Emmett Gravel Pit Counter Initiative

Emmett Gravel Pit Counter Initiative Perhaps we can help each other!

This community action page is aimed at keeping Emmett, ID beautiful, sharing environmental concerns, and holding private and industrial parties not aligned with Emmett residents' goals accountable by ensuring our voices are heard. This page was created as a community action page, dedicated to fostering community input on the proposed mineral extraction site at 809 Sunset Drive, Emmett, ID 83617. S

ince the original hearing was delayed and rescheduled to August 26th, 2024, with many Emmett residents unaware of what is going on and how it will affect our small town, in terms of peace and quiet, environmental quality (water, soil, and air quality, as well as resident wildlife, some species of which are listed as endangered), and recreational opportunities at our nearby Gem Island Sports Complex, among others, we will try to let our voices be heard by the Gem County Planning & Zoning Commission at the upcoming postponed hearing. As for myself, I've been a resident of Emmett for the past 25 years, since 1999, and a highly motivated, recently graduated environmental scientist who wants to ensure Emmett's green beautiful spaces don't suffer any more than they already do.

11/15/2024

Hello, everyone.

I've been quite busy, lately, and haven't been as active on FB. However, in light of the water table concerns and well water levels and/or production rates, which could be affected by the McReynolds and Dwyer properties, I'd suggest checking out the Idaho Department of Water Resources website. You can find well driller records on their 'Find a Well Map'. https://idwr.idaho.gov/wells/find-a-well-map/

Instructions:
(Use the layers check boxes as you wish. I didn't see any difference in the well values).
Locate the property and surrounding properties North-Norhwest of the Gem Island Complex. Look for the black and white arrows indicating wells. Clicking on them brings up a little pop up with info. Scroll all the way down within the mini pop-up window. Note well depth, well production rate, static water level, etc. Go to 'Well Docs' toward bottom and click the 'More Info' link. Voilà.

Looking at this, I found info 'Elvin the engineer' couldn't/didn't want to provide (or at least reference as a comparison point) — about wells on or near the discussed properties within the floodplain.

Wells I looked into provided the following data:

First, the well closest to the river (1972) is 29 feet deep, with a 6 foot static water table and a production rate of 20 gal/min.

The casing depth of the well slightly Northeast from this one, marked as located on 'Shady Lane' (1996) is 129 (!) feet with a static water level of 57 and a production rate of 55 gal/min.

The well that feeds the 'Bonnie Laura Subdivision' to the East and downhill from these residences is 40 feet deep, with a static level of 5 ft below the land surface (I looked up what 'static level' actually means because I've seen various wells of over 100 feet total depth with much deeper static levels of 50-60 ft. So, this is how high the accessible water table is, or how close to the surface). It shows a production rate of 400 gal/min, which makes sense as it seems to serve most or all of that subdivision which includes Lilac Lane. It's right next to the adjacent irrigation canal, which must have something to do with water acess and the high production rate, because naturally, water from any sort of stream or non-cement-enhanced canal will follow gravity and percolate down into aquifers below, especially if the canal is full year-round (is it?).

My reasoning for this is that another well CLOSER to the subdivision came up as NOT producing AT ALL. This one was drilled to 60 and then, 145 feet, with NO water flow (1988).

There is an older well West of the subdivision (1974), which shows production rate of 225 gal/min and a static water level of 2 feet, which I'm wondering about as it's not marked as an artesian well because it is a whopping 337 feet deep!!

Of course, I'm not an expert on this in particular, but common sense suggests that if the aquifer at some point carries significantly less water, all of these wells might have to be drilled a lot deeper than the 100-some feet that keep the water at those 50-60 ft below-surface access levels...

I haven't looked at elevations, yet, but I imagine the higher elevation makes it more difficult to reach the aquifer, which might explain why the other Bonnie Laura well stayed dry even at 145 feet depth.

Looking at other surrounding properties to the North and South, anything that is within the floodplain (South), naturally has a static water level of 5-6 feet below the surface, with well depths no more than 45 feet down. Everything uphill from the properties and the river (North) has a significantly deeper drill depth with static water levels between 50-70 feet down. This tells me that while most properties on that bench have deep wells by necessity and currently have regular access to water (if not, I'd like to hear where you live and maybe look into how elevation may affect this, via DM, please!) — it depends on how much water is actively pumped, well below the Bonnie Laura subdivision and properties higher up and to the North, 24/7, for a minimum of 75 days, out of two 40+acre properties in the easy-water-access flood plain area. In other words, we need to find out whether enough negative pressure would be created to allow static water levels to plummet low enough to where wells run dry temporarily or altogether... 🤔

I'll have to refresh my physics and hydraulic pressure knowledge and compare against prospected pumping volumes at the excavation sites (if available; —if someone knows and can save me some time here, I'd be grateful!).

Anyway, I'm trying to be objective — BUT my observations and some dim memories about the fun stuff related to water pressure at different elevations, capillary pressure, etc. make my gut still lean toward 'problematic'...

Let me know what you think, folks!

10/29/2024

I'm sorry for not posting this sooner. Final thoughts after partial discussion of the permit requirements and feasibility concerns, Oct 28, 2024. To be continued and finalized today at 6 pm. See you there!

Per multiple requests, here are the majority of resources (links) for the KNIFE RIVER CORPORATION and MDU RESOURCES (PAR...
10/29/2024

Per multiple requests, here are the majority of resources (links) for the KNIFE RIVER CORPORATION and MDU RESOURCES (PARENT COMPANY) VIOLATIONS, etc.

