12/08/2025
Strategic Borrowing: The Vital Engine for Sikkim's Development, Debunking the "Debt Economy" Myth
Sikkim, nestled in the Himalayas, faces unique economic challenges. Its rugged terrain, limited arable land, remoteness from major markets, and small population inherently constrain its revenue-generating capacity. Yet, the aspirations of its people for better infrastructure, healthcare, education, and livelihoods are immense. In this context, loans and borrowing are not merely important; they are essential catalysts for Sikkim's economic growth and social development. However, recent claims labelling the current SKM government's approach as creating a "debt economy" require careful scrutiny against economic principles and ground realities.
Why Borrowing is Indispensable for Sikkim:
1. Bridging the Fiscal Gap: Sikkim's own tax and non-tax revenues are insufficient to fund essential government functions and ambitious development projects. Like most Indian states, it relies heavily on Central transfers (tax devolution and grants). However, these too are often inadequate to meet specific local needs and large-scale infrastructure investments. Borrowing bridges this critical gap between available resources and necessary expenditure (Reserve Bank of India - State Finances Reports).
2. Funding Critical Infrastructure: Sikkim's development hinges on overcoming geographical isolation. Building and maintaining roads, bridges, tunnels, power transmission lines (especially for its vast hydropower potential), water supply schemes, and digital connectivity require massive upfront capital. These projects have long gestation periods but generate long-term economic returns and public good. Borrowing provides the necessary capital injection that current revenues cannot cover (NITI Aayog - Reports on Infrastructure Development in States).
3. Investing in Human Capital:Quality education and healthcare are fundamental for sustainable development. Building schools, colleges, hospitals, and training healthcare professionals demands significant investment. Borrowing allows the state to accelerate these investments, improving human development indices and creating a more skilled workforce for the future, which ultimately boosts productivity and growth (World Bank - Principles on Public Debt for Development).
4. Stimulating Economic Activity:Government spending, financed partly by borrowing, acts as a key economic stimulus, especially in a small economy. It creates jobs (directly in projects and indirectly in supporting industries), boosts demand for local goods and services, and attracts private investment by improving the overall business environment.
5. Leveraging Hydropower Potential:Sikkim's major economic opportunity lies in hydropower. Developing these projects requires enormous capital expenditure. Strategic borrowing enables the state to participate in or facilitate these projects, aiming for future royalty and tax revenues that can service debt and fund other development (Sikkim State Hydropower Policy documents).
6. Managing Asymmetric Shocks: Events like natural disasters (common in the Himalayas) or economic downturns (like the COVID-19 pandemic) cause sudden revenue shortfalls and increased expenditure needs. Borrowing provides a crucial buffer to manage such emergencies without crippling essential services (RBI - State Finances: A Study of Budgets during COVID-19).
Countering the "Debt Economy" Claim:
The accusation that the SKM government has created a "debt economy" implies unsustainable borrowing solely for consumption or short-term gain, leading to a dangerous debt trap. While prudent debt management is always crucial, the claim requires counterpoints based on context and data:
1. Debt-to-GSDP Ratio - The Key Metric: The primary indicator of debt sustainability is the Debt-to-Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) ratio. While Sikkim's absolute debt has risen, **it consistently remains below the 20-25% threshold often considered manageable for Indian states, and significantly lower than many larger states.** As per RBI and State Budget documents, Sikkim's Debt-to-GSDP ratio has generally hovered around 15-20% in recent years, well within norms. This suggests the borrowing is proportional to the state's economic capacity to repay.
2. Financing Productive Assets:Much of Sikkim's borrowing is directed towards creating productive assets – roads, power projects, water infrastructure, tourism facilities. These assets generate economic returns (directly or indirectly) and enhance the state's revenue potential over the medium to long term. This is fundamentally different from borrowing for unproductive recurrent expenditure or populist giveaways.
3. Central Guidelines and FRBM Act: State borrowing is strictly regulated by the Central Government (Ministry of Finance) under the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act and associated rules. Sikkim, like all states, must adhere to borrowing limits set annually based on its fiscal deficit and debt targets. The SKM government operates within this nationally mandated framework, not in a borrowing free-for-all (Union Budget Documents, FRBM State Rules).
