08/25/2026
🚨 PUBLIC RECORDS: Commissioner Cara Keys apparently thinks county government should revolve around her kickball schedule.
Commissioner Cara Keys has cultivated a likable public image, but these newly obtained emails give Jefferson County residents a very different look at how she behaves behind the scenes.
The dispute? A voluntary employee kickball game.
When Keys discovered the game conflicted with her Planning Commission meeting, she didn’t simply RSVP “no.”
Instead, she demanded to know why her personal schedule hadn’t been taken into account:
“Did you not take into my schedule on the planning commission when drafting this schedule for kickball?”
Then came this:
“Should I put this on the agenda, so my participation is respected in decisions?”
And she did.
Keys submitted an official Jefferson County Commission agenda request over the scheduling of the kickball game.
But it gets worse.
County Administrator Edwina Benites explained that the event was organized by Culture Task Force volunteers, that attendance by commissioners was entirely optional, and that the event was intended for county employees, not centered around any individual officeholder.
That apparently wasn’t enough.
The following day, Keys sent a lengthy email accusing the County Administrator of a “serious breakdown in our established chain of command” and laying out her expectations going forward:
• “Direct communication”
• “Professional courtesy”
• “No triangulation with other commissioners”
• Bringing potential event dates to commission meetings
All of this… over a voluntary kickball game.
But this isn’t about kickball anymore. It’s about temperament. It’s about entitlement.
And it’s about whether an elected official views county staff and county activities as serving Jefferson County, or herself.
A lot of people in Jefferson County like Cara Keys. That’s precisely why these public records matter.
Voters usually see politicians at meetings, campaign events and carefully managed public appearances.
Emails show you how they act when they think the public isn’t watching.
Read them for yourself and decide:
Is this the kind of leadership Jefferson County voted for?