04/05/2025
Homily for the Third Sunday of Easter, Year C,
Acts 5:27-32,40-41
Apocalypse 5:11-14
John 21:1-19
In today’s gospel we continue hearing the stories of Christ’s appearances after the resurrection. Two things are central to all of these stories. The first is that Jesus was still recognisably the same person, He still bore the signs of his crucifixion, He still ate and drank with his disciples, but He was also fundamentally different. He was not just resuscitated. He was raised to a whole new kind of existence.
This tension, of being the same but different, is clearly shown in today’s gospel story. At the centre of this episode is the most normal and human thing in the world. Jesus is having a BBQ breakfast, on the beach with His friends – but this is Jesus after He has risen from the dead. That makes a difference, and that difference is seen in the two stories either side of this BBQ.
In the lead up to this passage, the apostles have been told to go to Galilee and to wait for Jesus. While they are waiting, they do what fishermen do. They go fishing. However, they fish all night and catch nothing. In the morning, a figure on the shore yells at them to put their nets out on the other side. They do so and the catch of fish is enormous.
As soon as this happens, John says “It is the Lord”. Now, he knows this because this has happened once before. In his gospel account, Luke tells us of a very similar incident that happened right at the start of Jesus’ ministry when He was calling His disciples. Only then it was a bit of a disaster. The nets were tearing and the boats were nearly sinking.
Now, however, in the presence of the risen Jesus, Peter is able to gather all the fish to shore and, even though it contains a large number of big fish, the net does not tear. Scholars tell us that John makes a point of this so that we might see in it a promise: a promise that, no matter what the strain, God’s church will never fail. Christ is risen. The victory has already been won. I think that’s an encouraging thing to know.
The presence of the risen Christ changes people, too. Which is why our story today seems to be almost as much about Peter as it is about Jesus. In the story in Luke’s gospel, Peter’s reaction to the miraculous catch was to beg Jesus to leave him because he was a sinful man: to draw away from God in shame and fear. Now, however, as soon as he realises who it is on the shore, he’s off. He’s not waiting for the boat. Impetuous as ever, He jumps in and swims and runs in his eagerness to get to Jesus.
Not that Peter’s sins are simply forgotten. No. Something far more wonderful happens. They are forgiven; point by point, they are forgiven, when, after the BBQ, Jesus takes Peter aside for a little chat.
The ‘same but different’ theme plays out here as well. during the last supper, Peter pleaded to follow Jesus and promised to lay down his life for Him. In one of the saddest lines in the gospels, Jesus then tells Peter that rather than lay down his life, before the morning comes Peter will have denied even knowing Jesus three times.
Now he is asked three times, “Do you love me?” Peter, of course, twigs to what is going on and gets upset. Don’t we all when presented with our weakness and failure? however, as he answers each time, “You know I love you”, he is commissioned to feed and care for the church: to provide the leadership that he had failed to provide before the crucifixion.
Then, his request at the last supper was rejected in sorrow. Now, his wish is granted, and Peter is called to follow his God. The promise that he made at the last supper, which failed through human weakness, will now be fulfilled through the grace of the risen Christ. He will lay down his life for love of Jesus, just as Jesus laid down His life for love of him. In our first reading, we hear that in the time that followed, this simple fisherman, who once ran away in fear, now has the courage and eloquence to stand up even to the learned and powerful men of the Sanhedrin.
There is one more important thing to notice. A common thread in all of these post-resurrection stories in that of a meal. Here, with the bread and the fish, it recalls the feeding of the five thousand, one of the great moments of eucharistic teaching. You see, here John is not just looking back, but also pointing forward. He is indicating to us how we too can encounter the risen Christ.
Here on this altar, in a few minutes, bread and wine will be changed to become the very body and blood of Jesus. The risen Christ will be present here just as surely as He was on that shore in Galilee. Today, we will have opportunity to encounter Him in the most personal and intimate way possible - in communion.
Will we recognise Him, the same but different, in the form of bread and wine? Will we come forward to meet Him in joy, and open our hearts to be transformed by that encounter as Peter was? Will we face our sins with Him and accept His forgiveness, and will we also lay down our lives for love of Him, just as He has laid down His life for love of us? If only we would allow ourselves to be transformed by the power of this encounter with the risen Christ, then we would be able to live such lives as would transform the world. This, and nothing less, is what we have been called to do.
Send a message to learn more