07/24/2025
Editor’s Note & Trigger Warning:
The following article contains firsthand accounts of severe childhood trauma, including descriptions of r**e, foster care abuse, medical mistreatment, systemic injustice, wrongful family separation, and gender-based violence. These themes may be distressing or triggering for some readers—especially survivors of similar experiences or those currently involved in the child welfare system.
Please take care while reading. If you or someone you know is experiencing emotional distress or crisis, help is available. Reach out to a trusted mental health provider or call a crisis support line in your area.
Why This Story Matters
This is more than a story—it’s a cry for help from a man still carrying the weight of his stolen childhood. It’s an urgent call to confront a decades-old injustice that continues to haunt an entire family.
The author, Ryan Michaels, shares this article in solidarity with a survivor named Prentice Nicholas and his father, Jerry Nicholas. Though Ryan has never met this family in person, he believes—as many of us do—that truth, transparency, and accountability must rise above silence and time.
If you choose to read on, do so with empathy, with courage, and—if you’re in a position of influence—with a willingness to act.
Title: “We Were Children, Not Criminals”: A Son’s Desperate Plea to Reunite a Family and Expose the Truth
By Ryan Michaels
In an email sent with the simple subject line “please help,” a grown son—Prentice Lashaun Nicholas—poured his broken heart into words that no child should ever have to write.
“I remember at five years old being taken away from my mother and father by the police... I don't understand why all of this happened to us. My father and mother never did anything wrong.”
Now an adult, Prentice is pleading for someone—anyone—to investigate the devastating decisions made by Illinois DCFS and the Cook County courts over 30 years ago that tore him and his five siblings from their loving parents, Jerry and Joanne Nicholas.
Backed by disturbing court documents and placement forms from 1993, Prentice’s story raises urgent questions about systemic failures, trauma inflicted in foster care, and how justice was never served for him or his siblings. Each child’s name—Princess, Wendy, Carolyn, Jerry Jr., Christopher, and Prentice—appears in state records that authorized their removal and placement in state custody. Many of these documents were signed within days or hours of the children’s seizure from their home, prompting suspicions that paperwork was used to retroactively justify what Prentice and Jerry describe as a legally unsupported raidimage.
In his letter, Prentice describes witnessing the r**e of his sister in foster care, being drugged until dizzy and disoriented, and enduring years of separation under a fabricated last name.
One of the most heartbreaking elements: neither he nor his siblings understand why they were taken. Prentice begs for answers from DCFS Director Heidi Mueller and Cook County Public Guardian Charles Golbert:
“Why didn’t our parents come and get us out of here? Why didn’t the lawyers help us go home? What did our parents do wrong? Why were we punished like this?”
He closes his message with an urgent appeal: investigate the lawsuit allegedly filed in their names—one he claims his family never knew about. “Please find out about this lawsuit,” he pleads. “Because why don’t our parents even know about it?”
A Call to Action: If I Can Help, So Can You
My name is Ryan Michaels. I’m just a random guy from Maine who runs a grassroots campaign for CPS accountability. I didn’t know Jerry Nicholas. He found me on social media and asked for help. I listened. I looked at the documents. I heard his son’s voice crying out for answers—and now, I can’t turn away.
If someone thousands of miles away with no prior connection can volunteer to elevate this story, then surely those in power—those in Illinois who are sworn to protect families—can do even more.
I am asking every legislator, every reporter, and every official reading this to do what’s right. Look at the evidence. Speak to Jerry Nicholas. Speak to his son. Reopen the case. Audit the money. And most of all—bring truth and healing to this family before it’s too late.
Because the children are no longer children. But they are still waiting to be heard.
CPS Accountability MovementABC World News Tonight with David MuirPortland Press HeraldFox NewsWMBF NewsThe Bangor Daily News