motor vehicles than fi****ms. Should we ban cars? Should we outlaw driving?”

This simple analogy exposed the cognitive dissonance of the Left. They accept freedom with risk in nearly every area of life — cars, alcohol, swimming pools, power tools — but when it comes to fi****ms, they demand total regulation and zero tolerance.

It’s not logic. It’s ideology.

⸻

🔒 America Already Has Gun Laws — Plenty of Them

The United States doesn’t suffer from a lack of gun control. It suffers from a lack of moral control, legal accountability, and cultural clarity.

We have:
• Background checks
• Waiting periods
• Licensing in many states
• Red flag laws
• Safe storage mandates
• Magazine limits
• So-called “assault weapon” bans in multiple jurisdictions

And yet, mass shootings, urban homicides, and now political assassinations still happen. Why?

Because these laws are not aimed at criminals. They are aimed at the law-abiding.

Criminals don’t obey magazine limits. Gang members don’t submit to background checks. Political assassins don’t pause to ask whether their rifle complies with local statutes.
But you do. Your freedoms are what they’re trying to limit.

⸻

🧱 The True Cost of Liberty — Charlie Knew It

Charlie Kirk understood what so many refuse to admit: Liberty always carries a cost.

You cannot eliminate all risk without also eliminating freedom. That’s why he said:

“The Second Amendment is not about deer hunting. It’s about preserving the balance of power between people and government — and ensuring that your right to protect your life is never contingent on the state.”

If we banned everything that posed a risk — if safety were the highest virtue — we would all be locked in padded rooms with helmets. But that’s not freedom. That’s slavery to fear.

Charlie warned us about that. And now, in the wake of his death, we see the very same voices he challenged using his assassination to push for the very ideas he stood against.

⸻

🎯 The Gun Used Doesn’t Fit the Narrative — So They Ignore It

Let’s be clear:
The weapon used to murder Charlie Kirk was not a semi-automatic AR-15.
It was not high-capacity.
It was not an “assault weapon” by any legal or practical standard.

It was a bolt-action rifle — a common, legal, and widely owned firearm used for hunting, sport shooting, and home defense.
So how does banning AR-15s stop something like this?

It doesn’t. And they know it.
But the facts don’t matter when the agenda is power.

⸻

🔥 Don’t Let the Left Use Charlie’s Death to Advance Tyranny

Charlie Kirk’s death should be a wake-up call — not to disarm the innocent, but to wake up the faithful.
• This was a political assassination.
• The shooter violated laws already on the books.
• The Left’s proposed laws would have done nothing to stop it.

What they will do, however, is make it harder for you to defend your family, your church, or your community.

Charlie carried the banner of truth and liberty without apology. He confronted lies with clarity, not anger. He bore the cost of discipleship and freedom — and now he has paid the ultimate price.

We owe it to him — and to every freedom-loving citizen — not to surrender in the face of fear or manipulation.

⸻

✝️ Final Word from Koinonia News

In a world of emotional politics and ideological agendas, Charlie Kirk stood for reason, freedom, and faith.
He calmly confronted the madness of anti-liberty voices, not with rage, but with facts, principles, and unshakable truth.

Let us do the same.

We don’t honor Charlie’s memory by passing laws that would have stripped him of the very rights he defended.
We honor him by refusing to be bullied into surrender.
We honor him by speaking truth — boldly, compassionately, and without apology.

⸻

In memory of Charlie Kirk — a bold cross-bearer, a defender of liberty, and a calm voice of reason in an age of madness.

✝️ Koinonia News
Charlie Kirk
𝑭𝒐𝒍𝒍𝒐𝒘𝒆𝒓𝒔.
Matt Walsh

09/11/2025

✝️ Vigil or Violence?

