09/19/2026
Understanding how someone became who they are doesn’t absolve them of what they do next.
That’s one of the tensions at the heart of Yesteryear.
Caleb has spent much of his life being molded by other people—his father, Natalie, the communities he falls into. Kelley sees that history as important to understanding how he becomes the man we meet later in the book.
Julianna keeps coming back to something else: He’s still an adult with agency.
Both things can be true.
We can understand the forces that shape someone without pretending they have no responsibility for their choices. And we can question the beliefs someone claims without assuming those beliefs are what actually motivate them.
Which raises an interesting question about Caleb: At what point does being influenced become choosing?