
27/09/2025
Big drama brewing in Victoria – a maths teacher at a Catholic girls’ school is taking the joint to court, saying they refused to recognise them as non-binary and wouldn’t let them use the title “Mx” instead of “Mr”.
They are claiming the school shut them down after they asked for the school to update timetables, emails, and official docs with “they/them” pronouns.
They say they copped heat for pride stickers on their laptop, even for handing a few out to students, and were basically told to take a number and book a meeting.
The Catholic bosses running the place have flat-out said no, arguing it clashes with their teachings. They’ve doubled down, but insist they are still a “valued member of staff”.
Meanwhile, insiders at the school say plenty of students and teachers already call them “Mx” anyway, with rainbow lanyards and stickers not exactly uncommon around campus.
What started with a complaint to VCAT has now landed in the Magistrates Court, shaping up as a test case over how far faith-based schools can go in rejecting gender-identity claims under federal law.
The Independent Education Union is backing the individual, while groups like the Australian Christian Lobby are pointing the finger at Dan Andrews’ old Labor government for stripping protections from religious schools back in 2021.
They’re saying it’s hypocrisy: political parties and clubs can demand loyalty to their values, so why not religious schools?
Albo has already floated changing the law again, possibly with Greens or Liberal support, to clamp down on discrimination loopholes – and this case could set the tone.
So now it’s more than just one teacher’s pronouns on a timetable. It’s shaping up into a battle over religious freedom, LGBT rights, and where the line is drawn when schools run by the church clash with teachers who want recognition.
Court showdown coming next month – and you can bet both sides will be watching this one like hawks.