Sugar Shop Baking Co.

12/14/2025

BEST Cookies Around Hands Down!

12/11/2025

🎄🍪 Holiday Cookie Alert! 🍪🎄

Make sure to get your Cookie Box Orders in ASAP from Sugar Shop Baking Co.! Our giant 6oz stuffed cookies are loaded with flavor, and the ooey gooey fun variety is the perfect treat to share (or keep all to yourself 😉).

✨ Limited holiday boxes available – don’t miss out on the sweetest gift of the season! ✨

📦 Message or text your orders to 772-222-7193 today and make your holidays extra delicious!

12/05/2025

12/05/2025

Make the Holidays Sweeter with Sugar Shop Baking Co. Message us Today to add something sweet to your Christmas Party!!

Send a message to learn more

12/02/2025

Now you Don't have to Travel to get The Best Cuban Pasteles!
Local Pick-Up, Delivery & Shipping Available!
Call or Text your Order to 772-222-7193

11/30/2025

Whats your VOTE?🎉🧁 Cupcake Showdown! 🧁🎉

The Holidays are Sweeter at Sugar Shop Baking Co. and We Need YOUR help! Which Cupcake do you think looks the most delicious? 😍✨

👉 Cast your vote in the comments below – will it be the Festive Bananas Foster, the Rich Pistachio Smores, Peanut Butter Dream, or the Praline Masterpiece?

Let’s settle this once and for all… the winning cupcake gets bragging rights as the Holiday Favorite of 2025! 🎄🎅

📩 Have questions or want to place an order? Message us here or text 772-222-7193 – we’ll make sure your holidays are extra sweet.

💖 Happy Holidays from all of us at Sugar Shop Baking Co.