03/08/2026
DEMOCRATIC ENGAGEMENT IS NOT AN ABUSE OF CLERICAL PRIVILEGE
Last week, Temitope Ajayi wrote “Cardinal Onaiyekan’s Abuse of Clerical Privilege.” Read the title again. It was not an argument. It was a demand for silence.
That is the real problem. Not a cardinal who spoke after a meeting. But a Presidency that seems more comfortable with praise singers than with hard truth.
The Catholic Bishops’ Conference of Nigeria met President Bola Ahmed Tinubu. The bishops spoke plainly about insecurity, hunger, and governance. The President responded with his own talking points on reforms and revenues.
That is democracy working. What is not democracy is the outrage that followed when Cardinal John Onaiyekan told Nigerians what he understood from that meeting. Unless the Villa declared the meeting off-record, there was no breach. “Abuse of clerical privilege” is just a polite way of saying “we don’t like what you said.”
Real bishops do not exist to make the President comfortable. Fake ones do.
The Catholic Church has priests in virtually every community in Nigeria. Bishops see what briefings cannot capture. They bury the dead. They feed the hungry. They counsel families displaced by violence.
Their job is not to cheer power. It is to hold it accountable. To ask them to meet the President, hear “the economy is fine,” and then go home quiet is to turn them into chaplains for the Villa. That is not their calling.
This is not new. It is Church tradition.
As Senator Shehu Sani put it:
“From the era of military rule and throughout the period of civilian governments, the Catholic Bishops have a consistent history of telling truth to power. They have never been partisan. Every President they visited, they bring him a gift of bitter kola instead of olive oil.”
Bitter kola. Not sweet talk. That is the point: walk into power with hard truth, not flattery. It is dangerous to now try to criminalize that voice.
They took the cry of Nigerians to the President*
The Catholic Bishops didn't go to A*o Rock seeking contracts.
They didn't go lobbying for appointments.
They didn't go “standing on any mandate.”
They went carrying the pain of millions of Nigerians.
They said Nigerians are hungry.
The answer? “There has always been hunger before I was born.”
They said the economy is crushing ordinary families.
The answer? “The economy is doing well.”
They expressed concerns about public confidence in INEC.
The answer? “INEC is neutral.”
They worried about a level playing field in 2027.
The answer? “Whoever wants power should be ready to wrestle for it.”
And immediately, my mind went to Rehoboam.
The people begged him to reduce their suffering. The elders pleaded: “Listen to your people.” His loyalists said: “Show them who's boss.” He listened to the loyalists. He ignored the people.
The result? A kingdom that took generations to build split in a single day. The people walked away shouting: “To your tents, O Israel!” 1 Kings 12:16
Every government should fear one thing more than criticism: the day it stops listening.
Propaganda cannot fill empty stomachs. Slogans cannot reduce the cost of living. And praise-singers cannot rewrite reality.
We keep hearing: “The President has intelligence you don’t have.” Maybe. But a nation is not run on classified files alone. It is run on outcomes.
When transport fares double, when students drop out, when farmers cannot access their land, that is also data. Dismissing it because “you don’t have the full picture” is how governments lose touch, and eventually lose elections.
The CBCN has never claimed to be the sole custodians of truth. But they are a necessary voice. They are not sycophants. They must continue to speak truth to power, even when it is uncomfortable.
This meeting did not diminish the Presidency. It did not weaken the Church. It showed dialogue is still possible. What would damage both is if we now demand silence as the price of access.
Mature democracies reward frankness. Leaders listen. Critics speak. Citizens judge.
So no, Cardinal Onaiyekan did not abuse a privilege. He exercised one that belongs to every Nigerian: to speak, to question, and to demand better.
With 2027 approaching, that is the privilege we cannot afford to surrender.
Hon. Chibuisi Mba
National Coordinator,
OKAY A NEW NIGERIA
WHATSAPP: 07037233448
10, Bouake Street Wuse zone 6, Abuja FCT
Rabiu Musa Kwankwaso Mr. Peter Obi Nigeria Democratic Congress Tableth Onuoha Jaypee Igbo Times Magazine Kwankwasiyya Reporters Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie Seun A Oluade Napiofficial27 Alex C. Otti Alex Ikwechegh Mascot fans