13/11/2025
Episode 5: The Man in the Photograph
(âI Wish I Never Knew Himâ â Episode 5 of 7)
The rain poured relentlessly that night, drumming against the windowpane like a thousand tiny fists demanding attention. I sat in the dim glow of my bedside lamp, the newspaper clutched tightly in my trembling hands. My eyes lingered again on the black-and-white photo of the âmissing local painter.â
Her name was Elena Drew. A name I had never heard before, yet her faceâthose haunting eyes and gentle smileâfelt strangely familiar. It was as if Iâd seen her somewhere, in a memory buried deep under the rubble of forgotten years.
I couldnât sleep. Each time I closed my eyes, I saw the framed photograph I found at the restaurant. The same woman. The same expression. Only⌠she wasnât alone in the version I found.
In my photo, there was a man beside her.
The next morning, I drove back to Pine Street Diner, ignoring the curious glance of the waiter who had served me days ago. The picture was still there, hanging crookedly between a clock that had stopped at 9:42 and an old painting of the cityâs skyline.
I stood there for a long time, my heart pounding. The man in the photograph looked no older than thirty. Sharp features, kind eyesâbut his smile was strained, almost forced. And though the years had softened his jawline and added grey to his hair, I knew that face.
Iâd seen it before.
In my motherâs old photo albums.
I called my mother that evening. Her voice came through the speaker, warm but cautious, as if sheâd been expecting this conversation.
âMom,â I said quietly. âWho is Elena Drew?â
There was silence. Then, a long exhale. âWhere did you hear that name?â
âShe was a painter, apparently. I found her picture in an old newspaper. The one hanging at the diner.â
The sound of shuffling papers came through the phone, followed by a sigh so deep it chilled me.
âGabrielle,â she said finally, âyou need to stop digging into things you donât understand.â
âIâm just asking, Mom. Why does her face look so familiar? Why was she in that restaurantâs photographâwith Dad?â
Her silence was louder than her voice.
âMom?â
Then, softly: âBecause she was your fatherâs first wife.â
My stomach dropped. âHis what?â
âShe disappeared before you were born,â she whispered. âYour father never talked about her. The police questioned him for weeks, but they never found proof of anything. She was declared missing, presumed dead.â
I gripped the edge of the bed, the newspaper now lying open beside me like an accusation.
âSo all these yearsâDad knew her? He was with her?â
âYes,â she said, her voice trembling. âThey were married for two years. He was her muse, she said. Her everything. Until one night, she vanished. Your father was never the same after that. When I met him, he was⌠broken. Haunted.â
The line went silent for a moment. Then she added, âHe told me heâd moved on, but he kept her painting locked in his study. I never asked why.â
After I ended the call, I sat still, staring into the darkness of my room. Every corner felt alive, pulsing with the ghosts of secrets I hadnât asked to inherit.
That night, I dreamt of the painting.
It wasnât the framed picture at the diner anymoreâit was something larger, more vivid. A canvas of red and gold, of shadows and whispers. Elena stood at its center, her hand outstretched toward a faceless man whose figure was dissolving into smoke. Behind them, the same restaurant appeared, its lights flickering like dying stars.
When I woke, my chest was tight, my breath shallow. On my desk, the newspaper lay open againâeven though I couldâve sworn I had closed it.
A small handwritten note had been tucked inside.
The ink was faded, but I could still read it:
âThe truth is not buried. Itâs waiting.â
The next day, I drove to my fatherâs old studioâa small brick building behind our house that had been locked since his death. The key still hung on a hook in my motherâs kitchen, untouched for years.
Inside, everything was exactly as heâd left it: brushes hardened with paint, easels covered with dust, the faint smell of turpentine still clinging to the air.
And then, leaning against the far wall, half-covered by a cloth, I found the painting.
When I pulled the cloth away, my breath caught in my throat.
It was her. Elena. Painted in exquisite detail, her expression caught between sorrow and fear. But it wasnât just her face that froze me.
In the background stood my fatherâhis hand on her shoulder, his eyes dark and unreadable.
And just below, hidden under the layers of brushstrokes, faint words emerged like ghosts rising from the paint:
âForgive me.â
To be continued in Episode 6 â âThe Secret in the Paint.â