16/08/2025
The Castlemaine-Maryborough Rail Trail group is fighting a proposed broiler farm in Carisbrook through a VCAT hearing, warning the industrial-scale operation would damage the trail and the region’s future if approved.
The application is lodged by Ian and Robert Hurse – with Robert owning the land at 705 Baringhup Road – on behalf of Michael Vukodinovic of Pavilion Farms.
Chickens raised at the facility are set to be slaughtered at Hazeldene’s in Lockwood, just outside Bendigo. The plan is staggering in scale: up to 400,000 birds crammed inside sheds, operating year-round, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.
While most traffic would occur during the day, the collection of birds for slaughter would happen at night, when the animals are asleep and easier to handle.
Despite the sheer numbers, only three full-time staff would manage the sheds, with two more brought in between batches to shovel manure, wash out the floors and reset the cycle.
CMRT, backed by farmers, landholders, two shires and VicTrack, has already spent eight days presenting its case, with four more hearing days to follow in September.
Their objections focus on planning law – claiming the project breaches the Broiler Code and Victorian Planning Provisions, fails on biodiversity and cultural heritage protections, and conflicts with state and local strategies for active transport, tourism and public health.
They also argue the facility threatens the Victorian Goldfields World Heritage Bid and poses a public health risk from diseases such as bird flu.
Yet the case sits within a wider storm. The trail itself has divided locals since it was announced, many dismissing it as a waste of taxpayer money for a council and state government already drowning in debt.
The World Heritage Bid, cited heavily in CMRT’s arguments, is also widely unpopular throughout the community, viewed by many as another top-down project imposed on the region.
And beyond planning law, there’s a rawer debate raging. Many in the community have raised alarm at the cruelty of the proposal – hundreds of thousands of chickens confined in sheds, living short, crowded lives before being trucked away for slaughter.
Animal welfare critics say the model treats living creatures as disposable units of production, a system out of step with community values. These concerns have not been taken up in CMRT’s formal arguments at VCAT.
The Tarrangower Times, a newspaper based in Maldon, reported last May that then-mayor, now councillor, Liesbeth Long was approached for comment on the application but did not respond.
CMRT is urging VCAT to reject the permit outright, citing public interest, ecological sensitivity and long-term economic opportunities.
But with the trail itself, the World Heritage Bid, and now animal welfare all part of the debate, the broiler farm has become a lightning rod – exposing not just opposition to one project, but the deep divides over what kind of future this region should pursue.