10/19/2025
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
October 17, 2025
District Court grants Council’s request for temporary restraining order in the unlawful termination of Controller McCabe
WINDOW ROCK, Ariz. — The Navajo Nation District Court has granted a temporary restraining order, stopping further actions related to Navajo Nation President Buu Nygren’s attempted unlawful removal of Navajo Nation Controller Sean McCabe and the appointment of an “Interim” Controller.
The order, issued by Judge Malcolm Begay on Friday, remains in effect until the preliminary injunction hearing scheduled for Oct. 27. The Court determined that President Nygren’s termination of Controller McCabe and subsequent appointment of Alva R. Tom as “Interim” Controller violated Navajo Nation law, which requires the consent of the Budget and Finance Committee to appoint an Acting Controller.
“The Court’s granting of the TRO is a strong indication that President Nygren broke the law and that the Navajo Nation Department of Justice was wrong in advising OPVP in the wrongful termination. The Council maintains that McCabe is the lawful Controller,” said Speaker Crystalyne Curley.
The temporary restraining order prohibits the President from appointing any Acting Controller without the approval of the Budget and Finance Committee and directs the Office of the Controller to refrain from taking actions under the authority of Alva R. Tom unless her appointment is lawfully ratified and confirmed.
The 25th Navajo Nation Council maintains that the Office of the Controller must operate independently and in full compliance with Navajo Nation statutes to uphold accountability, maintain public trust, and ensure responsible management of the Nation’s financial resources.
# # #