Keystone Cold Cases: A Pennsylvania Unsolved Crimes Podcast

15/09/2025

🎧 Patreon Episode #31 is out now: The Gypsy Hill Killings 🔪🕵️‍♀️

Today, Shannon dives into one of California’s most chilling solved serial killer cases — the Gypsy Hill Murders.

Back in the late 1970s, fear gripped San Mateo County as women began disappearing one by one. Their bodies were later found — brutally murdered and discarded. The media soon gave this string of killings a name: the Gypsy Hill Murders.

At the time, law enforcement didn’t realize they were dealing with a single predator. It would take decades, and the power of DNA technology, to finally connect the dots and bring justice.

👤 5 known victims.
🧬 40+ years of mystery.
💥 1 killer unmasked.

Join us as we walk through the investigation, the breakthrough, and the final reveal of the monster behind it all.

🎁 New to our Patreon?
Get instant access to all 31 Patreon episodes, plus 2 exclusive episodes every month. We also send out 4 awesome gifts a year to our amazing supporters!

Your support keeps the show running — and we truly couldn’t do this without you.

Got thoughts, info, or corrections? Drop a comment or slide into our DMs - we're ready to talk!

Thanks for being part of the KCCPod community. Stay safe, and happy Monday!

☀️

12/09/2025

🎙️Today episode #168 - The Unsolved Murder of Miss Hollywood🎬🌴

Today drops our California Beyond the Keystone episode. Melissa recounts the tragic life of Miss Hollywood AKA Jill Ann Weatherwax. Jill was born in Michigan into a small town. As she grew up she stole the spotlight from the local community. She participated in modeling, dancing, sports, and music. It seemed there was nothing she could not excel at.

With the dream of a bigger spotlight, her goal was to move to California to make it big. At 19 Jill moved to LA to chase her big dreams. Unfortunately everyone had the same idea. Now she was competing with other talented people and was not getting the recognition she anticipated she would receive.

For awhile Jill bounced around trying to get a stroke of luck. That is when she met Ciro Orsini who was a restaurant owner and seemed to know all the important people. According to Ciro he knew with one look at Jill he would marry her. Now there was a huge age gap, but both got what they were looking for. Ciro now had eye candy around his arm and Jill was able to bump elbows with Hollywood's elite.

This was the beginning of Jill's decline. She was partying hard and living the good life. But that fun became harder to chase. It moved from partying to an addiction. This lead her down a terrible path were she would end up dead in an abandoned parking lot behind a SPCA animal shelter.

Got thoughts, info, or corrections? Drop a comment or slide into our DMs - we're ready to talk!

Thanks for being part of the KCCPod community. Stay safe, and happy Friday!

05/09/2025

🚨 Episode #167 - Julie Conway is LIVE! 🚨

Today we’re diving into a chilling case with a twist—and we’re not doing it alone. We’re teaming up with our friends at The Corrupt Podcast to cover the haunting story of Julie Conway.

Julie had it all—family, a growing business, deep roots in her community. But on August 28th, 1993, everything changed. What started as a normal Saturday quickly turned into a nightmare when Julie vanished during a quick trip for errands.

⏳ Over a week later, hikers discovered her body near a quarry in Wampum, PA—a single gunshot wound the only detail police released.

So what happened that day?
🔍 Why Julie?
🔍 Who did this—and why?

This episode raises more questions than answers, and we’re unpacking it all with Corrupt Podcast. You won’t want to miss this one.

🎧 Listen now wherever you get your podcasts.
💬 Got tips, theories, or corrections? Drop a comment or slide into our DMs—we’re all ears.

Thanks for being part of the community.
🖤 Stay safe out there.
Happy Friday!

04/09/2025

🎙️ 7 episodes in 6 days?!

Yep — we’ve been hustling behind the scenes to make sure your podcast feed stays full through (almost) the end of the year. 💪✨

Why the rush? Because our amazing editor Shan is getting married this month! 💍🎉

We’re beyond excited for her and wishing her the most magical celebration and a well-deserved break from podcast life. 🥂💕

We seriously couldn’t do this without her. Love you so much, Shan! 💖

With that being said all of our spooky episodes for October are done!
10/3 - Debra Harman Murder House
10/10 - Perkasie Train Tunnel
10/17 - Pittsburgh Vampire Panic
10/24 - Dan Rivera / Annabelle
10/31 - Valley Creek Twin Tunnels Downingtown
10/31 - Surprise Solved Halloween Case

🎙️ Don’t forget — our collab with The Corrupt Podcast drops TOMORROW!