4. Low-Cost Borrowing Sources: States access loans from multiple sources:
Market Borrowings: Raised through State Development Loans (SDLs), typically the largest source.
NSSF Loans:From the National Small Savings Fund, often at concessional rates.
Central Loans:For specific projects or schemes.
Institutional Loans: From agencies like World Bank, ADB (less common for states directly now). Diversification helps manage costs. Sikkim benefits from relatively lower interest rates compared to many states due to its historical fiscal prudence.
5. Focus on Development Imperatives: The borrowing under the SKM government aligns with demonstrable development needs: improving connectivity (roads, Pakyong Airport), boosting power infrastructure (supporting hydro projects, grid stability), enhancing tourism facilities, and improving social infrastructure. These are investments in Sikkim's future, not consumption.
6. Comparative Perspective: All Indian states borrow extensively for development. Criticizing Sikkim's borrowing without acknowledging its unique geographical handicaps and smaller revenue base ignores context. Its borrowing per capita or as a percentage of GSDP is not an outlier suggesting recklessness.
7. Revenue Enhancement Efforts: Countering the "debt economy" narrative requires acknowledging efforts (even if needing acceleration) to boost own revenues – improving tax administration, exploring new revenue streams linked to tourism and hydropower, and ensuring efficient use of borrowed funds.
Conclusion:
Labeling Sikkim's necessary borrowing for development as creating a "debt economy" is an oversimplification that ignores economic realities and the state's unique constraints. Borrowing is an indispensable tool for a state like Sikkim to overcome its geographical limitations, build critical infrastructure, invest in its people, and unlock its economic potential, particularly in hydropower and tourism. The key metric – the Debt-to-GSDP ratio – indicates that Sikkim's borrowing, including under the SKM government, remains within sustainable limits defined by national frameworks and economic principles.
The focus should not be on demonizing borrowing itself, but on ensuring its strategic and efficient utilization. Continuous scrutiny on the quality of expenditure (productive vs. unproductive), transparency in debt reporting (including contingent liabilities), and relentless efforts to enhance the state's own revenue generation are paramount. Sikkim's challenge is to walk the tightrope: leveraging borrowing as a vital engine for growth while maintaining rigorous fiscal discipline to ensure long-term sustainability. The evidence suggests it is navigating this path, not hurtling towards a debt trap.
References:
1. Reserve Bank of India (RBI): Annual "State Finances: A Study of Budgets" Reports. (Provides authoritative data on state debt, deficits, and fiscal indicators across India, including Sikkim).
2. Reserve Bank of India (RBI): "State Finances: A Study of Budgets during COVID-19" (2020/2021). (Highlights borrowing pressures during the pandemic).
3. Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG): Audit Reports on State Finances (Sikkim). (Provides audits of state government finances, including debt management, though often with a lag).
4. NITI Aayog: Various reports on infrastructure development, sustainable development goals, and state performance. (Context on national infrastructure needs and state comparisons).
5. World Bank: "Debt Management Performance Assessment (DeMPA)" Methodology and Reports. (Provides international principles and frameworks for assessing public debt management).
6. Government of India, Ministry of Finance: Union Budget Documents, especially the "State of the Economy" section and Fiscal Policy Statements. (Details central guidelines on state borrowing limits under FRBM).
7. Government of Sikkim: Annual State Budget Documents and Economic Survey. (Primary source for state's own fiscal plans, debt figures, and development priorities - requires accessing state finance department websites).
8. Government of Sikkim: Sikkim State Hydropower Policy. (Outlines the strategy for leveraging hydropower, a key area requiring investment).
Like& Share
As Truth's lamp illumines the path; Misinformation's cup holds only poison.
SKM Darpan PS Golay - Unofficial Prem Singh Tamang-Golay Milan Basnet Navraj Gurung Jacob Khaling Rai Bikash Basnet Nabin Dahal Raju Human Devendra Chettri Sutar Bishnu Kumar Khatiwara Bishnu Kattel Skm Skm Soreng Chakung मिलन समर्पण Tashi Tshering Lepcha Bina Sharma Bijay Rai Tomatshang Ganesh Chettri Ganga Parsai Chettri Ganza Denzongpa Suresh Tamang Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Skm Insight SKM updates
