26/06/2026
BEYOND ROBBERY
Part 2 - Following on from the previous post, dated 18th June'26
WHAT IF.....
£50,000 REWARD FOR INFORMATION LEADING TO KILLER'S IDENTITY
NEW INSIGHT? - While Police Scotland’s "robbery-gone-wrong" theory remains a foundation of this case, looking at the crime scene, from a behavioural point of view reveals a potentially deeper, darker motive. We find it difficult to reconcile to what started out perhaps only as a simple robbery, then escalated to the full horror of the brutality which took place on the night of Thursday 29th Sept 1983. Leaving a man dying, on the rain-soaked pavement, near the top of Pitfodels Station Road, Cults. A quiet, dark, little-known road, close to the main A93, which leads west out of Aberdeen.
Recently, I took part in a Zoom call with the highly respected, experienced Forensic Psychologist, Dr. Hart, to take a closer look at the behavioural evidence of that night. Her insights proved to be very interesting, thought-provoking and challenging.
THE WEAPON: Not an accident, but a choice. The killer carried a cheesewire—a highly unusual, deliberate weapon. Dr. Hart theorised that bringing a garrote suggests pre-planning, control, and a calculating mindset. That does not seem to tie in with a spontaneous robbery.
INTENSE RAGE: The crime scene showed a shocking level of ferocity. According to the psychologist, the sheer violence used, leading to manual strangulation at the end, points to an explosive, rage-fuelled attack. This level of overkill often signals a persistent desire to inflict harm, pain, or suffering on another person. It signifies a hidden, fundamental evil or hostility that is not just a passing feeling of anger, but an unexplainable, and deliberate act of cruelty.
LACK OF EMPATHY: Based on the weapon of choice, the explosive anger, and the cold ex*****on, the forensic psychologist believes the killer exhibited strong psychopathic traits. This wasn't a desperate person making a tragic mistake; it matches the behaviour of a cold, highly dangerous individual.
WHY DOES THIS MATTER NOW: If the killer was a psychopath driven by rage and control, someone, at some time in their life, noticed his volatile behaviour, cruelty, or strange obsession with strangulation, either before, during, or after 1983. What about the cute little lad living next door, or close by? Was there ever a time when he gave you cause for concern, especially as he grew older? Did you ever hear stories of him acting dangerously out of control? Psychopaths exhibit a core set of personality traits and behaviours, characterized by a severe lack of empathy, shallow emotions, and a disregard for social norms. Often using superficial charm and deceit to exploit others for personal gain, they are skilled at reading people and mirroring emotions to blend in, making them difficult to spot initially.
Look deeper. Does this sound like someone you may have known at the time? Typically, they do not feel sorry for hurting others. Anything can trigger them at any time. Might have been one of your drinking buddies? For most of the time, a great guy, blended nicely into your social circle? But every once in a while maybe something he did, or said, raised eyebrows? You laughed it off at the time, but did you ever wonder about that episode later? Did anyone ever mention strangulation to you, as in a "joke"? But were you uncomfortable with the conversation?
Did you know someone in Aberdeen in 1983 who carried a cheesewire, showed sudden unprovoked rage, or changed their behaviour after that September night?
One thing which some of you may know? I touched on this in a previous FB article. The film, The Godfather, apparently was shown on TV a short while before George's murder. At the end of the final scene in part 1, it shows a garrotting which takes place inside a car. A guy sitting in the back seat (behind driver), loops a garrote around the driver's neck, after he gets into the car, killing him. Shockingly similar to the attack launched on George by his eventual killer. Could that have been the trigger for his actions on 29th Sept? One of Dr. Hart's senior students carried out some research, which revealed that another garrotting scene appeared in the film, From Russia With Love. I believe that was in the seventies. If the killer was in his 20s-30s' when he killed George, his developmental years would have occurred during the 70s'.
Dr. Hart went on to share a hypothesis, which I found to be of particular interest, potentially plausible and rather chilling.
At the outset of this murderous attack, the killer would have been in a high state of excitement, adrenalin pumping, playing out this scene he'd thought about for so long. Focused, planned, action orientated. But then it went wrong - his first attempt at murder by cheesewire. That would have led to significant anger. How dare George mess this up for him, thwart his kill. Fury would have fuelled him. Had it worked, the use of the cheesewire would have been a quick, easy kill in his mind. But it didn't go as he'd planed. He realised that it wasn't as easy as the scenario which had played out in his mind, maybe for years? He wasn't as capable as he'd thought. Lots of energy was needed to do this, as opposed to a straight kill. This was not part of his expectations.
So, as the cheesewire - his weapon of choice - had not played out as he'd imagined, could he then have switched to using knives as weapons? Or perhaps he had used knives before to kill and got away with it? Do we know if any murders went unsolved, just before, or after George's murder? But really, it was the cheesewire which gave him the biggest thrill. The deadly, vicious weapon excited him. That was the next extension in his story.
His intention was to murder. That was his internal story. The choice of the cheesewire was important to him as a legacy. If he'd been successful in using the cheesewire to garrote George, that could have been the start of an infamous killing spree by him. Maybe even leading to him becoming a serial killer? He only had to google Cheesewire Killer and knew it was about him. When it went wrong, it shocked him to the core.
Psychopaths don't just change their nature overnight. This killer left a trail of volatile behaviour somewhere in his past. Take another look at those you knew in 1983.The answer to Aberdeen's most infamous mystery is sitting in someone's memory. Only you can unlock it.
Please contact us privately at this page with names or information
Or email [email protected]
If you wish to remain anonymous, we shall honour that. Your name will not be passed to the police, only your information.
Thanks to forensic science, the police now hold a profile of the killer's DNA. The net is closing fast on this cruel individual who took an innocent man's life. Will you help us to bring this case to a close and award poor George the justice he deserves?
N.B. Our special thanks and deep gratitude to Dr. Helen Hart and her student, for their kindness and foresight in exploring other avenues in this deeply troubling case. Your participation may help bring forth new names and information.