
12/12/2023
‘They just kind of stole my money,’ safety deposit box owner fumes after $57k vanished from his vault thanks to the FBI https://ift.tt/615rhdY
Joseph Ruiz from California rented a safety deposit box from US Private Vaults in February 2021 in which he
A MAN lost his life savings for months after an unconstitutional FBI raid of safety deposit boxes, according to a lawsuit.
Joseph Ruiz from California rented a safety deposit box from US Private Vaults in February 2021 in which he kept all of his money.
Joseph Ruiz rented a safety deposit box from US Private Vaults and his life savings of $57,000 was seized in an FBI raid that may have been unconstitutional[/caption]
A class-action lawsuit has been filed on behalf of customers who had their belongings taken by the FBI during the raid[/caption]
An indictment alleged that the safety deposit box company and its customers were money laundering and allowing drug dealers to store fentanyl, guns, and cash.
On March 22, 2021, the FBI and the DEA broke into around 1,400 boxes and seized the contents following a warrant to investigate the claims.
While the agencies managed to seize guns, drugs, jewelry, and $86 million in cash, many Price Vaults customers lost their belongings despite having no criminal connections and breaking no laws.
In addition to this, the warrant granted by US Magistrate Steve Kim stated that it did “not authorize a criminal search or seizure of the contents of the safety deposit boxes.”
Kim added that the contents of the boxes had to be returned to the owners.
As a result, customers have launched a class-action lawsuit to get their property back.
Under forfeiture laws, law enforcement can only seize items if they are connected to criminal activity.
According to the Institute for Justice, the organization filing the lawsuit on behalf of the safety deposit box customers, the FBI’s “government games” have “hurt box renters” like Ruiz.
The 47-year-old kept $57,000 in his safety deposit box, some of which was money from a car accident that gave him a spinal injury and left him unemployed, according to the Los Angeles Times.
“They just kind of stole my money,” Ruiz told the outlet.
He added that a federal agent asked him if he belonged to a drug cartel as he tried to retrieve his money.
“I’m made out to be a criminal, and I didn’t do anything. I’m a law-abiding citizen.”
After the seizure of the cash that he used for medical care and food, Ruiz was unable to get medical treatment.
“The FBI now refuses to give anyone their property back until they come forward and submit to an ‘investigation,'” the Institute for Justice claims.
“In other words, the government wants to force people to prove their own innocence to get their own stuff back.”
Following the raid, signage was put up on the door of the raided businesses instructing customers to “initiate a claim for your U.S. Private Vaults Box,” via the FBI wesbite.
“Although the government has indicted USPV [for money laundering], the government has not accused USPV’s customers—like the Snitkos, Ruiz, and Gothier—of violating any law,” the lawsuit alleges.
“And while a warrant authorized the government to seize USPV’s property, the warrant did not authorize the government to conduct a criminal search or seizure of USPV’s customers’ property.
“But the government did just that and, two months later, the government is still holding many of those customers’ property even though the warrant explicitly contemplated that customers’ property would be returned.
“The government’s behavior is shocking, unconscionable, and
unconstitutional.”
Over four months after the raid, prosecutors agreed to return Ruiz’s money to him, according to court papers seen by the Los Angeles Daily News.
The return of the cash occurred after US District Judge R. Gary Klausner ordered the government in July to “show cause to the court in writing as to why the government continues to seize the contents” of Ruiz’s box.
The government responded on August 3 that after reviewing the information, a judicial forfeiture action would not be filed against the funds and the cash would be returned to Ruiz.
Thom Mrozek, a spokesman for the US attorney’s office in LA hit back at claims that the FBI violated forfeiture laws.
“We have some basis to believe that the items are related to criminal activity,” he told the LA news outlet.
He added that the FBI had returned the contents of approximately 75 boxes and was planning to return the contents of at least 175 more due to no evidence of criminality.
Assistant US Attorney Andrew Brown, who prosecuted U.S. Private Vaults said in an email to one affected customer: “Please rest assured that the contents of your box are safe and secure and that we want to return all legitimately held items to their rightful owners.”
On Thursday a panel of judges from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals heard both sides of the argument about the raid after a lower court sided with the FBI last year.
A decision is expected in the coming months over whether the raid violated the customers’ Fourth Amendment Rights.
Institute for Justice senior attorney Rob Johnson is confident that the panel will side with the affected customers.
“I think the public sees this and recognizes that this is just a total abuse of people’s constitutional rights,” he told Fox News Channel.
Meanwhile, Victor Rodgers who argued on behalf of the government said that the FBI did all it could to return the property.
“All they had to do was contact the FBI,” he said.
US Private Vaults pleaded guilty to money laundering and as of October 2022, no other criminal charges were filed by the US Attorney’s Office.
#‘They just kind of stole my money,’ safety deposit box owner fumes after $57k vanished from his vault thanks to the FBI https://ift.tt/615rhdY