22/05/2023
Wondering which tool is the best for video scriptwriting? ChatGPT plus? ChatGPT free? Bing? Bard?
We are reviewing the performance among:
1) ChatGPT 3.5/ Free ver.
2) ChatGPT 3.5/ Paid ver.
3) ChatGPT 4/ Paid ver.
4) Bing Chat/ Free ver.
5) Google Bard/ Free ver.
-----
a) Duration (Does the generated script matches the requested duration of 30s?):
1 ★
2 ★★
3 ★★★★★
4 ★★★★
5 ★★★★★
::Sum: Although both free and paid ChatGPT 3.5 version are the same version, the paid version seems to understand assignment given better than the free one. Both versions are pretty generous I would say. 😂
b) Visual shot (Does the generated script provides shot reference?):
1 ★★★
2 ★★★
3 ★★★★★
4 ★
5 ★★
::Sum: Google Bard and ChatGPT 3.5 provided visual shots as what to shoot/ edit to match the script. However, ChatGPT 4 has way more variety and interesting shot compilation.
c) Script (Is the generated script written professionally?):
1 ★★★★
2 ★★★★
3 ★★★★★
4 ★
5 ★★
::Sum: ChatGPT 3.5 used fancy words, ChatGPT 4 used less fancy word. All are great but ChatGPT 3.5 doesn't sounds like it is written by human.
d) Structure (Is the script structure correct?):
1 ★★★★
2 ★★★★
3 ★★★★★
4 ★
5 ★★
::Sum: Great performance again by ChatGPT since it actually generates script in a good structure, easier for us to follow.
e) Accessible (Is the tool easy to reach and use?)
1 ★★★★
2 ★★★★★
3 ★★★
4 ★★★
5 ★★★★★
::Sum: ChatGPT 3.5 free ver. has limitation when traffic is high. ChatGPT 4 paid ver. limits to 25 msg/ hour. Bing Chat requires us to download Microsoft Edge. Google Bard and ChatGPT 3.5 paid ver. are not limited to message generated.
-----
Overall Score
1. ChatGPT 3.5/ Free ver. - 3.2/5.0
2. ChatGPT 3.5/ Paid ver. - 3.6/5.0
3. ChatGPT 4/ Paid ver. - 4.6/5.0
4. Bing Chat/ Free ver. - 2.0/5.0
5. Google Bard/ Free ver. - 3.2/5.0
SUM:
***ChatGPT plus (3.5 & 4.0) is the best if you have some budget to spare. It understands the assignment well, the scripts are quite relevant. I would suggest to play around with 3.5 paid version and only use 4.0 paid version when the task is more complex.
**ChatGPT 3.5 free version is the best if you don't have budget to spend but Bear in mind, you will have to tolerate with the traffic. It also needs more prompts, more inputs to get a more accurate and better results.
Bing Chat is not good in content generation at all. The score is the lowest among all platform. Although it is running on latest model ChatGPT 4.0, it still more tailored to web searching rather than content generation.
Google Bard is really fast in generating, but the generated script is just not as good compared to the other.
