11/04/2024
“Whoever killed my mom, stole my piggy bank” I told my cousin, a few months after my mom’s murder.
I thought this, because the day of, or the day after her death, my aunt and uncle took me and my sisters back to our apartment on Holabird Avenue, across from Squire’s restaurant, which was also the crime scene. I stayed in the car, but my uncle asked me what I wanted from the home.
We didn’t have much to save, and most was replaceable, but I wanted my piggy bank and my bowling trophy. He couldn’t miss either one, they were displayed on the hutch in the living room. I added change I’d find in the alley to the bank often.
My uncle returned to the car and said the bank was gone.
I brought this bank up from time to time to my sisters. Theories of how its disappearance could be connected to the case. I envisioned its ceramic smashed open with a hammer for a measly $25 or so.
Maybe a few weeks before the murder, Mom parked the old station wagon in front of the house as she always did, and when we got out of the car, a pile of change was in the dirt. Too much change to have been dropped from a pocket or purse. My sister and I excitedly scooped up the change that had seemed to magically appear- but had that money been stolen from our apartment? From me or my sister’s banks? Had we surprised the intruder, who dropped the change and ran when he saw our car chugging down the alley?
The apartment we lived in was really a small historic home split into four individual units, 2 on top, and 2 on the bottom. Yet they were all connected through the basement and attic. It wasn’t difficult to access each others’ space.
I’ve always considered found penny’s as signs from my mom. They’ve shown up on the road when I’m thinking about her, taking walks in the evening. They’ve shown up on windowsills in the empty first home I bought.
And then last month, Stephanie Schmansky found it! When she and my father divorced in the early 2000’s, she packed her boxes and moved on. Somehow this bank was among the wreckage of their marriage. Marked in a box with my name on it.
After 35 years, I have my childhood piggy bank back.
And it’s not how I remembered. Time fades and memory becomes malleable. I don’t remember it being powder blue, I don’t remember it being this large, I don’t remember the delicate hand painted flowers (by mom of course). Only its face stayed the same.
It’s all bothersome. What else has my memory distorted? And if someone (most likely my father) had packed up some of our belongings prior to my aunt and uncle getting there, what does this make of my theory? I’m always (and still) looking for a reason. Why did this person do this to her? Money? Revenge? Jealousy? S*x? And the more I uncover, the more theories are crossed from the list. At the bottom of that list, the last rusted penny at the bottom of the bank, is just - senseless crime. Things that happen for no good reason. The person was on drugs, or drunk, or both, deluded out of their mind. They barely even remember that night. It was one of many bad decisions. Dead is dead, and motive or none, it doesn’t bring her back, but pointless feels like added insult.
Al Capone once said, “Be careful who you call your friends. I’d rather have four quarters than one hundred pennies.” And while Mom certainly had some quarters in her inner circle, the amount of penny’s we’ve had to sift through is exhausting.
And as is the case, for every answer I get, for every lost object found, ten more questions take its place.