OSHA Violations for unsafe conduct (main inspection detail - other OSHA links right below are single cases included in this)
https://www.osha.gov/ords/imis/establishment.inspection_detail?id=1591620.015

OSHA Traffic Security Violation 2022 SERIOUS: https://www.osha.gov/ords/imis/establishment.violation_detail?id=1591620.015&citation_id=01001

OSHA Safety Hazard Failure to abate Violation 2022 SERIOUS
https://www.osha.gov/ords/imis/establishment.violation_detail?id=1609341.015&citation_id=01001A

OSHA Safety Hazard Violation 2022 SERIOUS:
https://www.osha.gov/ords/imis/establishment.violation_detail?id=1591620.015&citation_id=01002A

OSHA Safety Hazard Violation 2022 SERIOUS:
https://www.osha.gov/ords/imis/establishment.violation_detail?id=1591620.015&citation_id=01002B

OSHA Repeat Violation A:
https://www.osha.gov/ords/imis/establishment.violation_detail?id=1591620.015&citation_id=02001A

OSHA Repeat Violation B:
https://www.osha.gov/ords/imis/establishment.violation_detail?id=1591620.015&citation_id=02001B

In the NEWS:
Knife River owner fined 3.4 million since 2000 (in 2022) for violations!
https://www.dakotanewsnow.com/video/2022/08/19/violation-tracker-knife-river-owner-fined-million-since/

Crook County, OR Water Pollution Case Info
https://www.opb.org/article/2023/06/13/oreogn-water-pollution-knife-river-corporation-crook-county/

SAFER Web - Company Snapshot KNIFE RIVER CORPORATION - MOUNTAIN WEST
https://safer.fmcsa.dot.gov/query.asp?searchtype=ANY&query_type=queryCarrierSnapshot&query_param=USDOT&query_string=3111936

Google Reviews
https://www.google.com/search?q=knife+river+company%2C+boise%2C+id+reviews&rlz=1C1VDKB_enUS965US965&oq=knife+river+company%2C+boise%2C+id+reviews&gs_lcrp=EgZjaHJvbWUyBggAEEUYOdIBCDY2NzNqMGo3qAIIsAIB&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 #

BBB Complaint (KR is not accreddited by BBB!)
https://www.bbb.org/us/id/boise/profile/ready-mixed-concrete/knife-river-1296-1000013751/complaints

44 Knife River Violation Tracker results
https://violationtracker.goodjobsfirst.org/?company_op=starts&company=Knife+River+&offense_group=&agency_code=

53 MDU Resources (Knife River Parent Company) Violation Tracker results
https://violationtracker.goodjobsfirst.org/?company=MDU+Resources

Knife River Mining Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) Violations/Case Info per Department of Labor Website
https://search.usa.gov/search?affiliate=www.dol.gov&sort_by=&query=%22Knife+River%22

Crook County, OR Water Pollution Case Info
https://www.opb.org/article/2023/06/13/oreogn-water-pollution-knife-river-corporation-crook-county/

INFO about MDU Resources Corporation/Revenue/Stakeholders, etc.
https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/m/NYSE_MDU_2008.pdf

Two federal lawmakers are pushing back on the way a state agency handled complaints about a mining company.

09/23/2024

Gem County Planning and Zoning finally scheduled the new public hearing on the proposed gravel pit(s) on Sunset Drive in Emmett. It's actually split into two hearings, October 28th and 29th at 6:00 p.m. in the Emmett Junior High auditorium. This serves to accommodate the multitude of members of our community wanting to have a say in all this.

PLEASE SHARE this information wide and far, mark your calendars, join our GROUP (https://www.facebook.com/groups/1869617993526881) to discuss, and let's show them what the people really want (or don't, in this case)!!

Addtl. Info:
This concerns the Special Use & Mineral Extraction Permit requested by property owners Mr. and Mrs. McReynolds and applicants Mr. and Mrs. Dwyer, who also happen to own the 40-acre parcel adjacent to the property in question.

If there is a ZOOM Link, I'll add this later, so please stay tuned.
More info will be added as it becomes available.

Send a message to learn more

08/31/2024

This is the Link to the Special Use and Mineral Extraction Permit Packet for 809 Sunset Drive, Emmett, as posted on the Planning & Zoning website.

08/28/2024

I feel it's necessary to provide a double disclaimer regarding the content you find on this page, for legal reasons. I'm a concerned citizen and longtime Emmett resident who also happens to have studied environmental science. Any information on this page is composed from information I am able to access publicly (on- and off-line), opinions and statements gathered from other interested parties, my personal opinion (much of which is informed by scientific facts), and whichever conclusions I draw from all of the above. For my own protection, I will say it's "for entertainment purposes only" -- but feel free to come up with your own conclusions and share them in the comments, after reading the following:

Disclaimer:

**Please take all info rendered on this page with a grain of salt as I am still working on getting all the facts. However, so far, the people of Emmett have not been provided with adequate proof that the operations on the 45 acre property in question won't be a nuisance that brings additional continuous noise, air pollution, water pollution, and traffic into town, lower property values for neighboring land and home owners, and take away the peace and relative quiet of the Gem Island Sports Complex just across the Payette River from there. We also do not know whether one approved permit will or will not lead to other such permits being granted to owners of private properties of significant size and potential environmental impact in the future. I do want to make sure that Emmett residents are fully informed and able to let their voices be heard in matters that can greatly change the character of this small town.**

Address

Emmett, ID
83617

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Emmett Gravel Pit Counter Initiative posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share