
26/07/2025
Who Really Is Africa’s Best Player?
Every year, CAF announces the African Player of the Year, and every year we applaud.
But no one pauses to ask the uncomfortable question:
Best where?
Because when CAF crowns the continent’s finest, it’s not the one who carried an African club through the CAF Champions League.
Not the one who dazzled at AFCON or elevated the African game at home.
No!! it’s the one who impressed in Europe.
And this is the quiet betrayal we all ignore.
Let’s Look at the Evidence: The Last 10 Winners
Zero of the last 10 winners were playing in Africa.
Not even one.
Not even a shortlist finalist.
When Was the Last Time an Africa-Based Player Won?
You’d have to go back to the year 1986 when Mohamed Timoumi of Morocco, playing for FAR Rabat, won the African Player of the Year award while based in Africa.
That’s nearly 40 years ago.
Let that sink in.
The Global Comparison
South America: Gabigol (Flamengo) and Carlos Tévez won continental best player awards while playing in South America.
Asia: Salem Al-Dawsari, based in Saudi Arabia, won the AFC Player of the Year.
Europe: Naturally picks from within its own elite leagues.
Yet Africa never recognizes its own from within.
This is not just about football awards it’s about how Africa sees itself.
CAF is telling every young African footballer this:
“You are not great until Europe says so.”
And so, every rising star sees escape as success.
Local clubs are left with no heroes.
The CAF Champions League becomes an audition, not a crown.
Meanwhile, players like:
Ali Maâloul (Al Ahly)
Denis Onyango (Mamelodi Sundowns)
Mohamed El Shenawy (Al Ahly)
Zouheir El Moutaraji (Wydad Casablanca)
…win trophies, carry clubs, shine in Africa’s biggest games yet never appear on the Player of the Year stage.
What CAF Must Do
Redefine Eligibility: Prioritize African-based performances in African competitions.
Dual Awards: Introduce a “Diaspora African Player” for those shining abroad.
Elevate Interclub Player of the Year: Make it a co-equal, not a consolation.
Honor AFCON Heroes: Weight national team exploits like Copa America or Euro achievements.
If South America can reward players for excellence within South America,
If Asia can uplift stars from Riyadh or Seoul,
Then why must Africa outsource greatness?
Why must our champions wear foreign jerseys before they’re worthy of a golden statue?
The best African player should not be the best African in Europe.
He should be the one who carries Africa on African soil.
And until we change that, this award remains not a celebration but a reminder of our silence.
Renaissance Quill……..
fans TotalEnergies CAF Champions League & Confederation Cup