08/29/2026
It was 1999 when Tracy Edwards came running out with handcuffs dangling from his wrist and stopped the police. He was 32 years old and had just fled the apartment of Jeffrey Dahme. That act exposed the crimes of a man who had killed 17 young men. Dahmer would die in prison in 1994, murdered by another inmate.
Edwards was seen as a hero. However, 20 years later he would return to court as the guilty party.
“He was not the same person he had been before being assaulted by Dahmer; the structure of his face had changed”
After the trial, Tracy fell apart. He did not seek psychological help because he was afraid of remembering what had happened, and he sank into illicit substances. He was convicted of at least three drug-related offenses in 1997, and his lawyer, Paul Ksicinski, stated that he had probably suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder because of his experience with Dahmer, but Edwards was still destined to fall even deeper.
Tracy could never forget the nauseating smell of Dahmer’s apartment; without knowing it, he had been surrounded by the victims, among stacked boxes and barrels. He was the martyr; however, he would pay a price.
Twenty years later, on July 26, 2011, Tracy, who had ended up living on the streets, helped the criminal Timothy Carr throw Johnny Jordan, another homeless man, into the river following an argument on the Milwaukee bridge.
Jordan, 43, drowned.
Edwards was arrested and pleaded guilty. His lawyer said that he had never stopped carrying Dahmer with him—and now, in his words, he was going to have another ghost for the rest of his life.
Judge Rebecca Dallet gave him the maximum possible sentence: a year and a half in prison. “In your attempts to drown your sorrows,” she told him, “you turned other people into victims.”
Edwards only replied: “I should have done more that day.”