10/10/2026
On the morning of Saturday, January 15, 2022, a man knocked on the door of Congregation Beth Israel in Colleyville, Texas, a small synagogue outside Fort Worth.
It was cold outside and he looked like he needed shelter. Rabbi Charlie Cytron-Walker let him in and made him a cup of tea.
A short time later, during the Shabbat service, the man took out a handg*n.
Only a handful of people were in the building. Most of the congregation was watching the service on the livestream at home, and for a while they could hear him shouting through it before it was cut.
He wanted the release of a woman serving a sentence on terrorism charges at a federal prison a short drive away.
He had no connection to the synagogue or to anyone in it. He appears to have picked it because of where it was.
Four people were held: the rabbi and three congregants.
It went on for close to eleven hours. Police and FBI negotiators were outside. One hostage was let go shortly after five in the afternoon.
Cytron-Walker spent that day keeping the man talking and keeping everyone calm, and he was doing something else at the same time: working the problem.
His congregation had been through active-shooter and security training more than once, run by local police, the FBI and a Jewish community security organization.
He had sat through it, taught it to his congregants, and never expected to need a minute of it.
One of the things that training tells you is to look for your moment.
By the last hour, the standoff was going badly. The man wasn’t getting what he wanted.
“It didn’t look good. It didn’t sound good,” the rabbi said afterward. “We were terrified.”
Then the g*nman shifted, and for a moment he wasn’t in a good position.
Jeffrey Cohen, one of the two hostages left, was watching the rabbi. The man started to sit back down.
“I told them to go,” Cytron-Walker said. “I threw a chair at the g*nman, and I headed for the door.”
All three of them got out. Not a single sh*t was fired at any of them.
The FBI’s hostage rescue team went in shortly afterward, and the man d*ed.
Every time Charlie Cytron-Walker was asked about it in the days that followed, he said the same thing.
It wasn’t instinct, and it wasn’t luck. It was the training.