
08/07/2025
Fadzayi Mahere Defies Defamation Claim from Minister Machakaire, Citing Constitutional Rights
Harare – July 2025
Prominent Zimbabwean lawyer and opposition figure Fadzayi Mahere has pushed back against a defamation claim filed by ZANU PF Cabinet Minister Tinoda Machakaire, stating that her public inquiries into the minister’s conduct were lawful, constitutionally protected, and grounded in the spirit of transparency and accountability.
Mahere’s legal team has responded to a letter of demand from Machakaire’s lawyers, which accused her of defaming the minister and called for a public apology and retraction. The dispute stems from a series of questions Mahere posted on social media, which were aimed at scrutinising alleged misconduct and abuse of public office.
In a strongly worded legal rebuttal, Mahere’s lawyers described the allegations as “legally untenable,” arguing that her questions were posed in good faith and in line with the constitutional right of Zimbabwean citizens to hold public officials accountable.
“The suggestion that a series of questions posed in the spirit of seeking accountability from a Cabinet Minister constitutes defamation is not only factually incorrect but legally flawed,” reads part of the response.
The legal team also took issue with Machakaire’s contradictory approach in the complaint. While his lawyers stated they were representing him in his personal capacity, they simultaneously invoked the Freedom of Information Act, which applies to public officials in their official roles. Mahere’s legal counsel argued that if the complaint is based on his personal identity, that Act cannot apply.
“Section 67 of the Constitution protects citizens’ rights to participate in political affairs and to question those in power,” the statement continues. “Our client has not defamed anyone, but simply exercised a democratic right guaranteed under the law.”
The clash has sparked fresh debate in Zimbabwe about the limits of free expression and the rights of citizens to question elected leaders, especially in the digital era where public scrutiny of government actions is becoming increasingly common.
Mahere, a former spokesperson for the Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC), is no stranger to political controversy. Her social media activism and legal advocacy have made her a vocal critic of government corruption and human rights violations.
Observers say this latest development is yet another test of Zimbabwe’s democratic space, where tensions between public accountability and political power often play out in the courts.
As of now, no court proceedings have been formally initiated by Machakaire, and Mahere has made it clear that she will not apologise or retract her statements.
⸻
Eye Witness News Zimbabwe
— Reporting the facts, without fear or favor