02/12/2025
I’m a writer and a musician. Generative AI has been somewhat of an existential crisis for me.
But having had a couple years to brood on it, I think I’ve found the silver lining.
The ability to create authentic, human art hasn’t vanished. Any real artist knows that if you’re creating for someone other than yourself, or for any motive other than the expression of genuine feeling, you’re being fake. The art that is most REAL, and therefore remembered, is made not as an end, but as its own means.
AI came for the arts first, which nobody quite expected, and we rightfully lament that. But it’s not going to stop there. Eventually, it will be able to do everything we can imagine, and many things we can’t imagine. What will be left for us to do, in a world like that?
I think the answer is deceptively simple: we just do whatever we’re naturally inclined to do anyway. The only adjustment we have to make lies in our conceptions of “action” or “purpose”. Humans, broadly speaking, are intensely practical. When we DO, when we exert energy, we expect to gain something from it. We’re like that because we’ve always had to be. The demands of Nature and history would have killed us otherwise.
A mistake many artists make is to expect renown or riches from their work. If we don’t “make it”, we’ve failed.
But even before ChatGPT, this was an unhealthy delusion. It’s always been nearly impossible to “make it”, and most of the “artists” who do are frauds. They don’t express real feelings; they make aural, visual, or literary noise that is calibrated to sell, not to communicate. Pop icons have always been robots.
The only one who has a problem with being a productive nobody is your ego. If you create out of a need for recognition, you’re doing it wrong already. Paint and sing and write because you have something to say and no better way to say it. Whether anyone hears or sees or reads is irrelevant.
Barring Armageddon, AI will end our need to do ANYTHING for practical reasons. If we can let go of our pride, this won’t be bad news. When you discover that life is rhythm and move with it for its own sake, living itself becomes a work of art.
—