08/09/2026
Where Do Spaceflight Disasters Happen?
The Kármán line, at an altitude of 100 kilometers, is widely used as a conventional boundary between Earth’s atmosphere and outer space. But when five of the best-known fatal crewed space missions are plotted on a single altitude scale, an unexpected picture emerges.
In only one case did the key fatal event occur above that boundary.
On June 30, 1971, the crew of Soyuz 11 were returning to Earth after their mission aboard Salyut 1, the world’s first space station. During module separation, at an altitude of approximately 168 km, the descent module began to depressurize. Georgy Dobrovolsky, Vladislav Volkov, and Viktor Patsayev died while the spacecraft was still in space.
All the other events shown in the infographic occurred below the Kármán line:
• Columbia broke apart during atmospheric re-entry at an altitude of approximately 63 km.
• Challenger was lost during ascent at approximately 14 km.
• The Soyuz 1 disaster ended when the descent module struck the ground.
• The Apollo 1 crew died on the launch pad during a ground test.
But this raises an important methodological question: what exactly do we mean by the altitude of a disaster?
The altitude of a technical failure, the altitude at which a spacecraft breaks apart, and the altitude at which its crew dies are not necessarily the same point.
• For Challenger, the approximately 14 km figure corresponds to the breakup of the vehicle. The crew cabin continued upward on a ballistic trajectory, reaching approximately 20 km, while the exact time and altitude of the astronauts’ deaths were never conclusively determined.
• For Columbia, approximately 63 km corresponds to the spacecraft’s main structural breakup (main hull breakup) during re-entry, rather than a precisely established altitude at which the crew died.
• For Soyuz 11, the approximately 168 km figure marks the beginning of depressurization during module separation. Unlike the other cases on this scale, the key fatal event occurred well above the 100-kilometer Kármán line — in outer space itself.
• Soyuz 1 presents a particularly revealing case. Some accounts of the disaster cite an altitude of approximately 7 km, associated with the parachute deployment sequence. But this was not the altitude at which Vladimir Komarov died. The descent module continued to fall, and Komarov was killed when it struck the Earth’s surface. This is why the infographic describes the altitude of Soyuz 1’s fatal descent as unspecified, rather than assigning it the 7 km figure.
The scale therefore does not represent an “altitude of death.” Instead, it shows the altitude of the key fatal event in each mission, where that altitude can be reliably established.
This is what makes the Kármán line particularly revealing. Of the five missions shown, Soyuz 11 is the only one whose key fatal event occurred above the 100-kilometer boundary of space.
Most of the tragedies we describe as crewed spaceflight disasters happened not in orbit, but much closer to Earth: during launch, during the return home, or before the spacecraft had even left the launch pad.
Space begins 100 kilometers above us. The risks of human spaceflight begin much earlier.