Keystone Cold Cases: A Pennsylvania Unsolved Crimes Podcast

16/05/2025

🚨 New Episode Alert! 🚨

Episode #151 Donna Dickey just dropped—and it’s a chilling one. 🖤
Join Shannon as she unravels the heart-wrenching story of Donna Dickey, a young mother with a seemingly perfect routine—until everything changed on August 9th, 1990. That day, Donna set out like any other Thursday. But after running her usual errands, she vanished. The next day, her body was discovered. 💔

There were sightings of a man pushing Donna’s car and when investigators tried to move the vehicle, it wouldn’t start. Did Donna unknowingly trust the wrong person to help her with car troubles? 🤔 Or was this a premeditated attack by someone she knew?

And here's the kicker: DNA was collected from the scene, but a torrential downpour that night raised questions—was the evidence even viable? 🌧️ Years later, investigators are still chasing leads with that very DNA.

Got any thoughts, info, or corrections? Drop them in the comments or slide into our DMs—we want to hear from you. 📩

Thanks for being part of the KCCPod community. Stay safe, and have an awesome Friday! 🙏💀

16/05/2025

🎧 New Patreon Exclusive! Posted as a bonus on the regular feed.

Episode #23: The Alabama Twins Murder Case is now live.
This week, Chelsea dives deep into the tangled web behind the shocking murder of Dr. Jack Wilson, a beloved eye surgeon in Huntsville, AL. Jack wasn’t just successful—he was admired for his compassion, treating every patient equally, whether they had $5 or $5,000.

Despite a tough upbringing, Jack built a life rooted in purpose and care. But even the brightest lives can be shadowed by darkness.
After a failed first marriage, Jack found companionship with Betty, a nurse with a similar past. They blended their families and built a life together—but cracks began to show. Jack’s chronic Crohn’s disease led to a major surgery, and while Betty stayed by his side, her loyalty may not have been what it seemed.

💔 Behind the image of a perfect marriage were secrets, resentment, and a hunger for a lifestyle Jack could provide—but Betty no longer wanted him in it.
Everything unraveled on May 22, 1992, when Jack was found brutally murdered. The case took an even more twisted turn when three people were arrested—including Betty and her identical twin sister, Peggy. 👯‍♀️🔪

It’s a case of love, betrayal, and murder that’ll leave you questioning everything.
Got thoughts, theories, or corrections? Drop them in the comments or hit our DMs—we love hearing from you! 🕵️‍♀️

Thanks for being part of the KCCPod community. Stay safe, and happy Friday! 💀

14/05/2025

Once of the first cases we ever did an episode finally had an arrest!

Allen Gould, the husband of missing Chester County woman Anna Maciejewska, has been charged with murder, according to court documents

09/05/2025

🚨 NEW EPISODE DROP 🚨
Our first Monthly Mood segment is here—Episode #150: Tracey Nix.

Join Chelsea as she unpacks a deeply unsettling case that has made headlines again: the story of Tracey Nix, a grandmother whose two grandchildren died—on separate occasions—while in her care.

📰 The recent trial of Uriel Schock's 2022 death has reignited public outrage, especially after the revelation that her brother Ezra Schock died just a year earlier—also under Tracey's supervision.

In this episode, we dig into:
🚗 The deadly reality of hot car tragedies
🧠 Common myths about hot car facts
✔️ Practical tips to help prevent them

We’re talking real cases, real consequences, and real ways to stay vigilant.
Got thoughts, info, or corrections? Drop a comment or slide into our DMs—we’re here for it.

🖤 Thanks for being part of this community. Stay safe, and Happy Friday!

02/05/2025

🎙️ Episode #149 is out now!
Craig Rice – Murdered (1986) Pt. 2 has just dropped on our regular feed. Join Chelsea as she wraps up this compelling case... or does she?

We've received a lot of feedback and interest—so much so that a Part 3 may be on the horizon (though it won’t be released for a while).

