08/23/2025
"One of the world's cruelest instruments of torture, the Buffalo Trolley, became one with General Custer last night in a belated last stand in the Broadway-Fillmore area." CE 7/2/1950
First electrified in 1889 the once proud Street rail system met an inglorious end.
The International Railway Company (IRC) was formed February 20, 1902 bringing together seven area trolley companies, and subsequently acquired six more companies. It operated, at its peak, 27 city trolley lines in Buffalo, city service in Lockport and in Niagara Falls. Interurban lines ran between Buffalo and Lancaster-Depew, Buffalo and Niagara Falls, and Buffalo and Lockport-Olcott.
In addition it owned the Canadian line from Niagara Falls, Ont., to Lewiston, as well as three bridges between the United States and Canada in the Niagara Falls area. In 1918 the IRC opened the new High Speed line to Niagara Falls which eventually replaced the old line. Early in its history the company came under the control of Mitten Management, a transportation management company.
Though the IRC was still a large operating company in 1941, the trolley operation was a small part of the action. Gone were the interurbans, the Niagara Falls and Lockport city service, the Canadian rail operation, and more than half of the Buffalo city routes. The entire west side had been converted to bus, and the plans were to convert completely by no later than 1950 and before, if they could raise money for the necessary buses.
The remaining street car operations were the; 8-MAIN, 9-PARKSIDE-ZOO, 13-KENSINGTON, 18-JEFFERSON, and 12-EAST UTICA lines operating from the Cold Spring barn. Routes 4-BROADWAY, 24- GENESEE, 2-CLINTON, 6-SYCAMORE, 16-SOUTH PARK, 1-WILLIAM, and 15-SENECA ran out of the Broadway car house. Long line 23-FILLMORE-HERTEL operated mostly from the Broadway barn with a few cars coming out of the almost entirely bus Hertel barn. The company still operated freight service from North Tonawanda to Lockport on the Lockport inter-urban line.
The IRC under Mitten Management, never reinvested in maintenance or new rolling stock. The system slowly fell apart, and Buffalonians grew to hate it. By 1950, the streetcar system was beyond repair -- the newest streetcars in the fleet were cars from the late 1910s, the track was in ruins, and pretty much the whole streetcar infrastructure needed to be rebuilt.
By 1947, with pressure from all sides, the International Railway had been thrown into bankruptcy, the Mitten Management contract broken and trustees had been appointed by the courts to try to bring some sort of financial order into the company . They studied, operated the lines, bused trolley lines, and finally gave a report. The result was a new organization, the Niagara Frontier Transit System(NFT). This company took over the operations and assets with the exception of the Lockport freight line, and all equipment of the trolley operation, on May 31, 1950.
Plans were announced to discontinue all trolley operation. On the evening of June 19, 1950 the three Cold Spring barn lines were abandoned with ceremony. Three cars were started from the end of the Main St. line, two from the end of Kensington, and one from the end of the Parkside - Zoo line. These cars merged into a six car procession at Main and Ferry and proceeded to the foot of Main Street. The cars were decorated with bunting and carried invited guests plus any rail-fans that could get aboard. After final pictures, the passengers were put aboard the new replacement buses and driven back to the ends of the respective lines.
On July 1, 1950, similar ceremonies, decorations, and guests rang out the old on the three east side lines of Fillmore,Broadway, and Genesee and it was all over. (read account of the celbration in the picture section) The cars were run to the Hertel yard to await possible sale, but finding no takers, they were burned and scrapped. Not a Buffalo trolley was saved.
(read account of the celebration and trolley parade in the picture section)