20/12/2025
Javed Akhtar, a renowned Indian lyricist and atheist, debated M***i Shamail Nadwi, an Islamic scholar, on December 20, 2025, in Delhi at the Constitution Club. The event, moderated by journalist Saurabh Dwivedi and streamed live on platforms like The Lallantop's YouTube channel, centered on "Does God Exist?" [1][2][1]. It drew significant online buzz following prior challenges from M***i Shamail and others like Dr. Zakir Naik.
# # Debate Format
The structured two-hour discussion included opening statements (10 minutes each), rebuttals (7 minutes then 5 minutes), cross-examination (16 minutes), closing arguments (5 minutes each), and audience Q&A (30 minutes). Both participants agreed to logical reasoning over scientific evidence or religious scriptures, avoiding empirical demands for God's visibility. [1]
# # Key Arguments: M***i Shamail
M***i Shamail used the contingency argument, stating the universe's contingent nature (dependent existence) necessitates a necessary, eternal, independent being—God—as an infinite regress of causes is logically impossible. He rejected "God of the gaps" critiques, emphasizing design in the universe's precise laws, and argued evil enables accountability, supporting God's existence. Faith, he clarified, must align with logic and evidence, not blind acceptance. [5][6]
# # Key Arguments: Javed Akhtar
Akhtar distinguished faith (unjustified belief without evidence, witnesses, or reason) from rational belief, calling religious faith "stupidity" as it demands surrender without proof. He highlighted historical gods' transience (e.g., Jupiter, Germanic deities), nature's amorality (no justice in predators or disasters), and humanity's progress through questioning, not faith. Religions promise posthumous justice but rely on unverifiable claims, he argued.
***iShamail
***iShamailNadwi