We had an absolute blast teaming up with Paige and Angela, and trust us — you won’t want to miss this one. 👀🔥

If you haven’t already, go check them out! Their latest episode on Ed Gein is wild — and the perfect binge before the new Netflix show drops this October. 🖤🎧

As always thanks for being part of the KCCPod!

24/08/2025

🕵️‍♀️ Suggestion Sunday 🕵️‍♂️

True crime fans, we need YOU! Got an unsolved Pennsylvania case that’s been stuck in your mind? Maybe it’s a local mystery, a decades-old cold case, or a story you believe deserves more spotlight. 🔦

We’re hunting for listener suggestions for upcoming episodes — and your pick could be the next case we dive into! 🎙️

Drop the details in the comments or send us a DM. Let’s work together to shine a light on the mysteries still waiting for answers here in the Keystone State. 🗝️

Ready to help solve some mysteries? We can’t wait to hear from you!

22/08/2025

New Episode Alert - #165 Tonee Turner

Tonee Turner was a beacon of light in her community located in Pittsburgh, PA. She was a young striving artist whose medium was metal and clay. She gave back to her community by teaching ceramics at Braddock Carnegie Library and provided her time with Children's Window to Africa.

Even though Tonee was young, she knew what she wanted in life. Everyone that knew her said she was a beaming ray of sunshine. If you look at the pictures we have linked, you can see she had an infectious smile.

But on December 30th, 2019, Tonee vanished.

She had just finished her shift at Studebaker Metals and, like many evenings, took public transit toward home. It’s confirmed she was on the bus… but what happened between the bus stop and her front door remains a mystery.

In this week’s episode, we walk through the timeline of Tonee’s disappearance and explore the unanswered questions that still linger today.

Have thoughts, theories, or a corrections? Drop it in the comments or slide into our DMs - we love hearing from you.

Thanks for being part of the KCCPod community. Happy Friday.

21/08/2025

🧠 Theory Thursday 🧠

We all have that one unsolved case that haunts us — the one you’ve read way too much about, replayed in your head a hundred times, and built your own theory around. 🔍

So let’s hear it:

💭 What’s your theory?
🕵️ Who do you think did it?
🧩 What really happened?

Drop your thoughts, wild ideas, and hot takes in the comments below. Let’s see how our true crime minds piece it all together. 🧠💬

👉 Just a reminder: Be respectful — these are real cases involving real people.

Let’s get into it. 🧵👇

20/08/2025

🔍 Whatchya Watching Wednesday 🔍

Hey true crime fans — we want to know what’s been keeping you on the edge of your seat lately! 👀

Whether it’s a chilling cold case, a gripping courtroom drama, or a mind-bending look into criminal psychology, drop your must-watch documentaries or series in the comments below! ⬇️

Every Wednesday, we’ll be asking for your latest binge-worthy picks — let’s build the ultimate true crime watchlist together. 🧠🎥

Got a hidden gem? Don’t keep it to yourself…

👉 Tag a friend & share your current obsession.

Happy Hump Day, and happy watching!

20/08/2025

🎙️Collaboration Alert!🎙️

We’re beyond excited to team up with the incredible Corrupt Podcast to bring you some powerful new true crime content this September!

🔍 Coming September 5, 2025:
KCCPod dives into the case of Julie Conway Wright.

🔎 Coming September 9, 2025:
Corrupt Podcast will take on the case of Karen Schepers.

If you’re not already listening to the Corrupt Podcast, now’s the time to start! They deliver compelling deep-dives into both well-known and under-the-radar cases—plus, their voices are seriously some of the smoothest in the game. 🎧

Stay tuned. You won’t want to miss these episodes!

30/07/2025

Don't forget to follow us on TikTok and YouTube!!

26/07/2025

11/07/2025

New Episode Out Now!

In 1984, Edna Posey — a young mother with her whole life ahead of her — was found brutally murdered near the Juniata River in Pennsylvania. A suspect was arrested and convicted, but that conviction was overturned just a few years later, leaving Edna’s case wide open once again. Decades have passed, but the question still echoes: Who killed Edna Posey? In this episode, we revisit the details of the case, the trial, and the lingering mystery that still haunts her family and community.

Listen now on your favorite podcasting app!