17/07/2025
SI members met for our monthly online Coffee Morning today to hear indexer David Green talk about the experience of indexing his own writings. David is the author of four true crime genre works; his most recent publication is The Murder of Lily White. David, an experienced indexer of others' true crime books, indexed all his books himself and gave a fascinating account of this work.
Generally, authors may not always be the best indexers of their own work: however, they may choose to for reasons of cost, curiosity and intellectual challenge, a belief that nobody else will understand the book or unwillingness to trust someone else with the work. Advice to authors sometimes suggests - misleadingly - that it is quite easy and underestimates the work involved in creating a good syndetic index.
Some of the difficulties author-indexers can have are being too close to the material so you can't take a detached, reader-perspective point of view; lack of indexing skills and knowledge; and lack of time or energy to produce a good index, especially at the end of a long book project. David noticed his own tendency to index his darlings, facts and topics that he was very proud of discovering, but which might not actually be indexable.
Term selection can be easier in some ways, since authors understand their own terminology. But thinking of terms the reader might look for can be harder, as you need to shift your perspective to discover these. It's also harder to achieve neutrality in the index when it gives you, as the author, a space to continue the arguments you make in the text.
David also talked about the writing process, and thinking like an indexer when you do this - ensuring terms are clear and that names are unambiguous. We also discussed the issue of representing victims fairly and completely in true crime books and indexes, and how to deal with working on dark or upsetting material - take breaks, and have something lighter to read or watch, was David's advice.
Interestingly, David's route into indexing was via an online community of anagram enthusiasts, which included - unsurprisingly - a few indexers. Celebrated C19 indexer Henry Wheatley was himself an anagram enthusiast. David included an anagrammatic Easter Egg in his presentation, too.
If you're an author approaching the indexing phase of your book, we have some useful guidance for you: https://buff.ly/66qUf4j