Have info, corrections, or thoughts? Drop a comment or slide into our DMs—we're listening.

🖤 Thanks for being part of the community, and Happy Friday!

01/05/2025

🎙️ New Episode Drop! Patreon Episode #22 – Terri Lynn Brooks 🎙️

Today’s Patreon episode is now live—and as a special bonus, it's also being added to the main feed!

If you enjoy deep dives into complex true crime cases, consider joining our Patreon community. For just $5/month, you'll get two exclusive episodes plus quarterly merch! Your support keeps the podcast going and helps cover production costs. 💛

🔍 The Case: Terri Lynn Brooks
In 1984, Terri Lynn Brooks seemed to have it all—thriving in her role as a night shift manager at Roy Rogers and engaged to be married to Scott Keefe. But just as her life was coming together, it was tragically cut short.

On the morning of February 4, 1984, the day shift manager walked into Roy Rogers and discovered a horrifying scene. Terri had been brutally murdered. $2,500 was missing, along with all of the previous night’s receipts. The investigation began immediately, but every lead went cold—and the case remained unsolved for 15 long years.

Then in 1998, with a new police chief at the helm, the case was reopened and assigned to investigator Lori Markle. With advancements in DNA technology and a fresh perspective, Markle began uncovering details that shifted the narrative—especially about Terri’s seemingly perfect relationship with Scott Keefe.

Was Scott the devastated fiancé he appeared to be—or was something darker hiding beneath the surface?

🎧 Tune in as Chelsea dives deep into this chilling case.

30/04/2025

Big Changes Are Coming — And We’re So Excited to Share Them With You!

Starting tomorrow, a brand new chapter begins. We’ve been working tirelessly behind the scenes to bring you deeper dives into cases, fresh bonus content, brand-new music, and some incredible new voices. 🎧🔍

To celebrate these changes, we’re kicking off May with 6 episodes — a little taste of everything we’ve been cooking up. Going forward, you can expect:

-A regular unsolved episode every week
-2 Patreon-exclusive episodes each month

Our Patreon is staying at just $5/month, and we’re beyond grateful to every single person who supports us there. It helps cover the costs of running the podcast and gives you access to extra content plus 4 exclusive gifts a year 🎁.

If Patreon isn’t in the cards right now (we get it — times are tough), please know that liking, sharing, commenting, and reposting means the world to us and helps more than you know. 🙏

Change can be scary, and we’ve had our fair share over the years. But we believe these updates will make the podcast better than ever. We’d love your honest feedback — and your kindness too. This has always been a passion project, and we pour our hearts (and wallets) into it.

Here’s to a new era — we hope you’re just as excited as we are. ❤️

25/04/2025

Today episode #148 Craig Rice-Murdered (1986) dropped on our regular feed. Join us as Chelsea discusses a 40 year old case that has a town divided. This case is slightly different from our usual content. There was an arrest made in this case but there is a huge cloud of doubt.

November 12th, 1985 16 year old Craig Rice did not come home. The family immediately called the police for help. They listed him as a runaway even though he did not have a history of running off. After a couple days and Craig didn’t turn up, they moved his case to a missing persons case. Police were able to piece together Craig’s movements the day of his disappearance. He was looking to get a ride to Ingram’s Honda because he was in the process of buying a car. He had asked his one friend but didn’t make it out to the parking lot in time. So he asked another friend, Greg Harner, who dropped him off in the parking lot of the car dealership. Then it is as if he vanished in thin air.

March 28th 1986 Craig’s body was found along Rock Creek. This amped up the investigation since it moved to a murder investigation. Less than 2 weeks later Greg was arrested for the murder of his friend. Police traced the bullet that killed Craig back to Greg’s father's gun. Greg’s story changed a lot over the next couple of months before trial. In the end Greg was convicted of the murder but only spent 5 years in prison. There are wild stories that surround this case such as town corruption from the police and even the judge on this case. People feel that Greg was the scapegoat. It is possible that after the threat of the people involved in the cover up die, maybe we will finally have answers. Give the episode a listen and let us know what you think.

