08/31/2025
OPEN LETTER: To Tabitha's Past Connections and the Industry's Failure
HER PAPER TRAIL IS AS CLEAR AS IT IS DAMNING
Bred in Kentucky in 2012 by Sheltowee Farm, Tabitha was sold as a yearling at Keeneland September by Denali Stud for $85,000 to CRESRAN LLC. As a four-year-old she was consigned by Paramount Sales and purchased by Repole, who culled her back through Keeneland in 2018, in foal to his Uncle Mo. Mill Ridge handled the consignment, from there she went to Saratoga Glen Farm in New York. She produced an Uncle Mo foal before being listed online and reportedly "given away." Records show she was covered by Rich Strike in 2026 at Irish Hill Century Farm.
On August 23rd, she was dumped at the Unadilla livestock auction with other "walk-ins"—the term used for horses without identities or paperwork, in other words meant to disappear. She was purchased by broker Brian Moore and now stands tethered in a lot with a deadline to ship – and she will ship to slaughter if not now, soon.
THIS IS NOT ISOLATED IT IS SYTEMIC
This is not an isolated tragedy. The same week David O'Dwyer's purchase of 11 yearlings at the Texas Thoroughbred Association Sale made headlines, Tabitha disappeared into the pipeline. The same weekend Saratoga celebrated the Travers, no New York aftercare organization funded by the NY Thoroughbred Breeding and Development Fund was present at Unadilla. Despite more than $1.3 million in state agency money being issued by NYSTBDF in the name of "aftercare," not a single representative from those organizations was present at Unadilla. Tabitha, and mares like her vanish in plain sight.
The industry loves to shine a spotlight on auctions, brokers, and kill pens as villains. But the deeper truth is this: Thoroughbreds bred by the most powerful farms, agents, and owners in the game—Repole, Darley, John Phillips, Darby Dan, Lane's End, Airdrie, Juddmonte, Live Oak, Kevin Plank, McMahon Farm, Padua, the Ramseys, Three Lyons, Runnymede, Taylor Made—to name only a few, have been repeatedly pulled from auctions and the slaughter pipeline. They have the means, the money, and the resources to properly retire and care for these horses. Why don't they? Why is tracking their cast-offs left to rescues and sanctuaries? Or anyone else to fund but them?
THE SUPPLY CHAIN OF RESPONSIBILITY
As a former breeder and owner, I would be ashamed not to help a horse I knew if found in this situation. These names are not powerless—they are the wealthiest and most celebrated participants in racing today. And not one of them has contributed a dime toward the support of their horses at Unbridled Sanctuary, accredited at the highest level by the Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries.
Why not the TAA? Because we refuse to stay quiet. We speak out about abuse, breakdowns, cruelty, drugging, neglect, and slaughter. And that is the price of honesty in this industry. Yet the proof of integrity is simple: our 65 sanctuary horses—55 of them Thoroughbreds—stand as living testimony to both the scale of this crisis and the refusal of the industry to care for its own.
THE PATTERN IS CLEAR
Tabitha's life is not an exception. These mares are tracked when they win, paraded when they produce, and abandoned when they don't. Papers may change hands, but responsibility does not. If she was valuable enough to stand in a breeding shed, she is valuable enough to deserve a lifeline today.
Unbridled was formed in 2004. We have rescued and secured safety for many hundreds of Thoroughbreds. We have stepped in where the industry has failed, again and again.
THE MOMENT OF TRUTH
And here is the irrefutable truth: Tabitha's fate is the measure of the integrity of her past connections. If those who bred, raced, sold, and profited from her will not step up now, when she needs a lifeline, it reveals she never meant anything beyond what she could earn or produce.
On August 29th, while Mike Repole celebrated winning the million-dollar Grade 1 Pacific Classic in Del Mar with Fierceness, his former mare Tabitha stood on a slaughter-bound lot in Pennsylvania, facing a death sentence. This is the same Tabitha who once carried a foal by his prized stallion Uncle Mo.
THE SOCIAL LICENSE QUESTION
And if the industry will not hold its own participants accountable—if breeders, owners, trainers, and sales agents can abandon horses like Tabitha without consequence—then horse racing has already lost its social license. Those who will not protect the very lives they create should lose the privilege to breed, to race, and to profit from them.
So I ask again: what will you do now?
Susan Kayne
Unbridled Sanctuary
💔 SHARE TO SAVE TABITHA 💔
Tag the connections • SHELTOWEE FARM | CRES RAN LLC | DENALI STUD | PARAMOUNT SALES | MIKE REPOLE | MILL RIDGE SALES | SARATOGA GLEN FARM | BARRACLOUGH FAMILY
Time is running out. Her life depends on it. BloodHorse Paulick Report The New Yorker New York Post The New York Times TDN