
08/05/2024
If the Spitfire and the P-51 Mustang used the same engine, what made the P-51 Mustang a better airplane?
Actually they didn’t have the same engine, both V-1650 Merlin’s, yes, but one (high powered Mk IX and others,) used Rolls Royce 61/63/66 and 70 series engines, and the P-51 used a Packard-licensed version of the Merlin.
And there were two main versions of that Packard Merlin 1650: the -7 version was geared so its supercharger drive speed would be optimal at War Emergency Power (WEP) with 130 octane fuel at 6200 feet with the supercharger in low speed and at 19,300 feet in high speed. (The -7 is the Merlin typically quoted for HP numbers.) Making 1,720 HP.
But this version was NOT optimal for escorting high altitude bombers at 25,000 feet so another Packard Merlin version, the -3 which had different supercharger drive ratios which changed the shaft speed, was introduced. The -3 engine actually has less power overall but gives it more power at 17,000 feet at low speed and 28,800 feet at high speed. Making 1,595 HP.
Many P-51’s were retrofitted with the -3 supercharger kits giving less overall HP but more where they needed it at high altitudes.
And as the Bf 109 G’s, for instance, start running out of steam/manifold pressure at only 18,800 feet that was a huge advantage for the P-51s. The -3 has 1595 HP on 120 octane fuel vs 1720 for the -7 but its a question of *where* that power is *available* at 25,000 feet and higher where the bombers were flying.
As for “Better Airplane,” the P-51 could strike at enemy targets, including Luftwaffe training bases, as far away as western Poland, causing mayhem along its entire 1,650 mile range. Being a “work horse” It wasn't as agile or as maneuver as a slender “race horse” of a Spitfire, but it could hold its own being well balanced in climb, dive, roll and “boom & zoom.”
The Spitfire was better armed and as slippery as anything in the sky, but had very little range, sadly condemning it more and more to defensive missions in Northern France. You might see Mosquitos over Berlin but never Spitfires, and that’s were the fight more and more was. Both had great cockpits and visibility and if the P-51 could drain its internal tank before getting in a fight and not throw off its COG, it did well in a dogfight.