
07/13/2025
Manitoba’s Accessibility and Gender Equality minister, Nahanni Fontaine, was caught on video making negative comments about an ASL interpreter.
On June 26, 2025, after making a speech to graduates, Nahanni Fontaine was recorded talking about the American Sign Language interpreter who shared the stage with her, saying the interpreter was distracting her.
“I was thrown off—it wasn’t great—but, because the woman, she shouldn’t have been on the stage. I couldn’t see anybody on the side.” “All I could see was her.” Fontaine 'mimics' the interpreter by waving her hands and her aide described the ASL interpreter’s signing as ‘frantic hand movements.' “Yeah. So, I’m like f*ck, why did I have her on stage? I’m like, Jesus. I’m like, ‘You need to leave.’”
An ASL interpreter needs to be visibly accessible to anyone who needs them, which means in order to be an accessible accommodation she needs to be in a highly visible spot when interpreting.
Under the Accessibility for Manitobans Act, all Manitobans are entitled to accessible communication including the provision of ASL translation during public events.
Nahanni Fontaine justified her words by saying the exchange was a private debrief with her staff and issued an apology after the public outrage at her behaviour.
Many people of the public and Deaf community were shocked at her arrogant attitude while complaining and not knowing how interpretation works which is extremely concerning considering her minister role. She gives little thought about the needs of the people she's supposed to be representing. If a government minister can't speak while an ASL interpreter is doing their job, then you shouldn't be one, let alone a minister of Accessibility.
A week later Premier Kinew stated Nahanni Fontaine would not lose her minister position and has apologized and she is "putting in the work with the Deaf community."
It is worth noting the initial apology to the Deaf community was made on a radio station, with no captions or transcript (though was later included on other platforms).
The public and Progressive Conservatives have called on Nahanni Fontaine to be removed from her position as the NDP's accessibility minister.
Two weeks after Nahanni Fontaine was caught, it was revealed she or her team blocked Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN) journalists from Manitoba Families Minister Nahanni Fontaine’s social media feed a few days after they reported on her controversial comments. APTN is based in Winnipeg but have staff across Canada and many of their staff have also been blocked. Staff noticed this about a week after the hot mic incident.
APTN contacted Manitoba cabinet communications the day they noticed and after repeated interview requests, received a statement from Fontaine acknowledging APTN journalists had been blocked from her social media. Nahanni Fontaine said when she "learned" journalists were blocked on her social media account, she immediately directed staff to reverse this decision.
Video from APTN News.
https://youtu.be/0XP-LItw7g4?si=bLoPHg2kZnPWsKom