What Our Reactions Reveal About Our Worldview

By Bishop Michael Callahan | Koinonia News | Social Commentary

In recent years, America has witnessed a deep and undeniable divide—not merely political or cultural, but spiritual. This divide is not only about policies or ideologies, but about how people respond in moments of loss, tragedy, and injustice. And that contrast was once again made painfully clear in the aftermath of the assassination of conservative commentator and unapologetic Christian voice, Charlie Kirk.

When Charlie Kirk was gunned down at a public event — a man who fearlessly proclaimed Christ at rallies, debates, and college campuses — there was no looting, no fires, no broken glass. Instead, there were prayer vigils. Memorials. Tributes. Candlelight gatherings across the country. Hearts were broken, but cities remained intact. The faithful turned not to Molotov cocktails but to the Cross of Christ.

Compare that with the aftermath of the tragic deaths of George Floyd in 2020 and Freddie Gray in 2015. Whatever one’s view of those cases, what followed was unmistakable: cities ignited in flames. Police precincts burned. Businesses—many Black-owned—were reduced to rubble. Opportunistic chaos masqueraded as justice. And mainstream voices excused it all as “understandable.”

One wonders: when did grief become a license for anarchy?

When George Floyd died, cities were torched. When Freddie Gray died, streets became war zones. But when Charlie Kirk—a Christian, a husband, a young leader—was assassinated, the response was solemn reverence.

Why the stark contrast?

A Matter of Worldview

What we are witnessing is not merely a difference in behavior but a difference in belief.
• One side believes the world is broken and must be torn down to be rebuilt in their image.
• The other believes the world is fallen and must be redeemed through grace, truth, and justice—God’s way, not man’s.

The progressive Left too often views destruction as a tool of progress. The conservative Christian Right, for all its flaws, tends to view suffering as a time for mourning, not mayhem.

While some paint Charlie Kirk as a “polarizing figure,” let’s not forget: he boldly spoke the name of Jesus in the public square. In an era where speaking truth costs everything, Charlie bore that cost. And now, he is gone. Not because he was silenced in debate, but because someone believed he didn’t deserve to speak at all.

Let that sink in.

And yet, in his death, his followers didn’t seek revenge. They sought prayer. They sought peace. They sought Christ.

Whose Voice Are We Listening To?

In a world increasingly ruled by emotionalism, social media mobs, and ideological rage, the reaction to Charlie Kirk’s assassination offers a powerful witness. It reminds us that the fruit of the Spirit is self-control, not destruction. It reminds us that the weapons of our warfare are not carnal but spiritual. And it reminds us that the path to authentic justice begins not in the streets but at the foot of the Cross.

This is not to dismiss legitimate injustices in society. But the Gospel does not excuse chaos in the name of compassion. It calls us to repentance, renewal, and righteous action—grounded in love, not vengeance.

Charlie Kirk may not have worn a collar, but he was undoubtedly a public witness to Christ. He died standing for truth. In the eyes of many believers, that makes him not just a political casualty, but a Christian martyr—a man who did not shrink back from proclaiming Christ, even in the face of mounting hostility.

A Wake-Up Call for the Church

Let his death awaken us, not merely to political realities, but to spiritual ones. Let it remind us that the Church must be ready to stand firm—calmly, confidently, and courageously. And let it be a witness to the watching world that Christians respond differently, because we live by a different Spirit.

We mourn not like those without hope.
We fight not like those without truth.
And we build—not by fire and fury—but by faith.

May God have mercy on our land.
May He receive His servant Charlie into eternal rest.
And may we, too, have the courage to carry the cross—even if it costs us everything.
𝑭𝒐𝒍𝒍𝒐𝒘𝒆𝒓𝒔. Charlie Kirk

09/10/2025

What Is a Woman? When We Lose Sight of Creation’s Order We Lose Sight of Salvation’s Order

For most of Christian history the question “What is a woman?” was not controversial. From Genesis through the Fathers, the answer was taken as self-evident: a woman is an adult human female, part of God’s created order. Today, however, that clarity is clouded by ideologies that insist “woman” is a subjective identity rather than a biological fact. Those who continue to affirm the historic understanding are frequently ridiculed as hateful or bigoted. Yet for Orthodox Christians, speaking this truth is not hatred but fidelity to reality, because when we lose sight of creation’s order we lose sight of salvation’s order.