14/04/2025

Our last edition to round off our show starting in May is Beyond the Keystone. We will have a regular episode drop the 3rd week of the month. We will go alphabetically through all of the states. In addition we are adding a patreon episode Beyond the Keystone that will drop the 15th of every month. Our patreon will still remain $5, but now you get 2 for the price of 1!!!

About Beyond the Keystone:
Born from the passion behind Keystone Cold Cases, Beyond the Keystone is our way of expanding the conversation. While our roots are proudly planted in Pennsylvania, out mission knows no borders. We're here to shine a light on unsolved murders and disappearances across the U.S. - because every story matters, no matter where it comes from.

Melissa Spivey hosts this special segment on our regular feed, which drops once a month and takes listeners on a cross-country journey into the unknown. From small towns to major cities, we're giving a voice to the voiceless, one case at a time.

For our additional patreon episode, various hosts will hop on to cover some of the wildest and craziest solved true crime stories that span the U.S.

So hop in and ride along as we sleuth our way across the nation - and maybe, one day, even beyond it.

12/04/2025

Yesterday episode #147 Carol Ann Dougherty dropped.

Join us as Shannon dives into an extremely old case from 1962 that happened in Bristol, PA. Carol was a 9 year old little girl when her life was cut too short. She loved to read, she would ride her bike all over town, loved the library, and was devoted to her religion. On October 22, 1962 Carol left her home on her bike to return books to the library. Unfortunately she was found dead in her church's loft later. She was SA'd and strangled. How could such a heinous crime happen to a sweet child, in the most holy of places??

Authorities were able to pull DNA but at the time, it was not used for forensics. We were not as advanced as we are today. Thankfully the people working the case preserved the DNA. As recent as last year the PA State Police & Bucks County DA's office announced they were sending DNA to a lab in Texas for analysis. Hopefully this testing can bring justice to the Dougherty family that has been waiting so long for answers.

07/04/2025

Hey all!

Our first new segment that is hitting in May is called Monthly Moods. It will be the second episode of each month. We cover some pretty heavy content on our regular episodes so, we thought it would be a fun change up during your monthly listening. Each month a host will pick something they're currently obsessing over to share with our listeners. It could be anything from another podcast, a movie, a trend, a hack, safety precautions, etc. The sky is the limit! We were looking for something a little more light hearted and fun. We realize this might not be for everyone, but we do ask for you to try before you deny. It'll give a little window opening for you to get to know your quirky hosts a little bit more. Plus you might find we are obsessing over the same damn things!

01/04/2025

We have some exciting news to share with you!

When we first started the podcast we were unprepared for the time, effort, energy, and money it would take to start a podcast. If you have been a long time listener you undoubtedly have noticed the changes over the last 4 years. At the end of 2022 we made the hard decision to move episodes from weekly to bi-weekly. It was not an easy decision and over the last two years, we've gone back and forth changing it back. Starting off this year we had a solid team of hosts that all have some big goals for the podcast. So we are extremely happy to announce that starting in May we will move back to weekly episodes.

Now the twist is we are adding two new segments that are slightly different than our regular content. Over the month of April we will be dropping some clues and info about these new segments. I hope you will enjoy them as much as we have enjoyed creating them.

To make this a reality, over the past 3 months we've been working tirelessly on cases. We have a huge list of listener suggestions and family requested cases. We've put more effort into doing deeper dives so there will be more 2 part episodes. We are expanding the types of cases we are working on as well.

We would really love if you could support us. When we see listeners suggest us on social media, we send out stickers. We love seeing comments on episodes to know how the audience feels. We have a patreon that helps us cover the necessities of the podcast. If you're looking for more content, when you sign up you get access to all 21 episodes already released. We appreciate every listener since day 1!

Let's go!