
16/07/2025
WE ARE NOT A DUMPING GROUND OR A PENAL COLONY OF USA UNWANTED CRIMINALS.
By Editorial Comment
In what can only be described as an outrageous affront to our sovereignty, safety, and dignity as a nation, the United States of America has made the reckless and indefensible decision to deport convicted criminals, some of whom are hardened offenders, to eSwatini, a country that neither nurtured their crimes nor shares in the responsibility for their rehabilitation or punishment. This decision is not only morally contemptible, it is constitutionally and legally indefensible, and it must be rejected with the outrage it deserves.
Let us be clear, eSwatini is not a penal colony. We are not the United States’ geopolitical trash can. The very idea that a foreign superpower can, without consultation or consent, decide to offload its criminal burden on our soil is an insult not only to our government and judiciary, but to the people of eSwatini, particularly the families already grappling with the daily threat of rising crime, poor policing, and overwhelmed social services.
Our Constitution, however flawed in practice, guarantees the right to safety, dignity, and protection under the law for all emaSwati. Nowhere does it empower a foreign power to relocate foreign-born felons into our midst without due process. Deporting criminals who are American by culture, upbringing, and record, and dumping them into a nation they have never called home, violates every principle of national justice and constitutional sovereignty.
This is an extraterritorial violation of our law. These individuals were convicted under a foreign legal system, served time in foreign jails, and now are being forced onto our soil with no accountability, no consultation, and no bilateral agreement debated in public. This is not deportation, it is a unilateral criminal export, and by all reasonable standards, an act of international disregard bordering on neocolonial imposition.
What makes this even more dangerous is the disturbing silence surrounding the apparent agreement between the US government and our own government. This so-called arrangement, which allows foreign criminals to be deposited into our country, was never debated nor sanctioned by Parliament — the only body constitutionally empowered to make such decisions on behalf of the people. If this agreement exists, it is a secret pact, made without public scrutiny, transparency, or democratic oversight.
This raises urgent and uncomfortable questions: What else has our government agreed to in secret with foreign powers? Are there other covert deals being made that endanger our national security, resources, or sovereignty? How long will the people of eSwatini be kept in the dark while decisions are made behind closed doors that affect their very lives?
This short-sighted move is not just an internal security threat, it is a regional powder keg. Our neighbors, Mozambique, South Africa, and others, will not stand idly by as eSwatini becomes a backdoor for criminal infiltration into their territories. These individuals, stripped of identity, support, and structure, will inevitably cross porous borders in search of survival. Already, there is diplomatic unease in the region over this decision, and rightly so. This policy will strain relations, invite condemnation, and isolate eSwatini diplomatically.
All of these deportees have no connection to eSwatini either on the technicality of birth or parental lineage. They did not grow up here, they do not speak siSwati, and they have no grounding in our customs, communities, or value systems. We are now being asked to absorb individuals whose criminal behavior was forged in a completely different environment, shaped by violence, gangs, and gun culture alien to our traditional norms.
The USA, a country that prides itself on the rule of law and national security, would never accept such a decision in reverse. If Swatini were to send convicted criminals to live freely in Chicago or Los Angeles, without oversight or agreement, it would spark diplomatic outrage. Yet Washington assumes it can do so with impunity because we are small, African, and poor. This is blatant double standards and should be rejected without hesitation.
We demand that the government of eSwatini take an unequivocal stance against this policy. Silence is complicity. Parliament must convene an emergency debate and pass a resolution condemning this policy. Civil society and the public must raise their voices before it is too late.
We are not a nation of second chances for other countries’ criminals. We are a proud people with a fragile justice system, a stretched social fabric, and a right to determine who lives within our borders. To the United States: Keep your criminals. Rehabilitate them if you must. But do not insult us with this arrogant and dangerous policy.
To the eSwatini government: Tell us the truth. Who signed this deal, and under what authority? eSwatini is not your personal kingdom, nor America’s dumping ground. The people deserve answers and action now.