17/02/2025
The Oscar Nominations 2025
DOCUMENTARY SHORTS
I saw the Documentary Shorts program last night. It's an excellent crop this year. They are all so different. It's going to be tough to choose a favorite, never mind a winner.
(If you can't find these in theaters, four are available for streaming in the US.)
INSTRUMENTS OF A BEATING HEART (YouTube)
Dir. - Ema Ryan Yamazaki
The winner of the IDA Best Short Film, follows Ayame, a first grader who is under a great deal of pressure as she learns to play an instrument during a transition ceremony to the second grade. It's a glimpse into the Japanese educational culture that may seem traumatic to western eyes and is simultaneously difficult and exhilarating to watch.
INCIDENT (YouTube)
Dir. - Bill Morrison
Hard to watch, haunting, and infuriating. The film tells the story of the murder of a black man bay a rookie policeman in Chicago, all through surveillance and body-cam footage. Everything is caught on film, exposing the lies the police told to justify the shooting.
I AM READY, WARDEN (Paramount+)
Dir. - Smriti Mundhra
Possibly my favorite of the five, this short is an examination of the death penalty. We see a condemned man during his final days, his son, his spiritual advisor, and his victim's son all try to reconcile the past with the sentence, especially when that sentence becomes reality. A heartbreaking tragedy that doesn't offer answers, but shows the terrible toll it takes on everyone involved.
THE ONLY GIRL IN THE ORCHESTRA (Netflix)
Dir. - Molly O’Brien
The lightest of the lot, this is a biography of Orin O'Brien, the first woman to perform with the NY Philharmonic in the 1960s, under Leonard Bernstein, no less. It's an interesting look at her life as she approaches retirement at after 55 years in the orchestra. Filmed with adoration by her niece, her only living relative.
DEATH BY NUMBERS (Theater only)
Dir. Kim A. Snyder
Inspired by the diary of Sam Fuentes, who survived the Parkland shooting, this may be my least favorite. That is not to say it is in any way bad, but something has to be #5. I felt that it didn't really delve into the issue, other that to show the effect it had on one victim of the shooting. It is poetic and powerful, and it left me wanting more. Maybe that's a sign of how good it is. It just needs more time than a short film allows.
Have you seen these yet? If so, what do you think of them?