14/07/2025
It is with a heavy heart that I must report that James Gunns SUPERMAN is one of the biggest disappointments in cinema I have ever endured. A complete miscalculation, not just a poor movie from a critical standpoint, but also it just doesn’t work for me on a personal level.
Not QUEST FOR PEACE bad but certainly one of the worst DC movies ever and a devastating beginning to the DCUniverse.
I will aim to be as dispassionate as possible with my assessment of this movie as pure hatred is not usually how I roll with movies.
Firstly, the screenplay, though considerably more light hearted and more comic book oriented, I still hate to admit it just doesn’t work. From the beginning the movie is silly and daft to the max and it just really makes you cringe and take you out of the movie. The humour never lands, this style and tone may be perfect for the Guardians but not Superman.
Almost every character is poorly conceived, on page and screen. No one is likeable and they all come off rather bland, annoying and unbelievable.
The story is bloated, messy and simply put.. boring. The political aspects are just awful, same with all the social media angles and speaking not only for myself, but you are just not compelled by anything in the storytelling or the character work.
I’d say the cast were mostly miscast but then again, they had very little to work with. David Corenswet exhibited no real value or heart for me and just came off rather smarmy and irritating, not to mention he couldn’t carry the movie. Lois, the justice gang, just cringe.
The dialogue is terrible and character work dreadful, caring for literally no one. The Kent’s were bland and underused, the relationship between Lois and Superman lacked chemistry and a fascination. The interview scene in particular was a raving mess of dialogue and political exposition.
Though there were very few moments, I will however relay the positives. Nicholas Hoult was without a doubt the defining aspect of the movie. He illustrated a wonderful Lex Luthor with his envious rage for Superman and his character was actually written well as a formidable foe for this Superman. He was exciting, clever, humourous and stole the show especially in the climax.
Mr Terrific wasn’t half bad and had the best action sequence in the movie. Krypto was cute and fun, if a little overkill at times. And the final act of the movie was actually half decent with some decent fights and some relatively sweet resolutions.
I’m a massive Superman fan, but I will say that a lot of my reservations with the movie are personal, to many others I do understand they feel a whole lot differently on the matter but for me, I did not enjoy superman’s overly emotional nature even if it is explained with some good intentions in the script at the end, it just doesn’t illustrate superman for me personally. I won’t spoil anything but Gunn also changes some of the mythology of the character and I thought it was dreadful, just didn’t work for me.
I know the climax tried so hard to reach the heart but with its short runtime, unconvincing portrayals and infuriating changes I just couldn’t feel that hopeful message the way others did.
It also lacks that goosebump inducing feel when the heroics just make your heart soar. Considering Superman is weak and useless throughout 90% of this movie and has the constant aid of the justice gang and Krypto he literally barely saved anyone. This is NOT the ultimate strongest meta human that we deserve. And as for Superman’s characterisation, he just seems to be an egotistical, whiney, emotional and childish person. He seems to pick and choose his battles depending on whether he wants to have a cringey argument with his girlfriend 🤷♂️ I found myself often sharing Lex’s hatred for him 😄👊But again… it’s down to personal feelings here and all these gripes I have mean something to gunns script, I get the point, it’s just not SUPERMAN 🤷♂️
“Even though you are being raised as a human being… you are not one of them” Superman is like a god. Making him more human is cute but it’s not SUPERMAN 🤷♂️ his identity is to be better than us and that’s why I’ve always appreciated his dispassionate nature in previous performances. He doesn’t get mean and angry with his foes and his actions say everything about his feelings that don’t need explaining to the audience.
Overall, this movie was just a failure as a movie and as an iteration of the popular DC superhero. The tone was too light and campy and could not replicate the feel-good vibe of the original Christopher Reeves movie. The story and direction did not compel , rarely entertained and for a superman movie it felt completely devoid of all heart, spirit and joy that this character so represents. Certain decisions in the script were just bad writing. With the exception of Hoult, some nifty effects work and some ok action in the final act this movie derailed at every turn with plot, character and style.
And though I appreciate this might very well work for others, this just wasn’t MY Superman.
It had its moments here and there but personally I much preferred the charming Reeves movie, the tonal shift in Man of Steel and even Superman Returns.
I’m no Snyder fanatic by all means but I thought man of steel served the character and his mythology beautifully and contrary to others views I found the movie had an abundance of depth, I felt I understood the character and his values and heart by the end and it just delivered on story, action, character and tone.
REEVES was a perfect superman, embodying the hero and Clarke Kent with such likeable sensibility and they were wonderful escapist comic book iterations to cherish.
SUPERMAN RETURNS, tragically underrated, had a much more interesting script than Gunns, a more complex study of his relationship with Lois and actually payed beautiful homage to Reeves.
The DC Universe’s SUPERMAN was definitely a love or hate movie. If you’re a fan I urge you to absolutely forge your own opinion and I just hope it gels with you guys more than it did me but sadly…..
⭐️