⸻

Scripture’s Unchanging Truth

The Bible opens with God’s design: “Male and female He created them” (Genesis 1:27). Jesus Himself reaffirmed this: “Have you not read that He who created them from the beginning made them male and female?” (Matthew 19:4). St. Paul taught, “Nevertheless, in the Lord woman is not independent of man nor man of woman… and all things are from God” (1 Corinthians 11:11–12). The sexes are not social inventions but gifts woven into creation itself.

⸻

The Patristic Witness

The Church Fathers echoed Scripture’s clarity:
• St. Irenaeus: “The handiwork of God is the formation of man and woman; the mystery of man is great, but that of woman is no less.”
• St. John Chrysostom: “The woman was not made inferior in essence, but different in order; she was created for the sake of a partnership, not as another kind of being.”
• St. Basil the Great: “The distinction of male and female is not of our choosing but from God, for He who formed us made the one for begetting and the other for bearing.”

For the Church, the categories of male and female are not arbitrary but integral to salvation history.

⸻

Modern Countercurrents: Debates and Documentaries

This once-settled question now sparks fierce public debate. Charlie Kirk, through Turning Point USA campus events, frequently challenges students and professors to define “woman” in a single sentence. What was obvious for millennia now provokes hesitation, evasions, and heated exchanges—showing how deeply society has drifted from shared reality.

Matt Walsh’s 2022 documentary What Is a Woman?, released by The Daily Wire, took the question global. Walsh traveled to interview politicians, medical professionals, activists, and even members of a Maasai tribe. His film exposed how many could not define “woman” without circular reasoning, while he himself gave the historic definition: “an adult human female.” Supporters praised the film for puncturing ideological confusion; critics accused it of bias and transphobia. Either way, it forced the debate into mainstream consciousness and revealed the social cost of telling the truth.

⸻

Why This Matters for Orthodox Christians

Some may ask, Why should Orthodox Christians care about this debate at all? Isn’t it just another culture war?

The answer lies in the title of this article. Orthodoxy teaches that the human body is not incidental to the soul but part of the person God created. Male and female are woven into Scripture, liturgy, and the sacramental mysteries—especially marriage, monasticism, and the veneration of Christ and His Mother. If society can redefine something as basic as “woman,” it becomes easier to dismiss or distort the Church’s teaching on marriage, the priesthood, and the dignity of motherhood and virginity.

As St. Maximus the Confessor warned, “When we lose sight of creation’s order, we lose sight of salvation’s order.” Defending the reality of man and woman is therefore not a political project but an Orthodox imperative. We are not called to mock or hate but to witness to truth with charity. St. Athanasius’s example remains apt: “It is better to suffer wrong for speaking truth than to profit by silence.”

⸻

Conclusion: Speaking the Truth in Love

The controversy over “what is a woman” reveals a deeper spiritual struggle: will we live according to God’s design or according to our own redefinitions? Across Scripture, the Fathers, campus debates with Charlie Kirk, and Matt Walsh’s documentary, one truth prevails with unwavering clarity: a woman is an adult human female. This is not hatred; it is reality. For Orthodox Christians, to speak this truth with charity and conviction is not to join a culture war but to preserve the created and sacramental order entrusted to the Church.
𝑭𝒐𝒍𝒍𝒐𝒘𝒆𝒓𝒔.
Charlie Kirk
Matt Walsh

Koinonia News

10/13/2025

09/13/2025

09/12/2025

09/11/2025

09/11/2025

09/10/2025

Address

Telephone

Website

Alerts

Contact The Business

Shortcuts

Share

Category