09/23/2026
What do President Trump and Mayor Zohran Mamdani have in common? More than Monday's photo op suggests - starting with a shared stance on who gets to vote in primaries.
Speaking beside Mamdani at Gracie Mansion, Trump said he hopes the mayor will be "a great one" and that he has "great potential" - a reversal from June 2025, when he called Mamdani a "100% Communist Lunatic" on Truth Social. The two discussed the Sunnyside Yard housing plan and protected status for Haitian New Yorkers.
Where they actually agree is election reform - opposition to it, that is. Mamdani said in July he is "quite content" with New York City's closed primaries, which shut out more than 1 million voters registered without a party, and in May he disbanded a charter commission that had voted to put open primaries on this November's ballot. Trump has given his "complete and total support" to an Alaska ballot measure that would repeal that state's open primary and ranked choice voting, calling the system "very fraudulent."
The party labels differ, but the effect is the same. In New York, the closed primary decides most races before independents can weigh in. In Alaska, repeal would let the parties decide whether the nearly 60% of voters registered as nonpartisan or undeclared get a primary ballot at all.