05/21/2026
Local Man Buys Former Market to Protect Market Share.
CARMI, IL — In a move city officials described as “totally normal small-town business activity” and residents described as “wait, he owns what now?”, a local businessman has reportedly continued his quiet quest to become the final boss of Carmi liquor sales.
According to the actual local news, (WRUL) he owns Pundrakes, East Side Package, Rock Bottom, and the property formerly known as Fifth Street Market, which is roughly the Carmi business equivalent of landing on three railroads, both utilities, and then asking if anybody is using Boardwalk.
The controversy began after Fifth Street Market had previously pursued a liquor license so it could add gaming. Then he purchased the property and explained he did so to protect market share, which is the polite business term for “I saw competition coming and hit it with a folding chair before it got through the door.”
He reportedly said Walmart getting a liquor license caused a 15–20% drop in sales, a development that sent shockwaves through Carmi’s delicate ecosystem of beer, scratch-offs, gaming machines, and men named Randy standing outside with hand rolled ci******es.
“It’s not a monopoly,” said one imaginary city official, nervously turning the Carmi Monopoly board face down. “It’s just one man owning several alcohol-adjacent properties while another guy has to ask permission to open a convenience store with gaming. Completely different.”
The city council recently amended the liquor ordinance after someone expressed interest in opening a convenience/dollar store with gaming. This reportedly means "someone' can return in June to formally request the newly created license, assuming there is still a license available and it hasn’t already been purchased defensively and placed in a locked drawer beside the Fifth Street Market sign.
Residents say they support local business but are beginning to wonder how many stores one man can own before the town starts issuing him a tiny top hat and a cane.
“I went in for a loaf of bread, a Pepsi, and some paper towels,” said one resident. “Somehow I ended up buying Busch Light, losing $40 in a machine, and being told the grocery aisle was coming soon to a different building he also owns.”
City leaders insisted the ordinance change was about fairness, opportunity, and economic development, not about turning every empty storefront in Carmi into a liquor-license chess match.
At press time, the Carmi Monopoly board had been updated again. Fifth Street Market is now marked “Protected Market Share,” Pundrakes has been upgraded to a hotel, and the Community Chest card simply says: “A new competitor appears. Buy property immediately.”