24/11/2025
WICKED FOR GOOD, for the most part, plays out as a wonderful companion piece and close for the story. In spite of its shortcomings the conclusion also manages to be lovingly faithful to the stage production, however, much like the latter half of the show, FOR GOOD just doesn’t soar even close to the gravity defying heights of the first part. Lacking in almost every respect that made WICKED the masterfully done and timeless musical classic it is.
Firstly, the positive.. the defining aspect of this story in general are the charming leads and exquisite performances of Cynthia and Ariana. Their chemistry is without question and they continue to redefine friendship and illustrate one hell of an emotional send off. Their beating hearts are what makes this story fly.
And with this extra leg room (being split into two movies) their arcs are given the utmost care and effort. They’re sweet, they’re flawed, complex and beautiful and the overall message of the movie hits hard.
Sadly though, the pace of this movie is very awkward, starting off very slow and plodding and then switching gears at a relentless speed, rushing the storytelling without taking the much needed time and effort to make the songs more appealing, to give the supporting cast more to with or to just leave the audience with a truly memorable sequence.
The first really took the time to be a spellbinding production with powerful songs and music and consistent emotional storytelling. Whereas here, they just seem to be rushing to fill in the gaps, tie off loose ends and connect back to its original source material.
The songs are ok at best, with the exception of ‘no good deed’ and ‘for good’, which both make up the climax of the movie. Those sequences were actually full of passion, excitement and charm that truly felt like the mastery of the first part. But the other songs, watchable as they are, just never seem to transcend or uplift you in any way. Oddly they seemed to have underdeveloped a lot of the musical sequences, they felt more like rehearsals, unfinished. The staging was also very bland and boring and lacking any confidence or creativity.
The two original songs also disappointingly forgettable with some awful lyrics and terrible production value.
The writers seem to have abandoned the credibility of the supporting cast, particularly Fiyero, whom was allowed very little defining moments beyond the obvious love interest. I think i remember him just pointing a gun at a lot of people and that’s it.
This time round, we just look forward to seeing our stars and the effortlessly watchable Jeff Goldblum and care very little for everyone else.
As expected, the tonal shift means this is a lot less chirpy but it’s a relief they did not squander on the emotional ending, which really did move me to tears.
Overall, it is still a harmlessly entertaining close with two phenomonal performances that anchor the whole movie and keep it from falling apart. The storytelling is messy, the songs not nearly as lively and the production itself just seems to lack the charm, passion, colour, flow and wit of the first.
Fortunately it entertains regardless. Perhaps because the fans are just truly invested in the story and these characters.
It was a good decent watch, however it won’t have any lasting effect on you and you likely won’t want to rediscover it nearly as often as Part one.
The effort, tone, spectacle appears to have been dialled down for no apparent reason.
Devotees should see it regardless and stay for the impeccable lead performances and their meticulous arcs, the hearty themes on friendship and what it means to be good and live up to its name and the emotionally devastating finale, which makes the journey completely worth it.
⭐️⭐️⭐️