16/10/2025
The final article in Assay 12.1, Jeff Porter’s essay “The History and Poetics of the Essay” traces how the essay’s shape has morphed across eras and how its tension between freedom and constraint makes it uniquely suited to exploring both the intellectual and the intimate. Porter argues that the essay is never stable, but always in process: a form alive to metamorphosis and the questions we haven’t yet asked.
“In a way, all thought is experimental and remains so until it can be fixed in a sentence. We are all essayists for a brief moment. Roland Barthes suggested that the essay may have preceded the concept of genre in the way it emulates the genesis of thinking. If there is something that fundamental about the essay to the play of the human mind, as Montaigne insisted also, one wonders why it took so long for the form to evolve. Why wasn’t there a bronze-age essay, for instance, something written by the hero in retirement (surely Nestor would have had something to say after the burning of Troy) or perhaps set down by the stay-at-home wife, the caretaker of the oikos, a meditation on crushing olives or weaving while awaiting the warrior’s return? Given the wanderings of Odysseus, his irrepressible digressiveness and curiosity, not to mention his fondness for the personal anecdote, the Odyssey might have been that Ur-essay. It could at least have contained essay-like intervals—’On Cyclopes’ or ‘Of Listening’—enlivened by shrewd reflections on the credulity of men and the cleverness of fish.”
Read it here or visit the link in our bio:
https://www.assayjournal.com/jeff-porter-the-history-and-poetics-of-the-essay-assay-121.html
Photo by Robin the Bird on Unsplash