06/11/2025
“This is a Jew of stature. He has wise eyes, and he is modest.”
— David Ben-Gurion
Seventy-two years ago today, 15 Marheshvan in 1953, Rabbi Avrohom Yeshayahu Karelitz – known as the Hazon Ish – passed away. One of the foremost halakhic authorities of his time, he was a formative figure in the development of Israel’s ultra-Orthodox sector.
In late 1952, David Ben-Gurion’s government was on the brink of a coalition crisis.
The Haredi Poalei Agudat Yisrael party, then part of the ruling coalition, was threatening to bring down the government over the issue of drafting young women into the IDF or national service. Party representatives explained to Ben-Gurion that they’d only defer to the opinion of the ultimate authority on the matter, the Hazon Ish. Ben-Gurion therefore asked to meet with the Lithuanian rabbinic leader at his modest home in Bnei Brak.
Accompanied by his aide Yitzhak Navon, Ben-Gurion arrived at the rabbi’s sparse apartment.
“I have come,” he began, “to ask how we can live together – religious and nonreligious – without exploding from within.”
The conversation, which lasted fifty minutes, was marked by deep disagreements. At one point, the Hazon Ish offered his now-famous parable, often misremembered as “the parable of the empty cart,” though its Talmudic source (Sanhedrin 32b) actually mentions camels:
“We religious Jews are like a camel burdened with a heavy load – the yoke of many commandments. You must make way for us.”
After the meeting, Navon recalled:
“Ben-Gurion was deeply moved. He said to me, ‘We must find a way to live together. Otherwise, the danger within will be greater than any external threat.’”
A few weeks later, the Hazon Ish sent Ben-Gurion a letter, urging him to forgo the plan to draft women for national service:
“Honorable Prime Minister,
I am inclined to believe that the Prime Minister, a man distinguished by his respect for freedom of conscience, feels unease at the thought of compulsory national service for girls, lest it harm the conscience of many—or even of one.
Allow me, therefore, to express my deep sorrow over this decree and to appeal to the Prime Minister to relinquish it. Such a step would reflect the refined sensitivity of the Prime Minister, in recognizing the anguish and conscience of the religious public…”
Ben-Gurion replied in kind:
“To the esteemed Gaon, the Hazon Ish, Zikhron Meir, Bnei Brak.
I was pleased to receive your letter, and I am truly sorry that I cannot fulfill your request. The issue of drafting women involves a double matter of conscience: the ultra-Orthodox sector feels that conscription violates their conscience, while a large part of the nation feels that the absence of conscription violates theirs.
I know that among scholars of halakha, opinion [on this matter] is divided, and I would not presume to rule in such matters, knowing you are the greatest rabbinic authority of our generation. But I am also aware of the security needs of the people of Israel, and the saving of national life overrides all else in my eyes.
I am deeply sorry that you define the drafting of girls for national service as ‘an evil decree.’ A law of the People of Israel in its own land is no external ‘evil decree’…”
Photo: Rabbi Avraham Yeshayahu Karelitz (the Hazon Ish). Wikimedia Commons.
-------
Join the Segula Snippets quiet WhatsApp group to revisit moments that have shaped Jewish history: https://bit.ly/Segula-Snippets