26/05/2025
𝙎𝙃𝙊𝙐𝙇𝘿 𝘾𝘼𝙏𝙃𝙊𝙇𝙄𝘾𝙎 𝙋𝘼𝙔 𝙏𝙄𝙏𝙃𝙀?
Someone brought this question to me: Is it mandatory for Catholics to pay tithe?
Now, there's something I’ve always wanted to say. I never really planned to say it, but this question came at a very interesting time, and I feel it’s the right moment.
A few days ago, someone who follows and appreciates my writings reached out to me. She said she wanted to send her tithe to me. At first, I was shocked. There's nowhere on my profile where I have written that I am a priest or a pastor. In fact, whenever people ask me if I’m a priest, I tell them outrightly that I’m not. So why would she want to give me a tithe?
I asked her why she is bringing her tithe to me when I’m not a priest.
She replied, "Must the tithe be given to a priest? I’ve developed my own way of giving. I don’t give it to the priest. I just use 10% of my income to do charity or appreciation as the spirit leads me. And now, the spirit is leading me to give it to you."
Deep within me, I didn’t want to discourage her, but I felt it was also a chance to offer her some clarity.
I told her something. I said, while what you’re doing may be commendable as an act of generosity or kindness, tithe—biblically and historically—was meant to be given to the priest.
If you feel led to help people, sponsor causes, or do charity, it should come from your regular income, not your tithe. That’s where the real sacrifice lies. But tithe, by nature and intention, was set aside for a sacred purpose and meant to be offered to the priest.
And there's a reason for that.
In the Old Testament, tithe was a divine command, and it was directed towards the Levites, who were the priests. These men lived off the tithe. That was their share because they had no inheritance of their own (cf. Numbers 18:21-24).
Giving it to them wasn’t just a donation; it was an obligation. And tied to that offering was the priestly blessing that only a consecrated person could give. I may say words of encouragement, but I cannot bless you like a priest would.
So just when I thought I had addressed this well with her, another person came with a similar question. He said their parish priest regularly preaches tithing, and then he asked me if it is actually mandatory in the Catholic Church.
Now, this is where it gets interesting. In contrast to our Protestant brothers who emphasize and even enforce tithing, the Catholic Church doesn't mandate a fixed 10% tithe. Yes, A priest may preach about it to encourage generosity and support for the Church’s mission, but the Catholic Church does not impose a percentage.
Follow me closely.
According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC 2043), the faithful are obliged to help provide for the needs of the Church according to their ability. Not a set 10%.
Also, Canon Law (Canon 222 #1) states that the faithful are obliged to assist with the Church’s needs so that divine worship, apostolic work, charity, and the decent support of ministers can continue—but again, it doesn't specify a tithe amount.
Are you still with me?
That is why you will hardly see Catholic parishes enforcing tithe like in some Protestant circles. What we have is an encouragement to give, based on your means, and in freedom—not out of compulsion.
So when people quote Malachi 3:10 to support tithe, yes, it's valid in its context. But in the Catholic understanding, the New Covenant prioritizes a generous heart over percentages. St. Paul says, "Each one must give as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver" (2 Corinthians 9:7).
In summary, Catholics are encouraged to support the Church, but not by a mandatory percentage. If someone chooses to give 10%, it is praiseworthy, but not obligatory. What matters is the spirit in which it is given.
So whether you’re giving directly to the Church, supporting a ministry, or helping someone in need, let it come from a heart that is free and generous.
And if you're still wondering what happened with the woman who sent me her tithe—I thanked her, prayed with her, and told her again: "I'm not a priest. But may God bless your generosity."
Thank you for reading to the end.
If you love Catholic content— news, reflections, stories, saints’ lives, doctrinal teachings, and real-life lessons—feel free to follow my profile James Terna. You’ll always find something that speaks to you.