24/12/2025
Toffee is one of those treats I typically ignore on a holiday tray. It’s fine, but is pretty low on my sweet snack power rankings.
And then I had toffee from Tasty Good Toffee. It was an “aha” moment into how delicious toffee can be.
Owner Katie Becker still employs her grandmother’s famous recipe, continuing the legacy she built making treats for the family. Katie had no intentions of turning it into a business, but it became so beloved and in demand that she simply had to share Grandma’s recipe with the world.
Thank goodness she did.
The hardened caramelized base is sticky and sweet, but not so hard that it gets stuck in your teeth. The milk chocolate layer adds a richness and a good *crack* texture. The base of the toffee itself is delightful.
Tasty Good Toffee has a variety of flavors, the best of which (to me) is the Hot Cocoa. A mint lover's dream, this bark has a kiss of mint in the butter crunch toffee base, and the chocolate is joined with marshmallow fluff and crushed candy canes. It’s seriously addicting.
The Dark Chocolate Sea Salt has a much different but similarly craveable flavor profile. The bitterness of the chocolate tones down the sugar, and the flakes of salt enhance that rich flavor while adding texture.
You can find Tasty Good Toffee at Made in Omaha stores and at various markets throughout the year. Just be careful: once you try this toffee, you won’t think of it as an afterthought treat anymore. Your sugar consumption is about to increase.